在B型超声基础上增加M型超声能否提高创伤性气胸中肺滑动征识别准确性
研究将140名急诊医师随机分组,分别仅用B型超声或B型加M型超声判读肺滑动征,比较诊断气胸的敏感度、特异度和准确率。总体B型加M型超声特异度较高但准确率较低;在超声检查总数少于250次的医师中,M型超声提高准确率和特异度,而超过250次者无显著差异。
要点
- 在经验较少(<250次超声检查)的医师中,M型超声将肺滑动征诊断准确率从88.2%提高至94.4%,特异度从87.0%提高至97.2%。
- 总体而言,B型加M型超声与单纯B型超声的敏感度无显著差异(93.1% vs 93.2%,P=0.8)。
- 总体B型加M型超声特异度较高(96.0% vs 89.8%,P<0.0001)但准确率较低(91.5% vs 94.5%,P=0.0091)。
核心结论
- 在B型超声基础上增加M型超声有助于急诊医师准确诊断肺滑动征,但在急诊医师完成超过250次超声检查后该获益消失。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照研究,140名急诊医师通过在线软件随机分组,分别接受仅含B型超声片段或B型加对应M型图像的测验,要求识别肺滑动存在与否。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 总体B型加M型超声 vs 单纯B型超声:敏感度93.1% vs 93.2%(P=0.8),特异度96.0% vs 89.8%(P<0.0001),准确率91.5% vs 94.5%(P=0.0091),对象为判读肺滑动征的急诊医师。
- 超声检查总数少于250次的医师:B型加M型超声 vs 单纯B型超声准确率94.4%(95%CI 92.8%-96.0%)vs 88.2%(95%CI 86.2%-90.2%)(P=0.001),特异度97.2%(95%CI 95.4%-99.0%)vs 87.0%(95%CI 84.5%-89.5%)(P<0.0001)。
- 超声检查总数超过250次的医师:B型加M型超声与单纯B型超声在敏感度、特异度和准确率上无统计学显著差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: It is unknown whether the addition of M-mode to B-mode ultrasound (US) has any effect on the overall accuracy of interpretation of lung sliding in the evaluation of a pneumothorax by emergency physicians. This study aimed to determine what effect, if any, this addition has on US interpretation by emergency physicians of varying training levels.
METHODS: One hundred forty emergency physicians were randomized via online software to receive a quiz with B-mode clips alone or B-mode with corresponding M-mode images and asked to identify the presence or absence of lung sliding.
RESULTS: The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of the diagnosis of lung sliding with and without M-mode US were compared. Overall, the sensitivities, specificities, and accuracies of B-mode + M-mode US versus B-mode US alone were 93.1% and 93.2% (P = .8), 96.0% and 89.8% (P < .0001), and 91.5% and 94.5% (P = .0091), respectively. A subgroup analysis showed that in those providers with fewer than 250 total US scans done previously, M-mode US increased accuracy from 88.2% (95% confidence interval, 86.2%-90.2%) to 94.4% (92.8%-96.0%; P = .001) and increased the specificity from 87.0% (84.5%-89.5%) to 97.2% (95.4%-99.0%; P < .0001) compared with B-mode US alone. There was no statistically significant difference observed in the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of B-mode + M-mode US compared with B-mode US alone in those with more than 250 scans.
CONCLUSIONS: The addition of M-mode images to B-mode clips aids in the accurate diagnosis of lung sliding by emergency physicians. The subgroup analysis showed that the benefit of M-mode US disappears after emergency physicians have performed more than 250 US examinations.
引用
- Avila J, Smith B, Mead T, et al. Does the Addition of M-Mode to B-Mode Ultrasound Increase the Accuracy of Identification of Lung Sliding in Traumatic Pneumothoraces? J Ultrasound Med. 2018. PMID: 29689594. doi:10.1002/jum.14629
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。