专家对机械通气患者肺超声检查解读的一致性研究
本研究让6名专家在无临床背景的情况下解读10名新手对机械通气ICU患者所做的150例肺超声检查,判断气胸、间质综合征、实变、肺不张或胸腔积液是否存在。专家一致率取决于定义方式,严格定义为51%,宽松定义为57%;剔除肺实变病例后一致率分别提高至69%和86%。作者认为ICU患者常合并多种肺部损伤,使肺超声确定主要肺部病变的效用可能低于急诊呼吸困难患者。
要点
- 专家间一致率严格定义51%、宽松定义57%,剔除肺实变病例后升至69%和86%。
- 肺实变是专家意见分歧最常见的来源。
- ICU患者常合并多种肺部损伤,使具体原发诊断的一致判断具有挑战性。
核心结论
- 专家一致率低于预期;作者认为ICU患者常合并多种肺部损伤,使肺超声识别主要肺部病变的效用可能低于急诊呼吸困难患者,并提示临床背景对肺超声可能比其他影像方式更重要。
研究设计与样本
- 让6名专家在无临床背景的情况下解读此前研究中10名新手对机械通气ICU患者所做的150例肺超声检查,判断气胸、间质综合征、实变、肺不张或胸腔积液是否存在。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 严格定义下专家一致率为51%,宽松定义下为57%。
- 剔除肺实变病例后,严格定义下一致率提高至69%,宽松定义下提高至86%。
局限性
- 作者指出本研究一致率低于预期,并分析可能原因,其中最主要的是ICU患者常合并多种肺部损伤,使具体原发诊断的一致判断具有挑战性。
- 作者提出肺超声在ICU患者中识别主要肺部病变的效用可能低于急诊呼吸困难患者。
- 作者提出临床背景对肺超声可能比其他影像方式更重要。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Although lung ultrasound (US) has been shown to have high diagnostic accuracy in patients presenting with acute dyspnea, its precision in critically ill patients is unknown. We investigated common areas of agreement and disagreement by studying 6 experts as they interpreted lung US studies in a cohort of intensive care unit (ICU) patients.
METHODS: A previous study by our group asked experts to rate the quality of 150 lung US studies performed by 10 novices in a population of mechanically ventilated patients. For this study, experts were asked to interpret them without the clinical context, reporting the presence of pneumothorax, interstitial syndrome, consolidation, atelectasis, or pleural effusion.
RESULTS: The rate of expert agreement depended on how it was defined, ranging from 51% (with a strict definition of agreement) to 57% (with a more liberal definition). Removing cases involving lung consolidation (the most common source of disagreement) improved the rates of agreement to 69% and 86%, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: The frequency of agreement was lower than might have been expected in this study. Several potential reasons are identified, chief among them the fact that ICU patients often develop multiple pulmonary insults, making agreement on a specific primary diagnosis challenging. This finding suggests that the utility of lung US in identifying the main contributing lung condition in ICU patients may be lower than in dyspneic patients encountered in the emergency department. It also raises the possibility that the clinical context is more important for lung US than other imaging modalities.
引用
- Millington SJ, Arntfield RT, Guo RJ, et al. Expert Agreement in the Interpretation of Lung Ultrasound Studies Performed on Mechanically Ventilated Patients. J Ultrasound Med. 2018. PMID: 29656607. doi:10.1002/jum.14627
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。