文献速递胸部CT

肺结节边缘形态对CT肺癌筛查中基于容积和直径的阅片者变异性的影响

Influence of lung nodule margin on volume- and diameter-based reader variability in CT lung cancer screening.
PubMed 文献 · Br J Radiol · 2017-11-08

从荷兰-比利时肺癌筛查试验(NELSON)93名参与者中按边缘形态(光滑、分叶、毛刺、不规则)各随机选取25个实性结节,评估边缘形态对三名放射科医生手动直径测量及半自动容积测量一致性的影响。手动直径测量在所有形态类别均存在显著系统误差(达1.2 mm),毛刺和不规则结节的阅片者间变异超过LungRADS 1.5 mm增长阈值,导致结节生长误分类;半自动容积测量无显著系统误差,该影响几乎可忽略。

要点

  • 手动直径测量的阅片者间变异在毛刺和不规则结节中超过LungRADS 1.5 mm增长阈值,可致生长误分类。
  • 半自动容积测量无显著系统误差,边缘形态对其阅片者间变异影响几乎可忽略。
  • 对毛刺和不规则结节,手动直径测量变异幅度超过25%容积增长阈值。

核心结论

  • 基于手动直径测量的肺结节大小评估受结节边缘影响,毛刺和不规则结节的阅片者间变异增大并导致结节生长的明显误分类,该效应在半自动容积测量中几乎可忽略。

研究设计与样本

  • 从荷兰-比利时肺癌筛查试验(NELSON)93名参与者中按边缘形态(光滑、分叶、毛刺、不规则)各随机选取25个实性结节,使用Syngo LungCARE®软件(Somaris/5 VB10A-W版,西门子,德国福希海姆)行半自动容积测量,三名放射科医生独立手动测量平均直径,以系统误差和95%一致性界限评估阅片者间变异。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 手动直径测量阅片者间变异:光滑结节±1.9 mm(+27%),分叶结节±2.0 mm(+33%),毛刺结节±3.5 mm(+133%),不规则结节±4.5 mm(+200%),均超过LungRADS 1.5 mm直径增长阈值;25%容积增长阈值被毛刺结节28%(+12%)和不规则结节27%(+8%)轻度超过。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者结论认为半自动容积测量在肺结节大小和生长判定方面优于手动直径测量。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE:: To evaluate the influence of nodule margin on inter- and intrareader variability in manual diameter measurements and semi-automatic volume measurements of solid nodules detected in low-dose CT lung cancer screening.

METHODS:: 25 nodules of each morphological category (smooth, lobulated, spiculated and irregular) were randomly selected from 93 participants of the Dutch-Belgian Randomized Lung Cancer Screening Trial (NELSON). Semi-automatic volume measurements were performed using Syngo LungCARE® software (Version Somaris/5 VB10A-W, Siemens, Forchheim, Germany). Three radiologists independently measured mean diameters manually. Impact of nodule margin on interreader variability was evaluated based on systematic error and 95% limits of agreement. Interreader variability was compared with the nodule growth cut-off as used in Lung CT Screening Reporting and Data System (LungRADS; +1.5-mm diameter) and the Dutch-Belgian Randomized Lung Cancer Screening Trial(acronym: NELSON) /British Thoracic Society (+25% volume).

RESULTS:: For manual diameter measurements, a significant systematic error (up to 1.2 mm) between readers was found in all morphological categories. For semi-automatic volume measurements, no statistically significant systematic error was found. The interreader variability in mean diameter measurements exceeded the 1.5-mm cut-off for nodule growth for all morphological categories [smooth: ±1.9 mm (+27%), lobulated: ±2.0 mm (+33%), spiculated: ±3.5 mm (+133%), irregular: ±4.5 mm (+200%)]. The 25% vol growth cut-off was exceeded slightly for spiculated [28% (+12%)] and irregular [27% (+8%)] nodules.

CONCLUSION:: Lung nodule sizing based on manual diameter measurement is affected by nodule margin. Interreader variability increases especially for nodules with spiculated and irregular margins, and causes substantial misclassification of nodule growth. This effect is almost neglectable for semi-automated volume measurements. Semi-automatic volume measurements are superior for both size and growth determination of pulmonary nodules.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE:: Nodule assessment based on manual diameter measurements is susceptible to nodule margin. This effect is almost neglectable for semi-automated volume measurements. The larger interreader variability for manual diameter measurement results in inaccurate lung nodule growth detection and size classification.

来源:Br J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Han D, Heuvelmans MA, Vliegenthart R, et al. Influence of lung nodule margin on volume- and diameter-based reader variability in CT lung cancer screening. Br J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28972803. doi:10.1259/bjr.20170405

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。