双期扫描CT率:质量支付计划中基于医疗机构的放射科医生测量机会
该研究利用2014年Medicare数据,计算放射科医生在腹部和胸部CT中双期扫描(平扫加增强)的比率,并分析其与医生特征的关系。腹部CT平均双期扫描率为5.9%±10.0%,胸部CT为1.0%±4.7%;腹部率与地理区域、执业规模和专科模式相关。MACRA授权CMS使用此类基于机构的测量来评估放射科医生,以激励辐射剂量和成本降低。
要点
- 腹部CT双期扫描率平均5.9%,胸部CT平均1.0%。
- 同一执业机构内放射科医生双期扫描率一致性中等,胸部ICC=0.70,腹部ICC=0.59。
- 腹部CT双期扫描率变异大于胸部,可能有助于区分放射科医生表现差异。
核心结论
- 放射科医生基于机构的双期扫描率因一系列专业特征而系统性变化;MACRA授权CMS使用这些测量评估放射科医生,以更好地激励辐射剂量和成本降低;腹部CT双期扫描率的较大变异支持其在区分放射科医生表现差异中的特殊作用。
研究设计与样本
- 利用2014年Medicare医师及其他供应商数据,识别机构环境中腹部和胸部CT检查的索赔;计算个体放射科医生双期扫描率;使用多变量回归与交叉验证探索率与从CMS公共数据集提取的放射科医生特征之间的关联;腹部CT分析纳入19,867名放射科医生,胸部CT分析纳入18,684名。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 双期扫描率定义为同时进行平扫和增强静脉造影的检查占总检查的百分比。
- 腹部CT双期扫描率平均5.9%±10.0%,52.8%的放射科医生为0.0%。
- 胸部CT双期扫描率平均1.0%±4.7%,91.3%的放射科医生为0.0%。
- 同一执业机构内放射科医生双期扫描率的一致性:胸部组内相关系数=0.70,腹部组内相关系数=0.59。
临床应用与阅片要点
- MACRA授权CMS使用基于机构的测量评估放射科医生,从而对齐Medicare的医院和医师绩效项目,并更好地激励人群辐射剂量和成本降低。
- 腹部CT双期扫描率变异大于胸部CT,支持腹部率在区分放射科医生表现差异中的特殊作用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act (MACRA) provides CMS flexibility to evaluate radiologists using hospital outpatient quality measures in place of conventional physician measures. We explore radiologist characteristics associated with variation in performance in two such measures: abdomen and chest CT "double scan" rates (percentage of total examinations performed both with and without intravenous contrast).
METHODS: Radiologists' claims for abdomen and chest CT examinations in a facility setting were identified using 2014 Medicare Physician and Other Supplier data. Individual radiologist double scan rates were computed. Associations were explored between rates and radiologist characteristics extracted from the CMS public data sets using multivariable regression with cross-validation.
RESULTS: Radiologists' double scan rates averaged 5.9% ± 10.0% (0.0% for 52.8% of radiologists) for abdomen CT (19,867 radiologists) and 1.0% ± 4.7% (0.0% for 91.3% of radiologists) for chest CT (18,684). At multivariable analysis, abdomen rates were best predicted by geography (lowest in Northeast, greatest in West), practice size (greatest for small practices), and specialty practice pattern (lowest for general radiologists; greatest for nuclear medicine physicians). Agreement for double scan rates among radiologists within the same practice was moderate, though slightly higher for chest (intraclass correlation = 0.70) than abdomen (0.59).
CONCLUSION: Radiologists' facility double scan rates vary systematically based on an array of professional characteristics. MACRA grants CMS the authority to use these measures for evaluating radiologists, thereby aligning Medicare's hospital and physician performance programs and better incentivizing population radiation dose and cost reduction. Greater variation in abdomen CT double scan rates, compared with ubiquitously excellent chest CT performance, supports a particular role for abdomen rates in distinguishing disparities in radiologist performance.
引用
- Rosenkrantz AB, Babb JS, Nicola GN, et al. Double Scan CT Rates: An Opportunity for Facility-Based Radiologist Measures in the Quality Payment Program. J Am Coll Radiol. 2017. PMID: 29275918. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2017.11.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。