Journal Club:急性踝关节损伤背景下中跗(Chopart)关节扭伤的MRI评估
本研究通过PACS检索纳入47例急性踝损伤患者和16例无踝外伤对照,回顾性分析Chopart关节韧带及骨性损伤的MRI表现及其与踝扭伤的关系。11例(23%)存在中跗扭伤,其中8例急性/亚急性病例中6例(75%)合并外侧副韧带损伤;骨性损伤前瞻性报告率89%,但韧带损伤漏诊率83%。作者认为中跗扭伤常与急性踝损伤和踝扭伤相关,目前可能被放射科医生低估。
要点
- 中跗扭伤在急性踝损伤中占23%,急性/亚急性病例中75%合并外侧副韧带损伤。
- 韧带损伤前瞻性漏诊率高达83%,而骨性损伤报告率为89%。
- 熟悉Chopart关节韧带和骨性损伤的MRI表现对准确诊断和临床管理重要。
核心结论
- 中跗扭伤常与急性踝损伤及踝扭伤相关,目前可能被放射科医生低估,熟悉Chopart关节韧带和骨性损伤的MRI表现对准确诊断和临床管理重要。
研究设计与样本
- 通过数字PACS检索识别两个队列:踝损伤后8周内行MRI的患者和无踝外伤的对照,回顾性共识阅片及独立阅片评估Chopart关节(跟骰关节和距舟关节)韧带及骨性损伤以及相关外侧副韧带和三角韧带损伤,计算观察者间一致性并复习前瞻性报告。
关键影像表现/征象
- 正常背侧跟骰韧带和分歧韧带跟骰组成显示不一,其余正常韧带均可见。
- 11例(23%)存在中跗韧带及骨性损伤,符合中跗扭伤,其中8例急性或亚急性、1例可能、2例陈旧。
- 8例急性或亚急性病例中6例(75%)合并外侧副韧带损伤。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 中跗扭伤诊断基于Chopart关节韧带及骨性损伤的MRI表现。
- 骨性损伤前瞻性报告率89%,韧带损伤漏诊率83%。
- 中跗扭伤诊断的观察者间一致性达到中等程度。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为熟悉Chopart关节韧带和骨性损伤的MRI表现对准确诊断和临床管理重要。
局限性
- 研究为回顾性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: This study determined the frequency and MRI appearance of osseous and ligamentous injuries in midtarsal (Chopart) sprains and their association with ankle sprains after acute ankle injuries. Prospective diagnosis of and interobserver agreement regarding midtarsal injury among musculoskeletal radiologists were also assessed.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Two cohorts with ankle MRI were identified via a digital PACS search: patients who had undergone MRI within 8 weeks after ankle injury and control subjects who had not sustained ankle trauma. Studies were retrospectively reviewed in consensus as well as independently, assessing ligamentous and osseous injury to the Chopart joint (calcaneocuboid and talonavicular joints) and associated lateral collateral and deltoid ligamentous injury. Interobserver agreement was calculated, and prospective radiology reports were reviewed to determine the musculoskeletal radiologist's familiarity with Chopart joint injury.
RESULTS: MR images of control subjects (n = 16) and patients with ankle injury (n = 47) were reviewed. The normal dorsal calcaneocuboid and calcaneocuboid component of bifurcate ligaments were variably visualized; the remaining normal ligaments were always seen. Eleven patients (23%) had midtarsal ligamentous and osseous injury consistent with midtarsal sprain (eight acute or subacute, one probable, and two old). Six (75%) of eight acute or subacute cases had coexisting lateral collateral ligament injury. Eighty-nine percent of osseous injuries were reported prospectively, but 83% of ligamentous injuries were missed. Substantial interobserver agreement was achieved regarding diagnosis of midtarsal sprain.
CONCLUSION: Midtarsal sprains are commonly associated with acute ankle injury and with ankle sprains. Presently, midtarsal sprains may be underrecognized by radiologists; thus, greater familiarity with the MRI spectrum of ligamentous and osseous injuries at the Chopart joint is important for accurate diagnosis and clinical management.
引用
- Walter WR, Hirschmann A, Alaia EF, et al. JOURNAL CLUB: MRI Evaluation of Midtarsal (Chopart) Sprain in the Setting of Acute Ankle Injury. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2017. PMID: 29112474. doi:10.2214/AJR.17.18503
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。