以手术为参考标准评估肩关节磁共振关节造影对盂唇撕裂的诊断效能:高分辨率各向同性三维序列(THRIVE)与标准方案的比较
本研究以关节镜所见为参考标准,回顾性分析84例接受直接肩关节3T磁共振关节造影的患者,比较T1高分辨率各向同性容积激发序列(THRIVE)与二维三平面质子密度脂肪抑制序列(2D-PD-FS)对SLAP损伤和Bankart损伤的诊断效能。THRIVE序列的对比噪声比及主观图像噪声、锐利度评分均显著优于2D-PD-FS,诊断效能与2D-PD-FS相似,且扫描时间缩短69%。作者认为THRIVE序列可能有助于SLAP和Bankart损伤的诊断,并可能常规用于直接肩关节3T磁共振关节造影。
要点
- THRIVE序列诊断SLAP和Bankart损伤的敏感度93.0-97.2%、特异度95.8-100%、准确率95.2-97.6%,与2D-PD-FS相似。
- THRIVE序列对比噪声比显著高于2D-PD-FS(p<0.001),主观图像噪声(p=0.009)和锐利度(p=0.039)评分也显著更优。
- THRIVE序列扫描时间较2D-PD-FS缩短69%(2分40秒 vs. 8分40秒)。
核心结论
- THRIVE序列可能有助于SLAP和Bankart损伤的诊断,并可能常规用于直接肩关节3T磁共振关节造影。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究纳入84例患者,均接受直接肩关节3T磁共振关节造影,采用THRIVE序列和二维三平面质子密度脂肪抑制(2D-PD-FS)序列;以关节镜手术所见为参考标准,由一名评价者评估对比噪声比,另两名评价者独立评估主观图像噪声、图像锐利度和影像诊断。
关键影像表现/征象
- THRIVE序列的对比噪声比显著高于2D-PD-FS序列(p<0.001)。
- THRIVE序列的主观图像噪声评分显著优于2D-PD-FS序列(p=0.009)。
- THRIVE序列的主观图像锐利度评分显著优于2D-PD-FS序列(p=0.039)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- THRIVE序列诊断SLAP和Bankart损伤的敏感度93.0-97.2%、特异度95.8-100%、准确率95.2-97.6%。
- 2D-PD-FS序列诊断SLAP和Bankart损伤的敏感度86.1-91.7%、特异度93.8-95.8%、准确率90.5-92.9%。
- THRIVE与2D-PD-FS诊断SLAP和Bankart损伤的效能差异无统计学意义(p≥0.18)。
- THRIVE序列的观察者间一致性ICC=0.898-0.942,2D-PD-FS序列的ICC=0.782-0.858。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为THRIVE序列可能有助于SLAP和Bankart损伤的诊断,并可能常规用于直接肩关节3T磁共振关节造影。
- THRIVE序列扫描时间为2分40秒,2D-PD-FS序列为8分40秒,THRIVE较2D-PD-FS缩短69%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To compare the diagnostic performance of T1 high-resolution isotropic volume excitation (THRIVE) sequence with that of a standard protocol for direct shoulder magnetic resonance arthrography (MRA) for the diagnosis of superior labral anterior-to-posterior (SLAP) and Bankart lesions, using arthroscopy findings as a reference standard.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We retrospectively studied 84 patients who underwent direct shoulder 3T MRA using THRIVE and two-dimensional three-plane proton-density fat-suppressed (2D-PD-FS) sequences. One reviewer evaluated the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) as a quantitative image quality. Other two reviewers independently evaluated the subjective image noise, image sharpness, and radiologic diagnosis as qualitative image quality. Arthroscopic surgical findings were considered the reference standard. Wilcoxon rank sum, Chi-square/Fisher's exact, and DeLong's tests, as well as intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were used to evaluate differences between THRIVE and 2D-PD-FS images.
RESULTS: THRIVE images had significantly higher CNR (p < 0.001), and subjective ratings of image noise (p = 0.009) and sharpness (p = 0.039) than 2D-PD-FS images (p < 0.001). THRIVE images had similar (p ≥ 0.18) diagnostic performance (sensitivity, 93.0-97.2%; specificity, 95.8-100%; accuracy, 95.2-97.6%) for the diagnosis of SLAP and Bankart lesions with excellent agreement (ICC = 0.898-0.942) when compared to 2D-PD-FS images (sensitivity, 86.1-91.7%; specificity, 93.8-95.8%; accuracy, 90.5-92.9%; agreement, ICC = 0.782-0.858). The scan time was reduced by 69% for THRIVE sequence compared to 2D-PD-FS sequence (2 min 40 s vs. 8 min 40 s).
CONCLUSION: The THRIVE sequence may be helpful in the diagnosis of SLAP and Bankart lesions, and may be routinely used during direct shoulder 3T MRA.
引用
- Lee SH, Yun SJ, Yoon Y, et al. Diagnostic performance of shoulder magnetic resonance arthrography for labral tears having surgery as reference: comparison of high-resolution isotropic 3D sequence (THRIVE) with standard protocol. Radiol Med. 2018. PMID: 29582321. doi:10.1007/s11547-018-0879-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。