胸部体层摄影图像质量对采集协议与图像处理的依赖性:基于临床数据的视觉分级研究
研究对20例疑似肺癌患者行胸部数字体层摄影,比较6.3秒与12秒两种采集协议及两种后处理方式的图像质量,5名观察者按预设标准分级并用VGC分析。结果显示6.3秒协议在轮廓与干扰标准上优于厂商推荐的12秒协议,标准DTS后处理在轮廓与干扰标准上优于更高级后处理。
要点
- 6.3秒采集协议在轮廓(AUCVGC=0.56,p=0.009)与干扰(AUCVGC=0.58,p<0.001)标准上优于12秒协议。
- 标准DTS后处理在轮廓(AUCVGC=0.45,p=0.017)与干扰(AUCVGC=0.43,p=0.005)标准上优于更高级后处理。
- 结构标准(脊柱骨结构定义)在两种比较中AUCVGC均为0.56或0.46,均未能与0.5做统计学分离(p=0.21或p=0.31)。
核心结论
- 6.3秒采集协议在多个解剖结构上图像质量略优于厂商推荐的12秒协议;标准DTS后处理在全部标准类别上图像质量在一定程度上优于高级后处理。
研究设计与样本
- 对20例疑似肺癌患者使用带体层摄影选项的胸部X线设备,每位患者行6.3秒与12秒两种采集协议,每种协议分别采用标准DTS处理和针对胸部摄影优化的更高级处理,共80组序列匿名随机呈现,5名观察者按预设质量标准的三个类别分级,以VGC分析,AUCVGC为品质因数,以12秒协议和标准DTS处理为参考。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以12秒协议为参考时,6.3秒协议轮廓标准AUCVGC=0.56(p=0.009)、干扰标准AUCVGC=0.58(p<0.001)、结构标准AUCVGC=0.56(p=0.21)。以标准DTS处理为参考时,更高级处理轮廓标准AUCVGC=0.45(p=0.017)、干扰标准AUCVGC=0.43(p=0.005)、结构标准AUCVGC=0.46(p=0.31)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare the quality of images obtained with two different protocols with different acquisition time and the influence from image post processing in a chest digital tomosynthesis (DTS) system.
METHODS: 20 patients with suspected lung cancer were imaged with a chest X-ray equipment with tomosynthesis option. Two examination protocols with different acquisition times (6.3 and 12 s) were performed on each patient. Both protocols were presented with two different image post-processing (standard DTS processing and more advanced processing optimised for chest radiography). Thus, 4 series from each patient, altogether 80 series, were presented anonymously and in a random order. Five observers rated the quality of the reconstructed section images according to predefined quality criteria in three different classes. Visual grading characteristics (VGC) was used to analyse the data and the area under the VGC curve (AUCVGC) was used as figure-of-merit. The 12 s protocol and the standard DTS processing were used as references in the analyses.
RESULTS: The protocol with 6.3 s acquisition time had a statistically significant advantage over the vendor-recommended protocol with 12 s acquisition time for the classes of criteria, Demarcation (AUCVGC = 0.56, p = 0.009) and Disturbance (AUCVGC = 0.58, p < 0.001). A similar value of AUCVGC was found also for the class Structure (definition of bone structures in the spine) (0.56) but it could not be statistically separated from 0.5 (p = 0.21). For the image processing, the VGC analysis showed a small but statistically significant advantage for the standard DTS processing over the more advanced processing for the classes of criteria Demarcation (AUCVGC = 0.45, p = 0.017) and Disturbance (AUCVGC = 0.43, p = 0.005). A similar value of AUCVGC was found also for the class Structure (0.46), but it could not be statistically separated from 0.5 (p = 0.31).
CONCLUSION: The study indicates that the protocol with 6.3 s acquisition time yields slightly better image quality than the vender-recommended protocol with acquisition time 12 s for several anatomical structures. Furthermore, the standard gradation processing (the vendor-recommended post-processing for DTS), yields to some extent advantage over the gradation processing/multiobjective frequency processing/flexible noise control processing in terms of image quality for all classes of criteria. Advances in knowledge: The study proves that the image quality may be strongly affected by the selection of DTS protocol and that the vendor-recommended protocol may not always be the optimal choice.
引用
- Jadidi M, Båth M, Nyrén S, et al. Dependency of image quality on acquisition protocol and image processing in chest tomosynthesis-a visual grading study based on clinical data. Br J Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29565673. doi:10.1259/bjr.20170683
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。