英格兰成人钝性创伤后颈椎清除的国家调查:主要创伤中心现状
该调查向英格兰22个主要创伤中心的创伤临床负责人发放电子问卷,评估颈椎清除的临床决策工具、初始影像选择及清醒与钝态无局灶神经症状患者的清除方法。18/22(82%)中心回复,71%使用加拿大颈椎规则,72%首选CT,初始CT正常时52%中心用MRI清除颈椎;钝态患者实践差异大。结论认为需提高对高质量正常多排CT在无局灶神经症状时清除颈椎可靠性的认识。
要点
- 英格兰多数主要创伤中心以多排CT作为疑似钝性颈椎创伤的首选初始影像。
- 初始CT正常且无局灶神经症状时,清醒与钝态患者均广泛依赖MRI清除颈椎。
- 钝态患者颈椎清除实践在各中心间差异很大,少数中心在高质量多排CT正常时解除脊柱防护。
核心结论
- 多排CT是英格兰多数主要创伤中心在疑似钝性颈椎创伤时的首选初始影像技术。
- 初始CT正常且临床评估无局灶神经症状时,清醒和钝态患者均广泛依赖MRI清除颈椎。
- 作者认为这呼吁提高对高质量正常多排CT在无局灶神经症状时清除颈椎可靠性的认识。
研究设计与样本
- 电子问卷调查,发送至英格兰22个主要创伤中心的创伤临床负责人。
- 评估内容为临床决策工具、初始影像技术选择及清醒与钝态无局灶神经症状患者的颈椎清除方法。
- 以英国骨科协会创伤标准(BOAST)2和东部创伤外科协会(EAST)指南作为标准。
- 18/22(82%)中心回复并完成调查。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 71%的中心使用加拿大颈椎规则进行颈椎临床清除。
- 72%的中心首选CT作为一线影像技术,选择基于患者年龄和损伤机制。
- 初始CT正常时,52%的中心以MRI清除颈椎,其中一半中心表示会先与放射科医生讨论进一步影像。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 多数中心以多排CT作为疑似钝性颈椎创伤的首选初始影像。
- 初始CT正常且无局灶神经症状时,清醒和钝态患者均广泛依赖MRI清除颈椎。
- 钝态患者中多数中心倾向于继续制动或以MRI清除颈椎,少数中心在高质量多排CT正常时解除脊柱防护。
局限性
- 调查仅覆盖英格兰主要创伤中心,18/22(82%)中心回复。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To assess current practice in cervical spine clearance across major trauma centres in England and review current guidelines.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: An electronic survey was sent to lead trauma clinicians at 22 major trauma centres in England. This assessed the clinical decision tools used, the choice of initial imaging technique, and the methods used to clear the cervical spine in alert and obtunded patients without focal neurology, and where initial imaging was normal. British Orthopaedic Association Standards for Trauma (BOAST) 2 and Eastern Association for Surgery for Trauma (EAST) guidelines were used as standards.
RESULTS: Eighteen out of the 22 (82%) centres responded by completing the survey. Most (71%) centres used the Canadian C-Spine Rule for clearing the cervical spine clinically. Seventy-two percent of centres preferred computed tomography (CT) as the first-line imaging technique, the choice based on age of patient and mechanism of injury. If the initial CT imaging was normal, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed in 52% of centres to clear the cervical spine, with half of these centres stating that they would discuss further imaging with a radiologist first. The practice across centres was highly variable for the obtunded patient, with most centres preferring continuing immobilisation or MRI to clear the cervical spine, with a small minority removing spinal precautions when a high-quality multidetector CT was normal.
CONCLUSION: Multidetector CT is the preferred initial imaging technique across most major trauma centres in England when blunt cervical spine trauma is suspected. There is widespread reliance on MRI to clear the cervical spine in both alert and obtunded patients, if initial CT imaging is normal and there is no focal neurology on clinical assessment. This calls for greater awareness of the reliability of a high-quality normal multidetector CT examination in clearing the cervical spine in the absence of focal neurology.
引用
- Chilvers G, Porter K, Choudhary S, et al. Cervical spine clearance in adults following blunt trauma: a national survey across major trauma centres in England. Clin Radiol. 2017. PMID: 29229178. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2017.11.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。