疑似身体虐待儿科放射摄影中成像技术的比较与优化
本研究比较了英国四家国民健康服务体系信托机构用于儿科疑似身体虐待(SPA)放射成像的临床方案,并在两个站点使用不同成像技术比较了SPA骨骼检查的患者剂量。此外,在一个参与站点优化了腹部前后位(AP)摄影技术。结果显示四家机构方案存在差异,新生儿体模在DR和dRF设备上的有效剂量分别为57±3 µSv和90±4 µSv,腹部AP在55 kV下相比当前临床设置64 kV在不增加有效剂量的情况下改善了对比噪声比(4%)。
要点
- 四家参与机构的SPA成像方案和技术存在差异。
- 新生儿体模骨骼检查在DR设备上有效剂量为57±3 µSv,在dRF设备上为90±4 µSv。
- 腹部AP在55 kV下相比64 kV在不增加有效剂量的情况下对比噪声比改善4%。
核心结论
- 四家参与机构的SPA成像方案和技术存在差异;新生儿体模在DR和dRF设备上的有效剂量分别为57±3 µSv和90±4 µSv;腹部AP在55 kV下相比当前临床设置64 kV在不增加有效剂量的情况下对比噪声比改善4%。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性数据收集比较四家英国国民健康服务体系信托机构的SPA方案;使用两个拟人化儿科体模在两种数字成像系统上执行SPA骨骼检查;使用PCXMC v. 2.0软件计算有效剂量;优化研究在DR系统上于40-117 kV管电压范围内获取腹部AP图像以保持有效剂量恒定。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 新生儿体模骨骼检查在DR设备上有效剂量为57±3 µSv,在dRF设备上为90±4 µSv。
- 腹部AP在55 kV下相比当前临床设置64 kV,对比噪声比改善4%,有效剂量未增加。
- 使用0.1 mm铜滤过和降低的管电压(55 kV)可在不增加有效剂量的情况下改善新生儿和1岁儿腹部AP放射摄影的对比噪声比。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: This study compares protocols in clinical use for paediatric suspected physical abuse (SPA) radiographic imaging across four National Health Service Trusts in the UK. The patient dose delivered from a SPA skeletal survey was compared between two sites using different imaging technology. Additionally, the technique in use for the abdomen anteroposterior (AP) radiographic projection was optimized at one of the participant sites.
METHODS: Retrospective data collection was performed to compare SPA protocols. Exposure details and patient dose data for SPA skeletal surveys were collected and compared. SPA skeletal surveys were performed on two anthropomorphic paediatric phantoms using two digital imaging systems. Effective dose (ED) was calculated using a dose calculator software (PCXMC v. 2.0, STUK, Helsinki, Finland) and used as a quantification of the radiation risk. For the optimization study, abdomen AP radiographs of the phantoms were acquired over a range of tube potentials (40-117 kV) for constant ED on a digital radiography (DR) system. The contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) between "bone" and "soft tissue" in the images was measured and used as an indicator of image quality.
RESULTS: This study showed that there is a variation in the protocols and a range of techniques in use for SPA imaging across the four participant sites. The skeletal surveys undertaken on the newborn phantom at two sites resulted in an ED of 57 ± 3 µSv and 90 ± 4 µSv, on the DR unit and digital radiography/fluoroscopy (dRF) unit, respectively. Measurements of the abdomen AP projection achieved an improved CNR (4%) at a lower tube potential (55 kV) without increasing ED, compared with the current clinical setting (64 kV). Advances in knowledge: This study showed that an improved CNR can be achieved for newborn and 1-year-old abdomen AP radiographs using 0.1 mm copper filtration and a reduced kV (55 kV) without increasing ED.
引用
- Hampel JR, Pascoal A. Comparison and optimization of imaging techniques in suspected physical abuse paediatric radiography. Br J Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29243488. doi:10.1259/bjr.20170650
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。