文献速递胸部CT

肺癌筛查中亚实性结节的检测:视觉阅读与计算机辅助诊断的互补敏感性

Detection of Subsolid Nodules in Lung Cancer Screening: Complementary Sensitivity of Visual Reading and Computer-Aided Diagnosis.
PubMed 文献 · Invest Radiol · 2018-01-01

在意大利多中心肺癌检测试验的2303例基线容积低剂量CT中,前瞻性视觉检测与回顾性计算机辅助诊断(CAD)分析检出194个亚实性结节。CAD敏感度88.4%高于视觉阅读的34.2%,但CAD需视觉确认以减少假阳性;作者建议两者联合用于低剂量CT阅片。

要点

  • CAD对亚实性结节的敏感度88.4%,显著高于视觉阅读的34.2%。
  • CAD平均每扫描0.26个假阳性标记,部分实性结节阳性预测值54.4%高于非实性结节的19.4%。
  • CAD与视觉阅读性能互补,作者建议联合使用以减少任一单独方法的假阴性。

核心结论

  • CAD与视觉阅读作为并行阅片方法显示互补性能,CAD敏感度更高尤其是对部分实性结节,但需视觉确认以减少假阳性;作者建议两者联合用于低剂量CT阅片以减少任一单独方法的假阴性。

研究设计与样本

  • 在意大利多中心肺癌检测试验的2303例基线容积低剂量CT中行前瞻性视觉检测与回顾性CAD分析,CAD结果由2名经验丰富的胸部放射科医生复核,参考标准为视觉检测与CAD任一方法检出的亚实性结节累计数。

关键影像表现/征象

  • CAD检出的部分实性结节实性成分直径较手动测量更大。
  • CAD与视觉检测对亚实性结节的半自动特征(直径、体积、质量,全结节及实性成分)均无影响。
  • 基线时CAD检出4个视觉阅读首次遗漏后演变为肺癌的亚实性结节中的3个。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • CAD敏感度88.4% vs 视觉阅读34.2%(P < 0.001)。
  • CAD阴性预测值99.2% vs 视觉阅读95.5%(P < 0.001)。
  • CAD对任一面亚实性结节的阳性预测值22.5%(175/779),部分实性结节54.4%(37/68)vs 非实性结节19.4%(138/711)(P < 0.001)。
  • CAD平均每扫描假阳性标记0.26(604/2303),每受检者阳性预测值25.6%(137/536)。
  • CAD纵向3时间点敏感度87.5%(42/48)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • CAD与视觉阅读应联合用于低剂量CT阅片以减少任一单独方法的假阴性。
  • CAD对部分实性结节的敏感度优势明显,但假阳性标记需视觉确认。
  • CAD半自动测量的实性成分直径较手动测量偏大,可能使 Lung CT Screening Reporting and Data System 分类上调。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to compare computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) and visual reading for the detection of subsolid nodules (SSNs) in volumetrl measuremic low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) for lung cancer screening.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Prospective visual detection (VD) and manuaent of SSN were performed in the 2303 baseline volumetric LDCTs of the Multicenter Italian Lung Detection trial. Baseline and 2- and 4-year LDCTs underwent retrospective CAD analysis, subsequently reviewed by 2 experienced thoracic radiologists. The reference standard was defined by the cumulative number of SSNs detected by any reading method between VD and CAD. The number of false-positive CAD marks per scan (FP/scan) was calculated. The positive predictive value of CAD was quantified per nodule (PPV) and per screenee (PPV). The sensitivity and negative predictive value were compared between CAD and VD. The longitudinal 3-time-point sensitivity of CAD was calculated in the subgroup of persistent SSNs seen by VD (ratio between the prevalent SSNs detected by CAD through 3 time points and the total number of persistent prevalent SSNs detected by VD) to test the sensitivity of iterated CAD analysis during a screening program. Semiautomatic characteristics (diameter, volume, and mass; both for whole nodule and solid component) were compared between SSN detected CAD-only or VD-only to investigate whether either reading method could suffer from specific sensitivity weakness related to SSN features. Semiautomatic and manual diameters were compared using Spearman ρ correlation and Bland-Altman plot.

RESULTS: Computer-aided diagnosis and VD detected a total of 194 SSNs in 6.7% (155/2,303) of screenees at baseline LDCT. The CAD showed mean FP/scan of 0.26 (604/2,303); PPV 22.5% (175/779) for any SSN, with 54.4% (37/68) for PSN and 19.4% for NSN (138/711; P < 0.001); PPV 25.6% (137/536). The sensitivity of CAD was superior to that of VD (88.4% and 34.2%, P < 0.001), as well as negative predictive value (99.2% and 95.5%, P < 0.001). The longitudinal 3-time-point sensitivity of CAD was 87.5% (42/48). There was no influence of semiautomatic characteristics on the performance of either reading method. The diameter of the solid component in PSN was larger by CAD compared with manual measurement. At baseline, CAD detected 3 of 4 SSNs, which were first overlooked by VD and subsequently evolved to lung cancer.

CONCLUSIONS: Computer-aided diagnosis and VD as concurrent reading methods showed complementary performance, with CAD having a higher sensitivity, especially for PSN, but requiring visual confirmation to reduce false-positive calls. Computer-aided diagnosis and VD should be jointly used for LDCT reading to reduce false-negatives of either lone method. The semiautomatic measurement of solid core showed systematic shift toward a larger diameter, potentially resulting in an up-shift within Lung CT Screening Reporting and Data System classification.

来源:Invest Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Silva M, Schaefer-Prokop CM, Jacobs C, et al. Detection of Subsolid Nodules in Lung Cancer Screening: Complementary Sensitivity of Visual Reading and Computer-Aided Diagnosis. Invest Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29543693. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000000464

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。