横断面成像诊断儿童急性舟骨骨折的诊断准确性:系统综述
该系统综述检索1980年至2017年7月的Medline、Embase和Cochrane数据库,未找到可纳入Meta分析的研究。3项低质量研究评估MRI(急性损伤后第2至10天进行)诊断儿童舟骨骨折,共119例(年龄6至16岁);MRI较X线发现更多舟骨骨折及其他腕骨损伤,研究3报告MRI阴性预测值为100%。作者结论为目前无证据推荐儿童疑似舟骨骨折的成像方案,应遵循现有基于成人研究的指南。
要点
- 儿童急性舟骨骨折的横断面成像证据质量低,无研究可纳入Meta分析。
- MRI在急性损伤后第2至10天即可显示X线未发现的舟骨骨折及其他腕骨损伤。
- 研究3报告MRI阴性预测值为100%(即使早至第2天),但样本仅18例。
核心结论
- 基于系统综述,目前无证据可用于建议儿童疑似舟骨骨折的成像方案。
- 在获得此类证据前,应遵循现有指南(其基于成人研究结果)。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索Medline、Embase和Cochrane数据库1980年至2017年7月的文献,由两名观察者独立完成。
- 预设Meta分析纳入标准,并使用QADAS工具评估研究质量。
- 无研究符合纳入Meta分析的条件;纳入3项评估MRI的研究,共119例儿童(年龄范围6至16岁)。
关键影像表现/征象
- 研究1(45例)报告X线与MRI的观察者间信度分别为0.53和0.95。
- 研究3(18例)报告MRI阴性预测值为100%(即使早至第2天)。
- 研究2(56例)未报告诊断准确性或观察者信度指标。
- 3项研究中MRI均较X线发现更多舟骨骨折及其他腕骨损伤。
- 研究3显示第38至45天的随访MRI与初始MRI相比未增加新信息。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 研究3报告MRI阴性预测值为100%(18例儿童,MRI于急性损伤后第2至10天进行,即使早至第2天)。
- 研究1报告观察者间信度:X线0.53,MRI 0.95(45例儿童)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者指出目前无证据建议儿童疑似舟骨骨折的成像方案,应遵循现有指南(基于成人研究结果)。
- 现有指南基于成人研究结果,作者建议在儿童中遵循这些指南。
局限性
- 无研究可纳入Meta分析。
- 3项研究质量低(依据STARD诊断准确性研究报告指南评估)。
- 研究2未报告诊断准确性或观察者信度指标。
- 目前无证据提出儿童疑似舟骨骨折的最佳成像策略。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To determine the diagnostic accuracy of cross-sectional imaging for the diagnosis of acute scaphoid fractures in children.
METHODS: A systematic review of Medline, Embase and Cochrane databases between 1980 and July 2017 was independently performed by two observers. Criteria for study inclusion in a meta-analysis and assessment of the quality of such studies using the QADAS tool, were predetermined.
RESULTS: No studies were eligible for inclusion in a meta-analysis. Three studies (of low quality when assessed against the STARD guidelines for reporting of studies of diagnostic accuracy) assessed MRI (performed between Days 2 and 10 after acute injury) for the diagnosis of scaphoid fractures in a total of 119 children (age range 6 to 16 years). Study 1 (45 children) reported inter-observer reliability of radiographs and MRI of 0.53 and 0.95 respectively. Study 3 (18 children) reported a negative predictive value of MRI (even as early as Day 2), of 100%. No measure of diagnostic accuracy or observer reliability was reported in Study 2 (56 children). In all 3 studies, MRI identified more scaphoid fractures (and other carpal injuries) than radiographs. Study 3 showed that follow-up MRI between Days 38 and 45 added no new information compared to initial MRI.
CONCLUSION: Based on a systematic review of the literature, there is currently no evidence on which to suggest an imaging protocol for suspected scaphoid fracture in children. Until such evidence is available, existing guidelines (which are based on findings from adult studies) should be followed. Advances in knowledge: (1) There is low quality evidence regarding the diagnostic accuracy of cross-sectional imaging for suspected scaphoid fractures in children and no evidence on which to propose an optimal imaging strategy. (2) Until such evidence is available, current guidelines (based predominantly on findings in adults and expert opinion) should be followed.
引用
- Offiah AC, Burke D. The diagnostic accuracy of cross-sectional imaging for detecting acute scaphoid fractures in children: a systematic review. Br J Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29376739. doi:10.1259/bjr.20170883
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。