技师主导的肌肉骨骼与胸部X线重复摄影:对诊断的影响频率
本研究纳入95例肌肉骨骼和87例胸部X线检查,技师因图像质量欠佳重复拍摄并将原图排除于PACS外。放射科医师回顾评审发现,多数重复摄影未增加显著临床信息或改变诊断,却增加了辐射暴露;是否重拍应在结合全部图像后由放射科医师决定。
要点
- 仅28.4%的肌肉骨骼和3.4%的胸部重复摄影被认为提供了有助于回答临床问题的额外信息。
- 77.9%的肌肉骨骼和93.1%的胸部被拒图像,不重拍即可满足临床需求。
- 重拍决策宜在结合整组图像后由放射科医师而非技师做出。
核心结论
- 多数重复摄影(胸部较肌肉骨骼更明显)未增加显著临床信息或改变诊断,尽管增加了辐射暴露;重拍决策应在结合整组图像后由放射科医师做出可能最佳。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性纳入95例肌肉骨骼和87例胸部X线检查,均为技师因图像质量欠佳重复拍摄并将原图排除于PACS提交之外;被拒图像从X线设备取回并上传至专用服务器,由肌肉骨骼和胸部放射科医师按时间顺序评审被拒图像和重复图像及检查其余图像。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 评审放射科医师同意肌肉骨骼图像被拒原因的比例为64.2%,胸部为60.9%。
- 被拒肌肉骨骼图像中77.9%可不重拍即满足临床需求,胸部为93.1%。
- 重复肌肉骨骼图像中75.8%显示图像质量改善,胸部为64.4%。
- 重复肌肉骨骼图像中28.4%被认为提供有助于回答临床问题的额外信息,胸部为3.4%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,决定是否重拍图像应在结合检查中所有图像评审可疑图像后做出。
- 作者认为,重拍决策可能最好由放射科医师而非执行技师做出。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Radiologic technologists may repeat images within a radiographic examination because of perceived suboptimal image quality, excluding these original images from submission to a PACS. This study assesses the appropriateness of technologists' decisions to repeat musculoskeletal and chest radiographs as well as the utility of repeat radiographs in addressing examinations' clinical indication.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We included 95 musculoskeletal and 87 chest radiographic examinations in which the technologist repeated one or more images because of perceived image quality issues, rejecting original images from PACS submission. Rejected images were retrieved from the radiograph unit and uploaded for viewing on a dedicated server. Musculoskeletal and chest radiologists reviewed rejected and repeat images in their timed sequence, in addition to the studies' remaining images. Radiologists answered questions regarding the added value of repeat images.
RESULTS: The reviewing radiologist agreed with the reason for rejection for 64.2% of musculoskeletal and 60.9% of chest radiographs. For 77.9% and 93.1% of rejected radiographs, the clinical inquiry could have been satisfied without repeating the image. For 75.8% and 64.4%, the repeated images showed improved image quality. Only 28.4% and 3.4% of repeated images were considered to provide additional information that was helpful in addressing the clinical question.
CONCLUSION: Most repeated radiographs (chest more so than musculoskeletal radiographs) did not add significant clinical information or alter diagnosis, although they did increase radiation exposure. The decision to repeat images should be made after viewing the questionable image in context with all images in a study and might best be made by a radiologist rather than the performing technologist.
引用
- Rosenkrantz AB, Jacobs JE, Jain N, et al. Technologist-Directed Repeat Musculoskeletal and Chest Radiographs: How Often Do They Impact Diagnosis? AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2017. PMID: 28898128. doi:10.2214/AJR.17.18030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。