脑部静音T1加权MRI与静音MR血管成像的临床评估
研究比较静音T1加权与平扫MRA序列和常规序列在临床人群中的表现:40例疑脑转移患者行T1加权增强MRI,51例疑血管病变或脑缺血患者行平扫颅内MRA,3名神经放射科医师盲法按5分Likert量表评分。静音T1多数病例评为等同或优于常规图像,但存在偏好时多偏好常规图像;静音MRA所有图像质量指标评分更低且被强烈偏好常规图像,作者认为目前不能推荐静音MRA。
要点
- 静音T1加权图像除诊断信心外各项评分略低于常规图像,88%病例两种序列对病灶检出一致。
- 静音T1加权在48%病例评为与常规等同,存在偏好时38%偏好常规 vs 14%偏好静音。
- 静音MRA所有图像质量指标评分均低于常规MRA,69%病例偏好常规、27%等同、4%偏好静音。
核心结论
- 常规T1加权图像总体更受偏好,但多数静音T1加权图像评为等同或优于常规图像,可作为对噪声敏感患者的潜在替代方案;静音MRA评分显著更差,目前不能推荐,需进一步改进后方可用于常规临床。
研究设计与样本
- 临床对照研究,纳入40例疑脑转移患者(中位年龄60岁,范围23-91岁)行T1加权增强MRI,51例疑血管病变或脑缺血患者(中位年龄60岁,范围16-94岁)行平扫颅内MRA;3名神经放射科医师盲法阅片,按5分Likert量表评分图像质量,并记录强化病灶数目及静音图像优于、劣于或等同于常规图像。
关键影像表现/征象
- 静音T1加权图像除诊断信心外各项图像质量评分略低于常规图像。
- 常规T1加权图像检出更多病灶,但差异无统计学意义,88%病例两种序列一致。
- 静音MRA图像在部分病例因伪影出现血管管径变细、血管不规则甚至血管缺失。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 图像质量采用5分Likert量表评分,由3名神经放射科医师盲法评阅。
- 静音T1加权与常规图像偏好:48%病例评为等同,存在偏好时38%偏好常规 vs 14%偏好静音。
- 静音MRA与常规MRA偏好:69%病例偏好常规、27%等同、4%偏好静音。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 静音T1加权可作为对噪声敏感患者的潜在替代方案,但阅片时需注意其诊断信心与常规序列的差异。
- 静音MRA目前不能推荐用于常规临床,阅片时需警惕伪影所致血管管径变细、血管不规则或血管缺失。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: New MRI sequences based on rapid radial acquisition have reduced gradient noise. The purpose of this study was to compare Silent T1-weighted and unenhanced MR angiography (MRA) against conventional sequences in a clinical population.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The study cohort consisted of 40 patients with suspected brain metastases (median age, 60 years; range, 23-91 years) who underwent T1-weighted contrast-enhanced MRI and 51 patients with suspected vascular lesions or cerebral ischemia (median age, 60 years; range, 16-94 years) who underwent unenhanced intracranial MRA. Three neuroradiologists reviewed the images blindly and rated several measures of image quality on a 5-point Likert scale. Reviewers recorded the number of enhancing lesions and whether Silent images were better than, worse than, or equivalent to conventional images.
RESULTS: For T1-weighted MR images, ratings were slightly lower for Silent versus conventional images, except for diagnostic confidence. Although more lesions were detected on conventional images, this difference was not statistically significant; agreement was seen in 88% of cases. In 48% of cases, T1-weighted scans were deemed equivalent, but when a preference existed, it was usually for conventional images (38% vs 14%). Conventional MRA images were rated higher on all image quality metrics and were strongly preferred (reviewers preferred conventional images in 69% of cases, rated the images as equivalent in 27% of cases, and preferred Silent images in 4% of cases). In some cases, artifacts on Silent images caused reduced vessel caliber, vessel irregularities, and even absent vessels.
CONCLUSION: Although conventional T1-weighted images were preferred overall, most Silent T1-weighted images were rated as equivalent to or better than conventional images and represent a potential alternative for imaging of noise-averse patients. Silent MRA scored significantly worse and could not be recommended at this time, suggesting that it requires additional refinement before routine clinical use.
引用
- Holdsworth SJ, Macpherson SJ, Yeom KW, et al. Clinical Evaluation of Silent T1-Weighted MRI and Silent MR Angiography of the Brain. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2017. PMID: 29112472. doi:10.2214/AJR.17.18247
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。