参数设置变化下影像组学特征的稳健性与疾病鉴别能力的比较:鼻咽部PET/CT应用
本研究纳入106例病理确诊患者(鼻咽癌69例、慢性鼻咽炎37例),在FDG PET/CT图像上提取57个影像组学特征并改变参数设置,评估特征稳健性(ICC)与鉴别诊断性能(AUC)。结果显示部分绝对尺度稳健性差(ICC低至0.02-0.98)的特征仍具良好AUC(0.82-0.91);鉴别I-II期鼻咽癌与慢性鼻咽炎时,SumEntropy和SZLGE的AUC(0.91)显著高于代谢活跃肿瘤体积(0.72)(p<0.01)。结论认为不应过度强调稳健性作为特征剔除依据,部分影像组学特征优于传统指标。
要点
- 参数变化下ICC低至0.02-0.98的GLCM等特征仍可获AUC 0.82-0.91,稳健性差不等于鉴别能力差。
- 鉴别I-II期鼻咽癌与慢性鼻咽炎时,SumEntropy和SZLGE的AUC为0.91,高于代谢活跃肿瘤体积的0.72(p<0.01)。
- SumEntropy、SZLGE、LGZE等影像组学特征鉴别鼻咽癌与慢性鼻咽炎优于传统指标。
核心结论
- 影像组学特征绝对尺度稳健性差仍可能具有良好诊断性能,不应过度强调稳健性作为特征剔除依据;SumEntropy、SZLGE、LGZE等特征鉴别鼻咽癌与慢性鼻咽炎优于传统指标。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入106例病理确诊患者(鼻咽癌69例、慢性鼻咽炎37例),在FDG PET/CT图像上提取57个影像组学特征,改变参数设置评估稳健性(ICC),采用留一交叉验证的逻辑回归生成分类概率,以AUC评估诊断性能。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 改变平均策略和对称性时,26个GLCM特征中4个成对ICC范围为0.02-0.98,相应AUC为0.82-0.91。
- 改变距离时,26个GLCM特征中5个ICC为0.82-0.99,相应AUC为0.52-0.91。
- 改变平均策略时,13个GLRLM特征中6个AUC为0.81-0.89且ICC为0.85-0.99。
- 改变邻域时,13个GLSZM特征中7个AUC为0.81-0.90,ICC为0.01-0.99。
- 改变窗口大小时,5个NGTDM特征中2个AUC为0.81-0.85,ICC为0.19-0.89。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片及影像组学分析时,参数变化下稳健性差(ICC低)的特征未必鉴别能力差,不宜仅凭稳健性剔除特征。
- 鉴别鼻咽癌与慢性鼻咽炎可关注SumEntropy、SZLGE、LGZE等特征,其诊断性能优于代谢活跃肿瘤体积等传统指标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the impact of parameter settings as used for the generation of radiomics features on their robustness and disease differentiation (nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) versus chronic nasopharyngitis (CN) in FDG PET/CT imaging).
METHODS: We studied 106 patients (69/37 NPC/CN, pathology confirmed), and extracted 57 radiomics features under different parameter settings. Robustness was assessed by the intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC). Logistic regression with leave-one-out cross validation was used to generate classification probabilities, and diagnostic performance was assessed by the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC).
RESULTS: Varying averaging strategies and symmetry, 4/26 GLCM features showed poor range of pairwise ICCs of 0.02-0.98, while depicting good AUCs of 0.82-0.91. Varying distances, 5/26 GLCM features showed ICCs of 0.82-0.99 while corresponding AUCs were 0.52-0.91. 6/13 GLRLM features showed both high AUC (0.81-0.89) and high ICC (0.85-0.99) regarding to averaging strategies. 7/13 GLSZM features showed AUCs of 0.81-0.90 while having ICCs of 0.01-0.99 under different neighbourhoods. 2/5 NGTDM features showed AUCs of 0.81-0.85 while having ICCs of 0.19-0.89 for different window sizes. Differentiating a subset of NPC (stages I-II) form CN, both SumEntropy and SZLGE achieved significantly higher AUCs than metabolically active tumour volume (AUC: 0.91 vs. 0.72, p<0.01).
CONCLUSIONS: Radiomics features depicting poor absolute-scale robustness regarding to parameter settings can still lead to good diagnostic performance. As such, robustness of radiomics features should not be overemphasized for removal of features towards assessment of clinical tasks. For differentiating NPC from CN, some radiomics features (e.g. SumEntropy, SZLGE, LGZE) outperformed conventional metrics.
KEY POINTS: • Poor robustness did not necessarily translate into poor differentiation performance. • Absolute-scale robustness of radiomics features should not be overemphasized. • Radiomics features SumEntropy, SZLGE and LGZE outperformed conventional metrics.
引用
- Lv W, Yuan Q, Wang Q, et al. Robustness versus disease differentiation when varying parameter settings in radiomics features: application to nasopharyngeal PET/CT. Eur Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29520429. doi:10.1007/s00330-018-5343-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。