依据RECIST 1.1评估观察者间变异性及其对CT测量肝转移瘤疗效分类的影响
100名放射科医生对3例患者化疗前后CT上的肝靶病灶进行测量,以一位经验丰富放射科医生的评估为金标准。观察者间一致率较高,但超过30%的观察者至少在3例中的1例与复核者分类不一致;与复核者一致的多数为高年资医生,不一致的多数为低年资医生,但差异未达统计学显著。
要点
- 超过30%的观察者至少在3例中的1例与金标准复核者的疗效分类不一致。
- 与复核者一致的多数为高年资放射科医生,不一致的多数为低年资医生,但差异未达统计学显著。
- 作者认为年龄和放射科医生经验仍是最关键因素,提示临床试验中应由经验丰富的放射科医生复核。
核心结论
- RECIST测量在大型且异质的放射科医生群体中具有可重复性;年龄和放射科医生经验仍是最关键因素,这提示临床试验中应由经验丰富的放射科医生复核。
研究设计与样本
- 共100名放射科医生在3例患者化疗前后CT扫描上测量肝靶病灶,并与一位被视作金标准的有经验放射科医生的评估进行比较;每名观察者填写关于个人和工作特征的问卷。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为年龄和放射科医生经验仍是最关键因素,提示临床试验中应由经验丰富的放射科医生复核;超过30%的观察者至少在3例中的1例与复核者分类不一致。
局限性
- 与复核者一致的多数为高年资放射科医生、不一致的多数为低年资放射科医生,但该结果未达统计学显著。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is the evaluation of inter-observer variability in the measurement of liver metastases according to RECIST and its influence on response classification.
PATIENTS AND METHODS: A total of 100 radiologists measured liver target lesions, on pre- and post-chemotherapy CT scans of three patients. Each observer filled out a questionnaire about his personal and work features. The evaluations of a well experienced radiologist, considered as "the gold standard", were compared to those taken by the observers. The percentage of the observers in agreement with the reviewer, in terms of the response category and in terms of inter-observer variability, was calculated for each patient.
RESULTS: The percentage of the inter-observer agreement was elevated. Most of the observers in agreement with the reviewer were senior radiologists, while those who disagreed were junior radiologist, but this result did not reach a statistical significance. More than 30% of observers disagreed with the reviewer at least in one of the three cases.
CONCLUSIONS: RECIST measurements are reproducible on a large and heterogeneous population of radiologists. Age and expertise of the radiologist remain the most critical factors: this suggests a revision by well-experienced radiologists in clinical trials.
引用
- Bellomi M, De Piano F, Ancona E, et al. Evaluation of inter-observer variability according to RECIST 1.1 and its influence on response classification in CT measurement of liver metastases. Eur J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28987705. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2017.08.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。