住院医师肌肉骨骼触诊准确性:超声验证研究
该观察性研究纳入单一机构18名物理医学与康复住院医师,在2个标准化患者模型上让受试者用回形针标记膝关节内侧关节线、髌腱内侧和胫骨后肌腱,并用高频线阵探头验证触诊准确性。结果显示三个结构总体准确率分别为14%、36%和28%,按培训年限(PGY2/3/4)总体准确率为19%、29%和31%;作者认为超声是提供快速反馈的有效无创方法,可减少不准确触诊的发生。
要点
- 住院医师对膝关节内侧关节线、髌腱内侧、胫骨后肌腱的触诊准确率分别为14%、36%、28%。
- 按培训年限(PGY2、3、4)总体准确率分别为19%、29%、31%。
- 超声高频线阵探头可有效验证触诊位置并提供快速反馈。
核心结论
- 研究凸显肌肉骨骼触诊技能的不准确程度,并提示住院医师肌肉骨骼培训项目亟需改进;超声成像是提供快速反馈的有效无创方法,可减少不准确触诊的发生。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性研究,纳入单一专门机构的18名物理医学与康复住院医师,在单次数据采集过程中对2个独立标准化患者模型进行触诊标记,使用高频线阵探头验证回形针位置并测量与目标结构的距离。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以超声识别回形针是否置于目标结构上方作为触诊准确性的判定标准。
- 膝关节内侧关节线、髌腱内侧、胫骨后肌腱在所有培训年限住院医师中的触诊准确率分别为14%、36%、28%。
- 按培训年限PGY2、PGY3、PGY4统计所有结构的触诊准确率分别为19%、29%、31%。
- 膝关节内侧关节线、髌腱内侧、胫骨后肌腱的中位置信度评分分别为3.75、3.5、2。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为超声成像是提供快速反馈的有效无创方法,可减少不准确触诊的发生。
- 研究结论提出肌肉骨骼住院医师培训项目亟需改进。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this observational study was to determine the accuracy of musculoskeletal palpation of the medial joint line of the knee, medial patellar tendon, and posterior tibialis tendon verified by ultrasound imaging among physical medicine and rehabilitation residents.
METHODS: Eighteen physical medicine and rehabilitation resident physicians at a single specialized institution were asked to identify the medial joint line of the knee, medial patellar tendon, and posterior tibialis tendon on 2 separate standardized patient models during a single data collection. They were asked to place a paper clip flat on the surface of the skin parallel to the specified anatomic structure. A high-frequency linear array transducer was used to identify whether the paper clip was correctly placed over the structures and to measure the distance from the intended structure.
RESULTS: The accuracy rates for palpation of the medial joint line, medial patellar tendon, and posterior tibialis tendon in both models were 14%, 36%, and 28%, respectively, for all levels of residents. Accuracy rates for all of the structures by level of education were 19%, 29%, and 31% for postgraduate years 2, 3, and 4. Median confidence scores were 3.75, 3.5, and 2 for the medial joint line, medial patellar tendon, and posterior tibialis tendon.
CONCLUSIONS: This study highlights the level of inaccuracy of musculoskeletal palpation skills and draws further attention to an area of much-needed improvement in our musculoskeletal residency training programs. Ultrasound imaging is an effective noninvasive method for providing swift feedback to medical students and residents and thereby reduce the instances of inaccurate musculoskeletal palpation.
引用
- Mehta P, Rand EB, Visco CJ, et al. Resident Accuracy of Musculoskeletal Palpation With Ultrasound Verification. J Ultrasound Med. 2017. PMID: 29280168. doi:10.1002/jum.14523
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。