定量计算机断层扫描在间质性肺疾病中的应用
研究利用220例受试者(正常71例、肺气肿73例、纤维化76例)的CT密度直方图,比较传统指标(肺气肿指数、第15百分位值、均值、方差、偏度、峰度)与新直方图函数形状(HFS)方法的分类性能。多分类逻辑回归显示所有方法联合时分类效能最高(总体正确分配率92%,敏感度0.95,特异度0.89,Nagelkerke伪R² 0.95);单一方法中HFS分类效能最高(总体正确分配率86%,敏感度0.93,特异度0.79,Nagelkerke伪R² 0.80)。结论认为HFS方法也可从肺密度直方图中提取有价值信息。
要点
- 所有直方图分析方法联合时分类效能最高:总体正确分配率92%、敏感度0.95、特异度0.89。
- 单一方法中HFS分类效能最高:总体正确分配率86%、敏感度0.93、特异度0.79。
- 传统指标单独应用分类效能较低,如肺气肿指数总体正确分配率69%、特异度0.26。
核心结论
- HFS方法此前用于CT骨密度曲线分析,也是肺密度直方图的显著信息提取工具。
- 据推测,作为一种数学原理方法,HFS也可从完全不同领域的直方图中提取有价值的健康相关信息。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为方法学比较研究,使用220例不同受试者的CT密度直方图。
- 受试者分为正常组71例、肺气肿组73例、纤维化组76例。
- 比较传统指标(肺气肿指数、第15百分位值、均值、方差、偏度、峰度)与新HFS方法。
- 采用多分类逻辑回归分析,以各方法单独或联合作为协变量预测肺实质分组。
- 估计总体正确分配受试者、敏感度、特异度和Nagelkerke伪R²效应量,并用伪R²建立方法排名。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 所有直方图分析方法联合时:总体正确分配率92%,敏感度0.95,特异度0.89,Nagelkerke伪R² 0.95。
- HFS单独应用:总体正确分配率86%,敏感度0.93,特异度0.79,Nagelkerke伪R² 0.80。
- 肺气肿指数单独应用:总体正确分配率69%,敏感度0.95,特异度0.26,Nagelkerke伪R² 0.52。
- 第15百分位值单独应用:总体正确分配率69%,敏感度0.90,特异度0.37,Nagelkerke伪R² 0.57。
- 均值、方差、偏度、峰度单独应用:总体正确分配率分别为65%、66%、65%、63%,敏感度分别为0.71、0.72、0.88、0.90,特异度分别为0.58、0.53、0.26、0.16,Nagelkerke伪R²分别为0.61、0.66、0.55、0.48。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate a new image marker that retrieves information from computed tomography (CT) density histograms, with respect to classification properties between different lung parenchyma groups. Furthermore, to conduct a comparison of the new image marker with conventional markers.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Density histograms from 220 different subjects (normal = 71; emphysema = 73; fibrotic = 76) were used to compare the conventionally applied emphysema index (EI), 15th percentile value (PV), mean value (MV), variance (V), skewness (S), kurtosis (K), with a new histogram's functional shape (HFS) method. Multinomial logistic regression (MLR) analyses was performed to calculate predictions of different lung parenchyma group membership using the individual methods, as well as combinations thereof, as covariates. Overall correct assigned subjects (OCA), sensitivity (sens), specificity (spec), and Nagelkerke's pseudo R2 (NR2) effect size were estimated. NR2 was used to set up a ranking list of the different methods.
RESULTS: MLR indicates the highest classification power (OCA of 92%; sens 0.95; spec 0.89; NR2 0.95) when all histogram analyses methods were applied together in the MLR. Highest classification power among individually applied methods was found using the HFS concept (OCA 86%; sens 0.93; spec 0.79; NR2 0.80). Conventional methods achieved lower classification potential on their own: EI (OCA 69%; sens 0.95; spec 0.26; NR2 0.52); PV (OCA 69%; sens 0.90; spec 0.37; NR2 0.57); MV (OCA 65%; sens 0.71; spec 0.58; NR2 0.61); V (OCA 66%; sens 0.72; spec 0.53; NR2 0.66); S (OCA 65%; sens 0.88; spec 0.26; NR2 0.55); and K (OCA 63%; sens 0.90; spec 0.16; NR2 0.48).
CONCLUSION: The HFS method, which was so far applied to a CT bone density curve analysis, is also a remarkable information extraction tool for lung density histograms. Presumably, being a principle mathematical approach, the HFS method can extract valuable health related information also from histograms from complete different areas.
引用
- Obert M, Kampschulte M, Limburg R, et al. Quantitative computed tomography applied to interstitial lung diseases. Eur J Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29496086. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2018.01.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。