Brooker分类中平片与CT扫描对异位骨化分级的潜在差异
该回顾性研究分析了1998年7月至2016年8月在Sunnybrook健康科学中心因异位骨化预防接受髋部和/或盆腔放疗的22例患者,由一名对患者病情和临床结局不知情的独立骨肌放射科医生依据Brooker分类评估影像。通过病例展示发现平片与CT扫描及不同投照角度间Brooker分级存在差异,且Brooker分类无法体现异位骨化的体积差异和关节置换假体长度。作者认为CT和正交投照可减少歧义,并有必要开发与功能结局相对应的新分类方法。
要点
- Brooker分类在平片与CT扫描之间可能出现分级差异,阅片时需注意。
- 不同放射学投照角度可导致Brooker分级不一致。
- Brooker分类无法反映异位骨化的体积差异及关节置换假体长度。
核心结论
- Brooker分类虽广泛使用,但存在局限性;使用CT等其他影像模态和正交投照可减少歧义,有必要开发与功能结局相对应的分类方法。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入1998年7月至2016年8月在Sunnybrook健康科学中心因异位骨化预防接受髋部和/或盆腔放疗的患者22例,由一名对患者病情和临床结局不知情的独立骨肌放射科医生依据Brooker分类评估影像。
关键影像表现/征象
- Brooker分类与平片、CT图像及不同放射学投照角度之间存在差异。
- Brooker分类无法体现异位骨化的体积差异。
- Brooker分类无法体现关节置换假体长度的差异。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,使用CT等其他放射学模态和正交投照可能减少使用异位骨化分类系统时的歧义。
- 作者认为,有必要开发一种能够与临床结局(如功能能力)相对应、以进一步评估异位骨化发展的分类方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The Brooker classification is a commonly used tool to characterize the extent of heterotopic ossification (HTO), which is the dystrophic formation of mature lamellar bone in non-osseous tissues such as muscles, connective tissue or nerves. We aim to provide illustrative cases to describe the limitations and challenges of this system.
METHODS: A retrospective review was conducted in all patients who had retrieved hip and/or pelvic radiotherapy for HTO prophylaxis at Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre between July 1998 and August 2016. An independent musculoskeletal radiologist who was blinded to the condition of the patient and the clinical outcome evaluated the imaging studies based on the Brooker classification.
RESULTS: 22 patients were identified for analysis. Three patient cases were presented to illustrate the discrepancies between the Brooker classification and radiographic images, CT images and different radiographical projections. Two patient cases were presented to demonstrate the inability of the Brooker classification to account for volumetric differences in HTO and arthroplasty lengths.
CONCLUSION: Although the Brooker classification for HTO is a widely used quantitative and qualitative assessment tool given its simplicity and familiarity, it possesses several limitations. Utilization of other radiographic modalities, such as CT, and orthogonal projections may reduce ambiguities from using the HTO system. Development of a classification method that can appropriately correspond to the clinical outcomes such as functional capabilities to further HTO development is warranted. Advances in knowledge: The present study critically evaluated the Brooker classification system, and identified areas in which improvement is warranted on characterizing HTO. This is important in further research that aims to improve the accuracy of HTO classification guidelines.
引用
- Mary Jiayi T, Linda P, Michael P, et al. Potential discrepancy between plain films and CT scans in Brooker classification of heterotopic ossification. Br J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28972793. doi:10.1259/bjr.20170263
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。