辐射防护:轻微胸部创伤中转诊指南依从性的影响因素
研究向112名处方者发放包含典型临床病史的问卷,测试轻微胸部创伤中肋骨X线转诊指南的知晓与依从情况。58%的处方者建议行肋骨X线检查,其中89%不知晓指南;告知指南和辐射剂量后仅11%改变开单意向(P=0.057)。肋骨X线平均剂量为胸部X线的38倍,法律与医疗法律顾虑是开单主因。
要点
- 多数处方者在轻微胸部创伤中开具肋骨X线,且大多不知晓转诊指南。
- 告知指南与辐射剂量后仅少数处方者改变开单意向,差异未达统计学显著(P=0.057)。
- 开单动机以法律和医疗法律顾虑为主,而非医学理由。
核心结论
- 指南表述不清晰加之社会与医疗法律问题,而非医学理由或对指南缺乏了解,强烈影响轻微胸部创伤中肋骨X线的开具。
研究设计与样本
- 向112名处方者(33名住院医师、18名外科医师、7名内科医师、24名全科医师和30名急诊医师)发放问卷,所有处方者均同意参与;比较采用Fisher精确检验及事后分析和McNemar检验。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 58%的处方者建议行肋骨X线检查,其中89%不知晓指南。
- 在获知转诊指南和辐射剂量信息后,仅11%的处方者改变了开具肋骨X线的意向(P=0.057)。
- 肋骨X线平均剂量为胸部X线的38倍。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 法律和医疗法律顾虑(保险公司要求及避免诉讼)是要求行X线检查的主要原因。
- 指南表述不清晰可能解释对指南的依从性差。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To test the hypothesis that referral guidelines are not sufficiently known by prescribers and that medico-legal concerns could influence the prescription of radiographs in minor chest trauma.
METHODS: We submitted a questionnaire including a typical clinical history and questions on reasons for prescribing radiographs of the ribs in minor chest trauma to 112 prescriptors (33 residents, 18 surgeons, 7 internists, 24 general practitioners and 30 ER physicians). All accepted to participate. Comparisons were performed by Fisher's exact test followed by a post-hoc analysis and by a McNemar test.
RESULTS: Fifty-eight percent of prescriptors proposed rib radiographs, most (89%) being unaware of the guidelines. Only 11% of them changed their intention to order radiographs after information on referral guidelines and radiation dose (P=0.057). The mean dose delivered by rib radiographs was 38 times higher than that of a chest X-ray. Legal and medico-legal concerns (requirements from insurance policies and avoidance of lawsuits) were the main reasons for requesting radiographs.
CONCLUSION: Unsharpness of guidelines in addition to social and medico-legal issues, rather than medical reasons or the lack of knowledge of the guidelines, strongly influence the prescription of radiographs of the ribs in minor chest trauma.
KEY POINTS: • Most prescriptors order radiographs of the ribs in minor chest trauma. • Only few prescriptors are aware of referral guidelines. • Information on guidelines does not change their need for radiographs. • Motivations for ordering radiographs are rather legal than medical, but poor compliance to guidelines could also be explained by their unsharpness. • Radiation dose of rib radiographs was 38 times that of a PA chest radiograph.
引用
- Tack D, Louagé F, Van Muylem A, et al. Radiation protection: Factors influencing compliance to referral guidelines in minor chest trauma. Eur Radiol. 2017. PMID: 29079913. doi:10.1007/s00330-017-5093-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。