慢性疼痛的脑影像检查:医学、法律与伦理问题及建议
国际疼痛研究协会主席工作组发布共识声明,审视脑影像用于慢性疼痛诊断的能力及伦理法律影响。工作组强调该应用尚处探索阶段,提出任何脑影像指标用于临床或法律目的前必须满足的证据标准,并结论:用脑影像发现支持或质疑慢性疼痛主张(即当作疼痛测谎仪)缺乏依据,但影像应继续用于深化对疼痛机制的理解。
要点
- 脑影像用于慢性疼痛诊断尚处探索阶段,目前不能作为疼痛测谎仪。
- 工作组提出脑影像指标用于临床或法律目的前须满足的证据标准。
- 脑影像证据在法庭的可采性取决于不同司法辖区的法律。
核心结论
- 用脑影像发现支持或质疑慢性疼痛主张(即当作疼痛测谎仪)缺乏依据。
- 脑影像应继续用于深化对疼痛机制的理解、指导治疗药物开发并预测治疗结局以服务于个体化疼痛管理。
研究设计与样本
- 国际疼痛研究协会主席工作组发布的共识声明,审视脑影像(如功能MRI、PET、EEG和脑磁图)在慢性疼痛诊断中的能力及伦理法律影响。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 工作组提出任何脑影像指标在可被认为适用于临床或法律目的之前必须满足的证据标准。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 工作组结论认为,用脑影像发现支持或质疑慢性疼痛主张(即当作疼痛测谎仪)缺乏依据。
- 脑影像应继续用于深化对疼痛机制的理解、指导治疗药物开发并预测治疗结局以服务于个体化疼痛管理。
局限性
- 工作组强调脑影像在此背景下的应用尚处探索阶段。
- 脑影像证据在法庭的可采性还强烈取决于不同司法辖区各异的现行法律。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Chronic pain is the greatest source of disability globally and claims related to chronic pain feature in many insurance and medico-legal cases. Brain imaging (for example, functional MRI, PET, EEG and magnetoencephalography) is widely considered to have potential for diagnosis, prognostication, and prediction of treatment outcome in patients with chronic pain. In this Consensus Statement, a presidential task force of the International Association for the Study of Pain examines the capabilities of brain imaging in the diagnosis of chronic pain, and the ethical and legal implications of its use in this way. The task force emphasizes that the use of brain imaging in this context is in a discovery phase, but has the potential to increase our understanding of the neural underpinnings of chronic pain, inform the development of therapeutic agents, and predict treatment outcomes for use in personalized pain management. The task force proposes standards of evidence that must be satisfied before any brain imaging measure can be considered suitable for clinical or legal purposes. The admissibility of such evidence in legal cases also strongly depends on laws that vary between jurisdictions. For these reasons, the task force concludes that the use of brain imaging findings to support or dispute a claim of chronic pain - effectively as a pain lie detector - is not warranted, but that imaging should be used to further our understanding of the mechanisms underlying pain.
引用
- Davis KD, Flor H, Greely HT, et al. Brain imaging tests for chronic pain: medical, legal and ethical issues and recommendations. Nat Rev Neurol. 2017. PMID: 28884750. doi:10.1038/nrneurol.2017.122
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。