放射科医生与泌尿科医生对前列腺MRI报告意见的比较:专业学会调查结果
该研究通过电子问卷调查比较了腹部放射学会的放射科医生与泌尿肿瘤学会的泌尿科医生对前列腺MRI报告的意见。两组均强烈偏好PI-RADSv2(各84%),但对报告是否应包含管理建议存在分歧(P≤0.039),泌尿科医生更偏好完全结构化报告(54% vs 53%),作者认为需开展协作教育以优化前列腺MRI报告对患者照护的影响。
要点
- 两组均强烈偏好PI-RADSv2用于前列腺MRI报告,放射科医生84%,泌尿科医生84%。
- 放射科医生与泌尿科医生对报告是否应包含靶向活检、随访影像及随访间隔等管理建议存在显著分歧(P≤0.039)。
- 泌尿科医生更偏好完全结构化报告(54%),放射科医生更偏好混合结构化与自由文本报告(53%)。
核心结论
- 放射科医生和泌尿科医生均强烈偏好PI-RADSv2用于前列腺MRI报告,尽管认识到其采用的障碍;泌尿科医生更强烈偏好完全结构化报告,且不同意放射科医生在报告中包含管理建议的偏好;作者认为需要放射科与泌尿科协作教育以优化前列腺MRI报告对患者照护的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 对腹部放射学会的放射科成员和泌尿肿瘤学会的泌尿科成员进行电子问卷调查,评估对前列腺MRI报告的意见;腹部放射学会应答率为12%(135/1155),泌尿肿瘤学会为8%(54/663)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 两专业均偏好PI-RADSv2:放射科医生84%,泌尿科医生84%。
- 报告PI-RADSv2在其机构使用:放射科医生84%,泌尿科医生78%。
- 理解PI-RADSv2对患者照护的含义:放射科医生89%,泌尿科医生71%。
- 同意放射科医生正确应用PI-RADSv2分类:放射科医生57%,泌尿科医生61%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- PI-RADSv2采用的主要障碍包括放射科医生使用PI-RADSv2经验不足(放射科医生51%,泌尿科医生51%)、泌尿科医生使用PI-RADSv2经验不足(放射科医生46%,泌尿科医生51%)和缺乏标准化模板(放射科医生47%,泌尿科医生52%)。
局限性
- 腹部放射学会应答率为12%(135/1155),泌尿肿瘤学会应答率为8%(54/663)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study is to compare radiologists' and urologists' opinions regarding prostate MRI reporting.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Radiologist members of the Society of Abdominal Radiology and urologist members of the Society of Urologic Oncology received an electronic survey regarding prostate MRI reporting.
RESULTS: The response rate was 12% (135/1155) for Society of Abdominal Radiology and 8% (54/663) for Society of Urologic Oncology members. Most respondents in both specialties prefer Prostate Imaging Reporting and Data System version 2 (PI-RADSv2) (radiologists, 84%; urologists, 84%), indicate that it is used at their institution (radiologists, 84%; urologists, 78%), understand its implications for patient care (radiologists, 89%; urologists, 71%), and agree that radiologists apply PI-RADSv2 categories correctly (radiologists, 57%; urologists, 61%). Both specialties agreed regarding major barriers to PI-RADSv2 adoption: radiologist inexperience using PI-RADSv2 (radiologists, 51%; urologists, 51%), urologist inexperience using PI-RADSv2 (radiologists, 46%; urologists, 51%), and lack of standardized templates (radiologists, 47%; urologists, 52%). The specialties disagreed (p ≤ 0.039) regarding whether reports should include the following management recommendations: targeted biopsy (radiologists, 58%; urologists, 34%), follow-up imaging (radiologists, 46%; urologists, 28%), and time interval for follow-up imaging (radiologists, 35%; urologists, 16%). There was also disagreement (p = 0.037) regarding report style: 54% of urologists preferred fully structured reports, whereas 53% of radiologists preferred hybrid structured and free-text reports.
CONCLUSION: Radiologists and urologists both strongly prefer PI-RADSv2 for prostate MRI reporting, despite recognizing barriers to its adoption. Urologists more strongly preferred a fully structured report and disagreed with radiologists' preference to include management recommendations. Collaborative radiologist-urologist educational efforts are warranted to help optimize the effect of prostate MRI reporting in patient care.
引用
- Spilseth B, Ghai S, Patel NU, et al. A Comparison of Radiologists' and Urologists' Opinions Regarding Prostate MRI Reporting: Results From a Survey of Specialty Societies. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2017. PMID: 29064758. doi:10.2214/AJR.17.18241
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。