类风湿关节炎超声滑膜炎评分:EULAR-OMERACT超声工作组第二部分——标准化共识评分系统在多关节的信度与应用
EULAR-OMERACT超声工作组分步测试了滑膜肥厚和能量多普勒信号新定义及联合评分在类风湿关节炎患者多个关节的信度。标准化扫描下掌指关节联合评分观察者间κ=0.86,其他关节亦显示良好至优秀信度。该评分系统应有助于提高超声在类风湿关节炎临床试验中的信度和反应性。
要点
- 标准化扫描下掌指关节EULAR-OMERACT联合评分观察者间κ=0.86。
- 非掌指关节(腕、近端指间、膝、跖趾)同样适用该评分,静态图像观察者内κ=0.8-0.97。
- 标准化扫描可提高观察者间信度,滑膜肥厚κ=0.87、能量多普勒κ=0.79。
核心结论
- EULAR-OMERACT评分在标准化扫描下对掌指关节显示中等至良好信度,并同样适用于非掌指关节;该评分系统应有助于提高超声在类风湿关节炎临床试验中的信度和反应性。
研究设计与样本
- 分步信度研究:第一步在基于网络的练习中评估掌指关节静态图像,随后对患者进行扫描评分;第二步在基于网络的练习中评估腕、近端指间关节、膝和跖趾关节静态图像,随后以标准化扫描与常规实践两种采集方式对患者进行扫描评分;信度采用kappa系数(κ)评价。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 掌指关节静态图像评分显示观察者内变异较大,但观察者间信度为良好至优秀。
- 患者扫描中,两种采集方法的观察者内信度相同。
- 采用标准化扫描时,观察者间信度滑膜肥厚κ=0.87、能量多普勒κ=0.79、EULAR-OMERACT联合评分κ=0.86。
- 其他关节静态图像所有评分的观察者内信度为优秀(κ=0.8-0.97),观察者间信度略低。
- 患者标准化扫描时,观察者内信度良好(滑膜肥厚和EULAR-OMERACT联合评分κ=0.64,能量多普勒κ=0.66);观察者间信度亦良好,尤其能量多普勒(κ范围=0.41-0.92)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 采用标准化扫描采集图像可提高掌指关节滑膜肥厚、能量多普勒及联合评分的观察者间信度。
- 该评分系统除掌指关节外,也可应用于腕、近端指间关节、膝和跖趾关节。
- 作者认为该评分系统应有助于提高超声在类风湿关节炎临床试验中的信度和反应性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To test the reliability of new ultrasound (US) definitions and quantification of synovial hypertrophy (SH) and power Doppler (PD) signal, separately and in combination, in a range of joints in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) using the European League Against Rheumatisms-Outcomes Measures in Rheumatology (EULAR-OMERACT) combined score for PD and SH.
METHODS: A stepwise approach was used: (1) scoring static images of metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joints in a web-based exercise and subsequently when scanning patients; (2) scoring static images of wrist, proximal interphalangeal joints, knee and metatarsophalangeal joints in a web-based exercise and subsequently when scanning patients using different acquisitions (standardised vs usual practice). For reliability, kappa coefficients (κ) were used.
RESULTS: Scoring MCP joints in static images showed substantial intraobserver variability but good to excellent interobserver reliability. In patients, intraobserver reliability was the same for the two acquisition methods. Interobserver reliability for SH (κ=0.87) and PD (κ=0.79) and the EULAR-OMERACT combined score (κ=0.86) were better when using a 'standardised' scan. For the other joints, the intraobserver reliability was excellent in static images for all scores (κ=0.8-0.97) and the interobserver reliability marginally lower. When using standardised scanning in patients, the intraobserver was good (κ=0.64 for SH and the EULAR-OMERACT combined score, 0.66 for PD) and the interobserver reliability was also good especially for PD (κ range=0.41-0.92).
CONCLUSION: The EULAR-OMERACT score demonstrated moderate-good reliability in MCP joints using a standardised scan and is equally applicable in non-MCP joints. This scoring system should underpin improved reliability and consequently the responsiveness of US in RA clinical trials.
引用
- Terslev L, Naredo E, Aegerter P, et al. Scoring ultrasound synovitis in rheumatoid arthritis: a EULAR-OMERACT ultrasound taskforce-Part 2: reliability and application to multiple joints of a standardised consensus-based scoring system. RMD Open. 2017. PMID: 28948984. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2016-000427
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。