文献速递妇产影像US

专家共识下的先天性子宫畸形(CUME):区分正常/弓形子宫与纵隔子宫的更好标准?

Congenital Uterine Malformation by Experts (CUME): better criteria for distinguishing between normal/arcuate and septate uterus?
PubMed 文献 · Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol · 2018-01-01

该研究让15位专家对100例三维超声子宫冠状面图像进行主观判断,以专家最常做出的选择(CUME)为参考标准,评估三项测量指标的观察者间可靠性和诊断准确性。结果显示专家间一致性好(kappa 0.62),CUME定义纵隔子宫18例、正常/弓形子宫82例;ESHRE-ESGE标准(I:WT比值>50%)定义纵隔子宫80例、正常/弓形子宫20例,与CUME一致性仅38%(kappa 0.1);ASRM标准定义纵隔子宫5例、正常/弓形子宫82例、灰区13例。三项测量AUC在0.96至1.00之间,最佳截断值为凹陷深度≥10 mm、凹陷角度<140°、I:WT比值>110%。作者推荐以凹陷深度≥10 mm作为纵隔子宫的判断标准。

要点

  • 专家主观判断正常/弓形与纵隔子宫的一致性良好(kappa 0.62)。
  • ESHRE-ESGE标准(I:WT比值>50%)高估纵隔子宫患病率,与CUME一致性仅38%(kappa 0.1)。
  • ASRM标准低估纵隔子宫患病率,将多数专家认为纵隔的子宫归入灰区。

核心结论

  • ESHRE-ESGE建议的截断值高估纵隔子宫患病率,ASRM标准则低估该患病率并将多数专家认为纵隔的子宫归入灰区;作者推荐以凹陷深度≥10 mm作为纵隔子宫的判断标准,因该测量简单可靠且与专家意见一致。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究由15位专家(5位临床医生、5位外科医生、5位超声医生)对100例疑似宫底内凹女性的三维超声子宫冠状面匿名图像进行主观判断,另由两名观察者独立测量凹陷深度、凹陷角度和凹陷与壁厚度比值(I:WT比值),以专家最常做出的选择(CUME)为参考标准。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • CUME参考标准定义纵隔子宫18例、正常/弓形子宫82例;ESHRE-ESGE标准(I:WT比值>50%)定义纵隔子宫80例、正常/弓形子宫20例;ASRM标准定义纵隔子宫5例(深度>15 mm且角度<90°)、正常/弓形子宫82例(深度<10 mm且角度>90°)、灰区13例。ESHRE-ESGE与CUME一致性38%(kappa 0.1);ASRM与CUME在纵隔子宫的一致性87%(kappa 0.39),将纵隔和灰区均视为纵隔时一致性98%(kappa 0.93)。凹陷深度观察者间CCC 0.99(95%CI 0.98-0.99),优于凹陷角度CCC 0.96(95%CI 0.94-0.97)和I:WT比值CCC 0.92(95%CI 0.90-0.94)。三项测量以CUME为参考标准的AUC在0.96至1.00之间。定义纵隔子宫的最佳截断值:凹陷深度≥10 mm、凹陷角度<140°、I:WT比值>110%。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者推荐考虑以凹陷深度≥10 mm作为纵隔子宫的判断标准,因该测量简单可靠且与专家意见一致。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: To assess the level of agreement between experts in distinguishing between septate and normal/arcuate uterus using their subjective judgment when reviewing the coronal view of the uterus from three-dimensional ultrasound. Another aim was to determine the interobserver reliability and diagnostic test accuracy of three measurements suggested by recent guidelines, using as reference standard the decision made most often by experts (Congenital Uterine Malformation by Experts (CUME)).

METHODS: Images of the coronal plane of the uterus from 100 women with suspected fundal internal indentation were anonymized and provided to 15 experts (five clinicians, five surgeons and five sonologists). They were instructed to indicate whether they believed the uterus to be normal/arcuate (defined as normal uterine morphology or not clinically relevant degree of distortion caused by internal indentation) or septate (clinically relevant degree of distortion caused by internal indentation). Two other observers independently measured indentation depth, indentation angle and indentation-to-wall-thickness (I:WT) ratio. The agreement between experts was assessed using kappa, the interobserver reliability was assessed using the concordance correlation coefficient (CCC), the diagnostic test accuracy was assessed using the area under the receiver-operating characteristics curve (AUC) and the best cut-off value was assessed using Youden's index, considering as the reference standard the choice made most often by the experts (CUME).

RESULTS: There was good agreement between all experts (kappa, 0.62). There were 18 septate and 82 normal/arcuate uteri according to CUME; European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE)-European Society for Gynaecological Endoscopy (ESGE) criteria (I:WT ratio > 50%) defined 80 septate and 20 normal/arcuate uteri, while American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) criteria defined five septate (depth > 15 mm and angle < 90°), 82 normal/arcuate (depth < 10 mm and angle > 90°) and 13 uteri that could not be classified (referred to as the gray-zone). The agreement between ESHRE-ESGE and CUME was 38% (kappa, 0.1); the agreement between ASRM criteria and CUME for septate was 87% (kappa, 0.39), and considering both septate and gray-zone as septate, the agreement was 98% (kappa, 0.93). Among the three measurements, the interobserver reproducibility of indentation depth (CCC, 0.99; 95% CI, 0.98-0.99) was better than both indentation angle (CCC, 0.96; 95% CI, 0.94-0.97) and I:WT ratio (CCC, 0.92; 95% CI, 0.90-0.94). The diagnostic test accuracy of these three measurements using CUME as reference standard was very good, with AUC between 0.96 and 1.00. The best cut-off values for these measurements to define septate uterus were: indentation depth ≥ 10 mm, indentation angle < 140° and I:WT ratio > 110% .

CONCLUSIONS: The suggested ESHRE-ESGE cut-off value overestimates the prevalence of septate uterus while that of ASRM underestimates this prevalence, leaving in the gray-zone most of the uteri that experts considered as septate. We recommend considering indentation depth ≥ 10 mm as septate, since the measurement is simple and reliable and this criterion is in agreement with expert opinion. Copyright © 2017 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

来源:Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ludwin A, Martins WP, Nastri CO, et al. Congenital Uterine Malformation by Experts (CUME): better criteria for distinguishing between normal/arcuate and septate uterus? Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2018. PMID: 29024135. doi:10.1002/uog.18923

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。