近期胸痛患者影像决策中NICE临床指南所实施验前概率计算的适用性与准确性
本研究比较了Duke临床评分与NICE指南95版在验前概率计算定义上的差异,并基于CoMe-CCT协作网4673例个体患者数据分析一致性与管理分组。结果显示指南定义存在歧义,仅30.8%(1439/4673)患者可完成验前概率计算,两种模型管理分组一致率仅70%(366/523)。作者认为NICE指南所实施的验前概率计算存在相关局限性。
要点
- NICE指南95版对年龄和危险因素数目的定义与Duke临床评分存在重大差异,Duke评分未被正确实施。
- 尽管所需数据齐全,仅30.8%(1439/4673)患者可按指南标准完成验前概率计算。
- 两种模型均可计算的患者中,管理分组一致率仅70%(366/523)。
核心结论
- 作者认为,NICE临床指南中用于心脏影像临床决策的验前概率计算存在相关局限性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究比较了原始Duke临床评分与NICE指南95版中验前概率计算的定义,并基于心脏CT协作荟萃分析(CoMe-CCT)的个体患者数据计算验前概率及影像和管理分组的一致性。
- 共分析CoMe-CCT协作网4673例个体患者数据。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 按指南标准进行验前概率计算仅对30.8%(1439/4673)患者可行,尽管所有所需数据均可获得。
- 两种模型均可计算验前概率的患者中,管理分组一致率为70%(366/523)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出NICE指南95版对危险因素和年龄组的定义存在歧义,导致多数患者无法完成验前概率计算。
- 原文指出Duke临床评分在NICE指南95版中未被正确实施。
- 原文结论认为需改进验前概率计算以实现准确的临床决策,这些改进对心脏CT的合理使用至关重要。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To analyse the implementation, applicability and accuracy of the pretest probability calculation provided by NICE clinical guideline 95 for decision making about imaging in patients with chest pain of recent onset.
METHODS: The definitions for pretest probability calculation in the original Duke clinical score and the NICE guideline were compared. We also calculated the agreement and disagreement in pretest probability and the resulting imaging and management groups based on individual patient data from the Collaborative Meta-Analysis of Cardiac CT (CoMe-CCT).
RESULTS: 4,673 individual patient data from the CoMe-CCT Consortium were analysed. Major differences in definitions in the Duke clinical score and NICE guideline were found for the predictors age and number of risk factors. Pretest probability calculation using guideline criteria was only possible for 30.8 % (1,439/4,673) of patients despite availability of all required data due to ambiguity in guideline definitions for risk factors and age groups. Agreement regarding patient management groups was found in only 70 % (366/523) of patients in whom pretest probability calculation was possible according to both models.
CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that pretest probability calculation for clinical decision making about cardiac imaging as implemented in the NICE clinical guideline for patients has relevant limitations.
KEY POINTS: • Duke clinical score is not implemented correctly in NICE guideline 95. • Pretest probability assessment in NICE guideline 95 is impossible for most patients. • Improved clinical decision making requires accurate pretest probability calculation. • These refinements are essential for appropriate use of cardiac CT.
引用
- Roehle R, Wieske V, Schuetz GM, et al. Applicability and accuracy of pretest probability calculations implemented in the NICE clinical guideline for decision making about imaging in patients with chest pain of recent onset. Eur Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29556770. doi:10.1007/s00330-018-5322-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。