文献速递腹部泌尿生殖CTMR

多机构分析评估不确定肾肿块的CT和MRI报告:与国家调查所期望报告要素的比较

Multi-institutional analysis of CT and MRI reports evaluating indeterminate renal masses: comparison to a national survey investigating desired report elements.
PubMed 文献 · Abdom Radiol (NY) · 2018-01-01

该多机构质量改进项目分析了美国6家社区和6家学术机构的319份CT和MRI肾肿块报告,并与已发表的国家调查中放射科医生和泌尿科医生期望的报告要素进行比较。结果显示,许多被认为必要或首选的报告要素经常被省略,学术机构更常包含肿块特征细节、恶性概率和分期,社区机构更常包含管理建议,提示标准化模板可能减少这些不一致。

要点

  • 必要要素中,实性肿块脂肪存在与否仅14%(34/236)报告,囊性肿块Bosniak分类仅54%(19/35)报告。
  • 学术机构比社区机构更常包含肿块特征细节、恶性概率和分期(差异显著)。
  • 社区机构比学术机构更常包含管理建议(差异显著)。

核心结论

  • 被认为必要或首选的肾肿块报告要素在放射科报告中经常被省略,不同放射科医生和实践环境之间存在差异,标准化模板可能减少这些不一致。

研究设计与样本

  • 多机构HIPAA合规的质量改进项目,宿主IRB豁免监管 oversight,分析美国6家社区实践(中位17份报告/站点)和6家学术实践(中位23份报告/站点)的CT和MRI报告,并与来自9家机构的学术放射科医生和泌尿科医生所述偏好的已发表国家调查进行比较。
  • 共分析319份报告,其中85%(271份;192份CT,79份MRI)报告了可能恶性的肿块(236个实性,35个囊性)。
  • 使用描述性统计和卡方检验进行数据分析。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 肿块大小报告率为99%(269/271),肿块类型(实性 vs. 囊性)报告率为99%(268/271),强化存在与否报告率为92%(248/271)。
  • 实性肿块中脂肪存在或缺失的报告率为14%(34/236),可获取时大小比较的报告率为79%(111/140),囊性肿块Bosniak分类的报告率为54%(19/35)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 学术实践比社区实践显著更可能包含肿块特征细节、恶性概率和分期。
  • 社区实践比学术实践显著更可能包含管理建议。
  • 局部治疗候选者的肾病测量评分通常未包含(12%[30/257])。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: To determine the need for a standardized renal mass reporting template by analyzing reports of indeterminate renal masses and comparing their contents to stated preferences of radiologists and urologists.

METHODS: The host IRB waived regulatory oversight for this multi-institutional HIPAA-compliant quality improvement effort. CT and MRI reports created to characterize an indeterminate renal mass were analyzed from 6 community (median: 17 reports/site) and 6 academic (median: 23 reports/site) United States practices. Report contents were compared to a published national survey of stated preferences by academic radiologists and urologists from 9 institutions. Descriptive statistics and Chi-square tests were calculated.

RESULTS: Of 319 reports, 85% (271; 192 CT, 79 MRI) reported a possibly malignant mass (236 solid, 35 cystic). Some essential elements were commonly described: size (99% [269/271]), mass type (solid vs. cystic; 99% [268/271]), enhancement (presence vs. absence; 92% [248/271]). Other essential elements had incomplete penetrance: the presence or absence of fat in solid masses (14% [34/236]), size comparisons when available (79% [111/140]), Bosniak classification for cystic masses (54% [19/35]). Preferred but non-essential elements generally were described in less than half of reports. Nephrometry scores usually were not included for local therapy candidates (12% [30/257]). Academic practices were significantly more likely than community practices to include mass characterization details, probability of malignancy, and staging. Community practices were significantly more likely to include management recommendations.

CONCLUSIONS: Renal mass reporting elements considered essential or preferred often are omitted in radiology reports. Variation exists across radiologists and practice settings. A standardized template may mitigate these inconsistencies.

来源:Abdom Radiol (NY),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hu EM, Zhang A, Silverman SG, et al. Multi-institutional analysis of CT and MRI reports evaluating indeterminate renal masses: comparison to a national survey investigating desired report elements. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2018. PMID: 29666953. doi:10.1007/s00261-018-1609-x

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。