局灶性肝脏病变:利用超声造影动态录像进行计算机辅助诊断
多中心试验中三个中心入组的106例超声数据集(54恶性、51良性、1例不确定)回顾性分析,用人工神经网络和支持向量机自动提取B模式和造影特征分类局灶性肝脏病变。支持向量机AUC 0.883与有经验阅片者0.843相近,仅与无经验阅片者0.702差异有统计学意义。CAD与阅片者一致时准确率提高,时间依赖的时间-强度曲线特征比强度依赖特征更具鉴别力。
要点
- 支持向量机AUC 0.883(95%CI 0.793–0.940),与有经验阅片者0.843(95%CI 0.756–0.903)相近,仅与无经验阅片者0.702(95%CI 0.586–0.782)差异有统计学意义。
- B模式不均匀性和造影剂廓清是CAD各次迭代选择的最具鉴别力的特征。
- CAD与无经验阅片者一致时准确率从71.3%(67/94)升至87.7%(57/65);与有经验阅片者一致时从80.9%(76/94)升至90.3%(65/72)。
核心结论
- CAD系统分类良恶性局灶性肝脏病变的准确率与专家阅片者相似,并可提高两位阅片者的准确率;时间-强度曲线的时间依赖特征比强度依赖特征更具鉴别力。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心试验中三个中心入组受试者的106例超声数据集回顾性分析,其中54例恶性、51例良性、1例不确定;105例良性或恶性病变经组织学检查、增强CT、动态增强MR和/或6个月以上临床随访确认;数据集含3分钟动态录像,自动校正平面内运动并自动滤除偏离平面的帧。
关键影像表现/征象
- B模式不均匀性和造影剂廓清是CAD所有迭代中最具鉴别力的特征。
- CAD在99.0%(207/209)的情况下选择时间依赖的时间-强度曲线特征来分类局灶性肝脏病变,而选择强度依赖特征仅占1.0%(2/209)。
- 15项视频质量标准均对CAD准确率无统计学显著影响,所有P值均大于Holm-Sidak多重比较校正的α水平。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 支持向量机AUC 0.883(95%CI 0.793–0.940),人工神经网络AUC 0.829(95%CI 0.724–0.901),有经验阅片者AUC 0.843(95%CI 0.756–0.903),无经验阅片者AUC 0.702(95%CI 0.586–0.782)。
- CAD、无经验阅片者和有经验阅片者分别能分析95、100和102段动态录像。
- CAD与无经验阅片者一致时准确率从71.3%(67/94;95%CI 60.6%–79.8%)提高至87.7%(57/65;95%CI 78.5%–93.8%)。
- CAD与有经验阅片者一致时准确率从80.9%(76/94;95%CI 72.3%–88.3%)提高至90.3%(65/72;95%CI 80.6%–95.8%)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Purpose To assess the performance of computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) systems and to determine the dominant ultrasonographic (US) features when classifying benign versus malignant focal liver lesions (FLLs) by using contrast material-enhanced US cine clips. Materials and Methods One hundred six US data sets in all subjects enrolled by three centers from a multicenter trial that included 54 malignant, 51 benign, and one indeterminate FLL were retrospectively analyzed. The 105 benign or malignant lesions were confirmed at histologic examination, contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT), dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance (MR) imaging, and/or 6 or more months of clinical follow-up. Data sets included 3-minute cine clips that were automatically corrected for in-plane motion and automatically filtered out frames acquired off plane. B-mode and contrast-specific features were automatically extracted on a pixel-by-pixel basis and analyzed by using an artificial neural network (ANN) and a support vector machine (SVM). Areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUCs) for CAD were compared with those for one experienced and one inexperienced blinded reader. A third observer graded cine quality to assess its effects on CAD performance. Results CAD, the inexperienced observer, and the experienced observer were able to analyze 95, 100, and 102 cine clips, respectively. The AUCs for the SVM, ANN, and experienced and inexperienced observers were 0.883 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.793, 0.940), 0.829 (95% CI: 0.724, 0.901), 0.843 (95% CI: 0.756, 0.903), and 0.702 (95% CI: 0.586, 0.782), respectively; only the difference between SVM and the inexperienced observer was statistically significant. Accuracy improved from 71.3% (67 of 94; 95% CI: 60.6%, 79.8%) to 87.7% (57 of 65; 95% CI: 78.5%, 93.8%) and from 80.9% (76 of 94; 95% CI: 72.3%, 88.3%) to 90.3% (65 of 72; 95% CI: 80.6%, 95.8%) when CAD was in agreement with the inexperienced reader and when it was in agreement with the experienced reader, respectively. B-mode heterogeneity and contrast material washout were the most discriminating features selected by CAD for all iterations. CAD selected time-based time-intensity curve (TIC) features 99.0% (207 of 209) of the time to classify FLLs, versus 1.0% (two of 209) of the time for intensity-based features. None of the 15 video-quality criteria had a statistically significant effect on CAD accuracy-all P values were greater than the Holm-Sidak α-level correction for multiple comparisons. Conclusion CAD systems classified benign and malignant FLLs with an accuracy similar to that of an expert reader. CAD improved the accuracy of both readers. Time-based features of TIC were more discriminating than intensity-based features. © RSNA, 2017 Online supplemental material is available for this article.
引用
- Ta CN, Kono Y, Eghtedari M, et al. Focal Liver Lesions: Computer-aided Diagnosis by Using Contrast-enhanced US Cine Recordings. Radiology. 2017. PMID: 29072980. doi:10.1148/radiol.2017170365
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。