联合CT与MRI方案能否提高LI-RADS对肝脏观察灶分类的诊断效能:一项前瞻性比较研究
该前瞻性研究纳入240例患者共296个超声筛查发现的肝脏观察灶,由6名放射科医生独立使用LI-RADS v2014分别基于CT、MRI及联合CT/MRI进行分类。联合CT/MRI对肝细胞癌诊断的准确率(91.29%)、敏感度(90.71%)和特异度(92.31%)均优于单独MRI或CT;作者结论认为联合方法仅在怀疑肝细胞癌的病例中使用。
要点
- 联合CT/MRI的LI-RADS分类对HCC诊断准确率91.29%、敏感度90.71%、特异度92.31%。
- 单独MRI准确率85.37%、敏感度86.34%、特异度83.65%;单独CT准确率67.6%、敏感度54.10%、特异度91.35%。
- CT与MRI的LI-RADS评分组内一致性极好(κ=0.9624,95%CI:0.9318-0.9806)。
核心结论
- CT与MRI互为补充,联合CT/MRI能更精确地确定肝脏观察灶的LI-RADS分类。
- 由于费用较高且准确率提升幅度较小,联合方法应仅用于怀疑肝细胞癌的病例。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性比较研究,纳入240例患者共296个超声监测中发现的肝脏观察灶。
- 所有患者接受肝脏CT和MRI检查、组织病理学检查以及临床和影像学随访。
- 6名放射科医生独立使用LI-RADS v2014分别基于CT、MRI和联合CT/MRI对每个观察灶进行LI-RADS分类。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 联合CT/MRI对HCC诊断的准确率91.29%、敏感度90.71%、特异度92.31%。
- 单独MRI对HCC诊断的准确率85.37%、敏感度86.34%、特异度83.65%。
- 单独CT对HCC诊断的准确率67.6%、敏感度54.10%、特异度91.35%。
- CT、MRI与联合CT/MRI之间LI-RADS评分的组内一致性极好(κ=0.9624,95%CI:0.9318-0.9806)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者结论认为联合CT/MRI可更精确地确定肝脏观察灶的LI-RADS分类。
- 作者建议考虑额外费用,联合方法可限制用于疑难病例。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare diagnostic performance and agreement between CT, MRI and combined CT/MRI in reference to LI-RADS classification system to categorize hepatic observations detected in hepatic patients during screening ultrasound.
METHODS: 240 patients with 296 liver observations detected during ultrasound surveillance underwent hepatic CT and MRI examinations, histopathology, and clinical and radiological follow-up. Using LI-RADS v2014, six radiologists evaluated the observations independently and assigned a LI-RADS category to each observation using CT, MRI and combined CT/MRI.
RESULTS: Combined CT and MRI in LI-RADS yielded better accuracy (91.29 %), sensitivity (90.71 %) and specificity (92.31 %) for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) diagnosis than using MRI or CT alone; accuracy, sensitivity and specificity decreased to 85.37 %, 86.34 %, and 83.65 %, respectively, for MRI and 67.6 %, 54.10 % and 91.35 %, respectively, for CT. The intraclass agreement of the LI-RADS scores between CT, MRI and combined CT/MRI was excellent (κ=0.9624 (95 % CI: 0.9318-0.9806)).
CONCLUSION: CT and MRI are complementary to each other. Combined CT/MRI enabled a more precise determination of LI-RADS category of hepatic observations; however, due to the expense and minor increase in accuracy, the combined methodology should only be utilized in cases of suspected HCC.
KEY POINTS: • Hepatic observation may be categorized differently depending on the imaging modality used. • We compared LI-RADS categorization between CT, MRI and combined CT/MRI. • MRI produces higher accuracy and sensitivity, while CT produces higher specificity. • Combining CT and MRI improves LIRADS categorization reports. • Considering additional cost, combined methodology could be restricted to challenging cases.
引用
- Basha MAA, AlAzzazy MZ, Ahmed AF, et al. Does a combined CT and MRI protocol enhance the diagnostic efficacy of LI-RADS in the categorization of hepatic observations? A prospective comparative study. Eur Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29368164. doi:10.1007/s00330-017-5232-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。