儿童三维旋转神经血管造影与二维数字减影血管造影的辐射剂量测定
该研究在24例复杂神经血管病变患儿中评估了33次三维旋转血管造影的有效剂量,并与二维双平面数字减影血管造影直接比较;定制减影与未减影三维方案的平均有效剂量分别为0.12和0.06 mSv,低于二维双平面数字减影血管造影的0.9 mSv,而厂家减影方案为0.5 mSv。
要点
- 定制减影三维旋转血管造影平均有效剂量0.12 mSv,低于二维双平面数字减影血管造影的0.9 mSv。
- 定制未减影三维旋转血管造影平均有效剂量0.06 mSv,为所有方案中最低。
- 厂家减影三维旋转血管造影平均有效剂量0.5 mSv,仍低于二维双平面数字减影血管造影的0.9 mSv。
核心结论
- 在儿童神经血管造影中,三维旋转血管造影的有效剂量可显著低于二维双平面数字减影血管造影,可作为评估神经血管病变的重要辅助手段。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入24例患儿(平均年龄10.4岁),共采集33次三维旋转血管造影,均在临床需要时于二维双平面数字减影血管造影后进行,采用3种技术方案(2种减影、1种未减影,含1种厂家方案和2种定制方案),图像重建为CT容积用于临床管理,并评估原始投影和定量剂量指标、计算有效剂量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 厂家减影三维旋转血管造影方案平均有效剂量为0.5 mSv。
- 定制减影三维旋转血管造影方案平均有效剂量为0.12 mSv。
- 定制未减影三维旋转血管造影方案平均有效剂量为0.06 mSv。
- 二维双平面数字减影血管造影平均有效剂量为0.9 mSv。
- 术中直接比较显示,定制未减影和减影三维方案相对于双平面数字减影血管造影的平均相对剂量分别为9%和15%,厂家减影方案为68%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 所有三维旋转血管造影采集图像均达到诊断质量并有助于患者管理。
- 可根据临床问题调整现有三维旋转血管造影方案以优化有效性和剂量。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The benefit-risk assessment concerning radiation use in pediatric neuroangiography requires an extensive understanding of the doses delivered. This work evaluated the effective dose of 3D rotational angiography in a cohort of pediatric patients with complex neurovascular lesions and directly compared it with conventional 2D-biplane DSA.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Thirty-three 3D rotational angiography acquisitions were acquired in 24 pediatric patients (mean age, 10.4 years). When clinically indicated, following 2D-biplane DSA, 3D rotational angiography was performed with 1 of 3 technical protocols (2 subtracted, 1 unsubtracted). The protocols consisted of 1 factory and 2 customized techniques, with images subsequently reconstructed into CT volumes for clinical management. Raw projections and quantitative dose metrics were evaluated, and the effective dose was calculated.
RESULTS: All 3D rotational angiography acquisitions were of diagnostic quality and assisted in patient management. The mean effective doses were 0.5, 0.12, and 0.06 mSv for the factory-subtracted, customized-subtracted, and customized-unsubtracted protocols, respectively. The mean effective dose for 2D-biplane DSA was 0.9 mSv. A direct intraprocedural comparison between 3D and 2D acquisitions indicated that customized 3D rotational angiography protocols delivered mean relative doses of 9% and 15% in unsubtracted and subtracted acquisitions, respectively, compared with biplane DSA, whereas the factory subtracted protocol delivered 68%.
CONCLUSIONS: In pediatric neuroangiography, the effective dose for 3D rotational angiography can be significantly lower than for 2D-biplane DSA and can be an essential adjunct in the evaluation of neurovascular lesions. Additionally, available 3D rotational angiography protocols have significant room to be tailored for effectiveness and dose optimization, depending on the clinical question.
引用
- Shkumat NA, Shroff MM, Muthusami P, et al. Radiation Dosimetry of 3D Rotational Neuroangiography and 2D-DSA in Children. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2018. PMID: 29496725. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A5568
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。