乳腺癌筛查中的双读片:CO-OPS试验的队列评估
该回顾性分析从33家英格兰乳腺筛查中心提取1年常规数据,评估805206名女性在数字乳腺X线双读片加仲裁机制下的召回率与癌症检出情况。双读片后经仲裁使总召回率降至4.08%,低于首读的4.76%;7055例检出癌症中627例(8.89%)仅由第二读片者发现,这些癌更多为导管原位癌、更小、淋巴结受累更少且分级更低。
要点
- 双读片经仲裁后召回率4.08%,低于单读的4.76%(P<.001)。
- 7055例癌症中627例(8.89%)仅由第二读片者检出(P<.001)。
- 第二读片者额外检出的癌症更多为导管原位癌,浸润癌更小、淋巴结受累更少、分级更低。
核心结论
- 与单读相比,双读片加仲裁可降低召回率并提高癌症检出;仅由第二读片者检出的癌症更小、分级更低且淋巴结受累更少。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析,从33家英格兰乳腺筛查中心提取1年常规数据,纳入805206名女性,评估数字乳腺X线双读片(读片不一致时进行仲裁)对召回率、癌症检出及检出癌症特征的影响;统计方法包括比例相等检验、χ2独立性检验和t检验。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 首读召回率4.76%(38295/805206;95%CI: 4.71%, 4.80%)。
- 双读片总召回率6.19%(49857/805206;95%CI: 6.14%, 6.24%),经仲裁降至4.08%(32863/805206;95%CI: 4.04%, 4.12%;P<.001)。
- 共检出7055例癌症,其中627例(8.89%;95%CI: 8.22%, 9.55%;P<.001)仅由第二读片者检出。
- 仅第二读片者检出的癌症中导管原位癌占30.5%(183/600),其他读片检出者占22.0%(1344/6114)(P<.001)。
- 仅第二读片者检出的浸润癌平均大小14.2 mm,其他读片检出者为16.7 mm(P<.001);前者淋巴结受累更少、分级更低。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Purpose To investigate the effect of double readings by a second radiologist on recall rates, cancer detection, and characteristics of cancers detected in the National Health Service Breast Screening Program in England. Materials and Methods In this retrospective analysis, 805 206 women were evaluated through screening and diagnostic test results by extracting 1 year of routine data from 33 English breast screening centers. Centers used double reading of digital mammograms, with arbitration if there were discrepant interpretations. Information on reader decisions, with results of follow-up tests, were used to explore the effect of the second reader. The statistical tests used were the test for equality of proportions, the χ2 test for independence, and the t test. Results The first reader recalled 4.76% of women (38 295 of 805 206 women; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 4.71%, 4.80%). Two readers recalled 6.19% of women in total (49 857 of 805 206 women; 95% CI: 6.14%, 6.24%), but arbitration of discordant readings reduced the recall rate to 4.08% (32 863 of 805 206 women; 95% CI: 4.04%, 4.12%; P < .001). A total of 7055 cancers were detected, of which 627 (8.89%; 95% CI: 8.22%, 9.55%; P < .001) were detected by the second reader only. These additional cancers were more likely to be ductal carcinoma in situ (30.5% [183 of 600] vs 22.0% [1344 of 6114]; P < .001), and additional invasive cancers were smaller (mean size, 14.2 vs 16.7 mm; P < .001), had fewer involved nodes, and were likely to be lower grade. Conclusion Double reading with arbitration reduces recall and increases cancer detection compared with single reading. Cancers detected only by the second reader were smaller, of lower grade, and had less nodal involvement. © RSNA, 2018.
引用
- Taylor-Phillips S, Jenkinson D, Stinton C, et al. Double Reading in Breast Cancer Screening: Cohort Evaluation in the CO-OPS Trial. Radiology. 2018. PMID: 29634439. doi:10.1148/radiol.2018171010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。