有无乳腺筛查国家间乳腺癌诊断的观察者变异性
研究比较无乳腺筛查国家(NS)与非筛查国放射科医生在典型筛查(TS)和高难度(HD)乳腺X线测试集上的阅片效能,NS医生11名,筛查国医生分别52名和49名阅读TS和HD集。结果显示三组在病例敏感度、特异度、位置敏感度、AUC和JAFROC上存在显著差异,NS医生所有测量评分显著低于经验丰富(ME)组,仅位置敏感度低于经验较少(LE)组。结论认为筛查国与非筛查国放射科医生乳腺X线阅片效能存在较大差异。
要点
- 无筛查国(NS)医生乳腺X线阅片各评分显著低于筛查国经验丰富(ME)医生。
- NS医生仅位置敏感度显著低于筛查国经验较少(LE)医生,其余评分无显著差异。
- 三组医生在病例敏感度、特异度、位置敏感度、AUC和JAFROC上均存在显著差异。
核心结论
- 筛查国与非筛查国放射科医生乳腺X线阅片效能存在较大差异。
研究设计与样本
- 使用典型筛查(TS)和高难度(HD)两套乳腺X线测试集;无筛查国(NS)放射科医生11名阅读两套测试集,筛查国放射科医生分别52名和49名阅读TS和HD测试集;筛查国医生分为经验≤5年的经验较少(LE)组和经验≥5年的经验丰富(ME)组;采用Kruskal-Wallis检验和Tukey-Kramer事后检验比较组间阅片效能,Wilcoxon配对检验比较NS医生在TS与HD测试集间的表现。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 三组间病例敏感度差异显著(χ2[2]=9.4,P=.008)。
- 三组间特异度差异显著(χ2[2]=10.3,P=.006)。
- 三组间位置敏感度差异显著(χ2[2]=19.8,P<.001)。
- 三组间ROC曲线下面积(AUC)差异显著(χ2[2]=19.7,P<.001)。
- 三组间JAFROC差异显著(χ2[2]=18.1,P<.001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONAL AND OBJECTIVES: Image reporting is a vital component of patient management depending on individual radiologists' performance. Our objective was to explore mammographic diagnostic efficacy in a country where breast cancer screening does not exist.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two mammographic test sets were used: a typical screening (TS) and high-difficulty (HD) test set. Nonscreening (NS) radiologists (n = 11) read both test sets, while 52 and 49 screening radiologists read the TS and HD test sets, respectively. The screening radiologists were classified into two groups: a less experienced (LE) group with ≤5 years' experience and a more experienced (ME) group with ≥5 years' experience. A Kruskal-Wallis and Tukey-Kramer post hoc test were used to compare reading performance among reader groups, and the Wilcoxon matched pairs tests was used to compare TS and ND test sets for the NS radiologists.
RESULTS: Across the three reader groups, there were significant differences in case sensitivity (χ2 [2] = 9.4, P = .008), specificity (χ2 [2] = 10.3, P = .006), location sensitivity (χ2 [2] = 19.8, P < .001), receiver operating characteristics, area under the curve (χ2 [2] = 19.7, P < .001) and jack-knife free-response receiver operating characteristics (JAFROCs) (χ2 [2] = 18.1, P < .001). NS performance for all measured scores was significantly lower than those for the ME readers (P < .006), while only location sensitivity was lower (χ2 [2] = 17.5, P = .026) for the NS compared to the LE group. No other significant differences were observed.
CONCLUSION: Large variations in mammographic performance exist between radiologists from screening and nonscreening countries.
引用
- Demchig D, Mello-Thoms C, Lee W, et al. Observer Variability in Breast Cancer Diagnosis between Countries with and without Breast Screening. Acad Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29580792. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2018.03.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。