后前位屈膝位摄影在评估膝骨关节炎方面优于前后位摄影
研究纳入365例膝痛患者,均行前后位、后前位屈膝位、侧位及Merchant位X线摄影,按K-L分级及内/外侧/髌股间室分组。轻度外翻性骨关节炎(K-L 1-2级)中,后前位屈膝位较前后位更敏感,68%患者外侧最小关节间隙宽度减少超过2 mm致K-L分级升高;重度外翻及所有内翻、髌股间室骨关节炎中两种体位无差异;单用后前位屈膝位较两者联用降低47%影像费用。
要点
- 轻度外翻性骨关节炎(K-L 1-2级)中,后前位屈膝位对显示外侧间室病变较前后位更敏感。
- 68%的轻度外翻性骨关节炎患者在后前位屈膝位上外侧最小关节间隙宽度减少超过2 mm,K-L分级升至3或4级。
- 重度外翻性及所有内翻性、髌股间室骨关节炎中,前后位与后前位屈膝位在影像测量或K-L分级上无差异。
核心结论
- 后前位屈膝位能更好地对轻度外翻性骨关节炎患者的外侧间室病变进行严重程度分类,且对内翻性和髌股间室骨关节炎的关节间隙狭窄提供与前后位相当的诊断敏感度;单用后前位屈膝位较前后位与后前位屈膝位联用更具成本效益。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入365例膝痛患者,均行前后位、后前位屈膝位、侧位及Merchant位X线摄影,按Kellgren和Lawrence(K-L)分级分为轻度(K-L 1-2级)或重度(K-L 3-4级)骨关节炎,并按内翻(内侧间室)、外翻(外侧间室)或髌股间室骨关节炎分组。
关键影像表现/征象
- 在前后位上表现为轻度外翻性骨关节炎(K-L 1-2级)的膝关节中,后前位屈膝位较前后位更敏感。
- 68%的患者在后前位屈膝位上测得的外侧最小关节间隙宽度减少超过2 mm,导致K-L分级升高(3或4级)。
- 在重度外翻性骨关节炎患者以及所有内翻性和髌股间室骨关节炎患者中,前后位与后前位屈膝位在影像测量或K-L分级上无差异。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 轻度外翻性骨关节炎(前后位K-L 1-2级)中,后前位屈膝位较前后位更敏感。
- 后前位屈膝位上外侧最小关节间隙宽度减少超过2 mm见于68%的轻度外翻性骨关节炎患者,并致K-L分级升高至3或4级。
- 重度外翻性及所有内翻性、髌股间室骨关节炎中,前后位与后前位屈膝位在影像测量或K-L分级上无差异。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 基于Medicare报销费率,单用后前位屈膝位替代前后位与后前位屈膝位联合摄影可降低47%的影像费用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to determine whether the posterior-anterior (PA)-flexed view improves the radiographic assessment of patients with knee pain compared with the standard standing anterior-posterior radiograph.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Three hundred and sixty-five patients with knee pain underwent anterior-posterior (AP), PA flexed, lateral, and Merchant radiographs of the knee. Knees were grouped as mild (Kellgren and Lawrence [K-L] 1-2) or severe (K-L 3-4) osteoarthritis (OA) and either varus (medial compartment), valgus (lateral compartment), or patellofemoral OA.
RESULTS: In knees with mild valgus OA on AP view (K-L 1-2), the PA flexed view was more sensitive than the AP view. The measured lateral minimal joint space width (minJSW) decreased more than 2 mm in 68% of the patients, resulting in an increase in K-L grade (3 or 4). In patients with severe valgus OA and in all patients with varus and patellofemoral OA, there was no difference between AP and PA flexed view with regard to radiographic measurements or KL grade. Based on the Medicare reimbursement rate using the PA flexed view alone instead of both views reduced imaging costs by 47%.
CONCLUSION: The PA flexed view better classifies the severity of lateral compartment disease in patients with mild valgus OA and provides comparable diagnostic sensitivity for joint space narrowing in varus- and patellofemoral OA. Using the PA flexed view alone was more cost effective than using the combination of AP and PA flexed imaging.
引用
- Rueckl K, Boettner F, Maza N, et al. The posterior-anterior flexed view is better than the anterior-posterior view for assessing osteoarthritis of the knee. Skeletal Radiol. 2017. PMID: 29159676. doi:10.1007/s00256-017-2815-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。