英国医院急性胰腺炎影像使用情况:一项全国医疗质量研究结果
该全国质量研究分析了2014年上半年英国医院4,479例急性胰腺炎患者,其中712例完成问卷、418例经病例审查。CT使用时机在90%患者中恰当,但超声被不当遗漏至少21%;作者认为应更多使用影像排除胆结石,包括疑似酒精性急性胰腺炎。
要点
- 仅12%患者需影像诊断急性胰腺炎,CT主要用于病情管理且使用时机90%恰当。
- 超声诊断胆结石46.4%、胆管扩张12.9%,但至少21%患者被不当遗漏超声。
- MRCP诊断胆结石62.4%、胆管扩张25.4%、胆总管结石14.4%。
核心结论
- 影像很少用于诊断急性胰腺炎;CT在急性胰腺炎管理中应用合理。
- 应更多使用影像排除胆结石,包括推测为酒精相关的急性胰腺炎。
- 除非同步更早治疗胆结石,否则增加诊断努力不会减少复发性胆源性急性胰腺炎。
研究设计与样本
- 全国医疗质量研究,纳入2014年前6个月英国医院诊断急性胰腺炎的4,479例患者。
- 国家机密调查入患者结局与死亡(NCEPOD)选择较重症急性胰腺炎患者进行病例审查。
- 临床医生完成712份问卷,病例审查者评估418例。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 急性胰腺炎常见病因为胆结石46.5%、酒精过量22%,17.5%未明确病因。
- 12%患者需要影像诊断急性胰腺炎;60.1%患者接受一次或多次CT扫描。
- CT扫描时机在90%患者中恰当;CT次数除6.6%外均恰当,6.6%中过多与过少各半。
- 69.8%接受超声,诊断胆结石46.4%、胆管扩张12.9%;至少21%被不当遗漏超声。
- 29.8%接受磁共振胰胆管成像,诊断胆结石62.4%、胆管扩张25.4%、胆总管结石14.4%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 急性胰腺炎集合干预中放射学干预为49/613,外科干预为23/613。
- 20.6%为复发性胰腺炎,其中胆结石占三分之一。
- 胆结石性急性胰腺炎中17%在指南推荐时间窗内接受胆囊切除术。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To assess use of imaging in patients admitted to UK hospitals with acute pancreatitis (AP).
METHODS: 4,479 patients had a diagnosis AP in the first 6 months of 2014. The National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death (NCEPOD) selected patients with more severe AP for case review. Clinicians completed 712 questionnaires and case reviewers assessed 418 cases. The use of imaging in patients with AP is reported.
RESULTS: The common causes of AP were gallstones (46.5%) and alcohol excess (22%) with no cause identified in 17.5%. Imaging was needed to diagnose AP in 12%. 60.1% of patients had one or more CT scan. The timing of the CT scan(s) was appropriate in 90% of patients. The number of CTs was appropriate in all except 6.6% (equally split between too many and too few). AP collection intervention was radiological in 49/613 and surgical in 23/613. 69.8% had an ultrasound scan which diagnosed gallstones in 46.4% and bile duct dilatation in 12.9%. At least 21% had ultrasound scan inappropriately omitted. The National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death recommends gallstones are excluded in all patients with AP, including suspected alcohol-related AP. 29.8% underwent magnetic resonance cholangio--pancreatography diagnosing gallstones in 62.4%, bile duct dilatation in 25.4% and common bile duct stones in 14.4%. 20.6% had recurrent pancreatitis with gallstones accounting for a third. 17% with gallstone AP had a cholecystectomy within the guideline recommended time period.
CONCLUSION: Imaging is rarely required for the diagnosis of AP. CT is used responsibly in AP management. Imaging should be used more to exclude gallstones, including in presumed alcohol related AP. Increased diagnostic efforts will not reduce recurrent biliary AP unless matched by earlier gallstone treatment. Advances in knowledge: Whilst CT is used responsibly in AP greater use of other diagnostic modalities is required to identify reversible causes, in particular gallstones, in order to prevent recurrent AP.
引用
- McPherson SJ, O'Reilly DA, Sinclair MT, et al. The use of imaging in acute pancreatitis in United Kingdom hospitals: findings from a national quality of care study. Br J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28869389. doi:10.1259/bjr.20170224
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。