儿科急诊科CT与MRI的过度使用
本文综述儿科急诊科人群中CT与MRI的过度使用情况。近二十年数据显示儿科急诊CT使用率先升后降,2008年前后形成平台期,下降与辐射风险宣传同步;但不同机构及医生间差异大,非教学、非儿童专科急诊过度使用更明显。作者认为需开展涵盖CT与MRI过度使用趋势、使用差异及临床方案依从性的最新研究。
要点
- 儿科急诊CT过度使用以头部和腹部扫描为主,决策规则(如PECARN、Alvarado评分)及替代影像可减少过度使用。
- 非教学医院及非儿童专科急诊的CT过度使用更明显,不同机构与医生间差异大。
- MRI可避免辐射但成本更高、可及性更低、年幼儿童耐受性更差,儿科急诊MRI使用仅见零星报道。
核心结论
- 儿科急诊CT使用在经历上升后于2008年前后形成平台期并近十年下降,但不同机构与医生间差异大,非教学和非儿童专科急诊过度使用更明显;需开展涵盖CT与MRI过度使用趋势、使用差异及临床方案依从性的最新研究。
研究设计与样本
- 综述,调查儿科急诊科人群中CT与MRI的过度使用情况,检索近二十年研究。
诊断标准与关键数值
- PECARN决策规则用于头部外伤,Alvarado评分用于腹痛,二者及使用替代影像方式已被证明可减少这两类CT的过度使用。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为需开展涵盖儿科CT与MRI过度使用趋势、使用差异及临床方案依从性的最新研究。
局限性
- 儿科急诊MRI使用增加的报道仅为零星报道。
- 作者认为需开展涵盖儿科CT与MRI过度使用趋势、使用差异及临床方案依从性的最新研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
The aim of this review is to survey CT and MRI overuse in the paediatric emergency department (ED) population. CT is one of the most important modalities employed in the ED. Not surprisingly, its high accuracy, rapid acquisition and availability have resulted in overuse. An obvious limitation of CT is ionizing radiation; in addition there are economic implications to overuse. Studies from the last two decades have shown increase in paediatric ED CT utilization in the first decade, reaching a plateau forming around 2008, followed by a decrease in the last decade. This decrease occurred in conjunction with campaigns raising awareness to the risks of radiation exposure. Although a trend of decrease in overuse have been observed, great variability has been shown across different facilities, as well as among physicians, with more pronounced overuse in non-teaching and non-children dedicated EDs. The leading types of paediatric ED CTs are head and abdominal scans. Decision rules, such as PECARN for head injury and the Alvarado score for abdominal pain, as well as using alternative imaging modalities, have been shown to reduce CT overuse in these two categories. MRI has the obvious benefit of avoiding radiation exposure, but the disadvantages of higher costs, less availability and less tolerability in younger children. Although anecdotally paediatric ED MRI usage has increased in recent years, only scarce reports have been published. In our opinion, there is need to conduct up-to-date studies covering paediatric CT and MRI overuse trends, usage variability and adherence to clinical protocols.
引用
- Ohana O, Soffer S, Zimlichman E, et al. Overuse of CT and MRI in paediatric emergency departments. Br J Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29271231. doi:10.1259/bjr.20170434
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。