基于T2加权成像和扩散加权成像的前列腺PI-RADSv2词典描述符的诊断效能与可重复性
研究分析了79例连续患者共176个病灶的多参数前列腺MRI,由两名盲法独立放射科医生按PI-RADSv2词典对T2w和DWI描述符及评估类别进行评分,并以MRI-超声融合活检病理为参考标准。PI-RADSv2评估类别的AUC为0.76/0.74(放射科医生1/2),P>0.05;外周带与移行带评估类别加权kappa分别为0.601和0.580;描述符分配的一致性最高仅为中等(kappa 0.082–0.493)。PI-RADSv2第3类的外周带癌率32%与移行带12%存在差异,P<0.05。
要点
- PI-RADSv2评估类别诊断效能AUC为0.76/0.74(放射科医生1/2),P>0.05。
- 外周带与移行带评估类别加权kappa分别为0.601和0.580。
- 描述符分配一致性最高为中等,kappa范围0.082–0.493。
核心结论
- PI-RADSv2词典描述符分配的一致性在本研究中最高仅为中等。
- 典型良恶性描述符得到验证,但部分描述符的鉴别能力受到质疑。
- PI-RADSv2第3类在外周带与移行带之间的癌率差异,未来将管理建议与评估类别挂钩时应予以考虑。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入79例连续患者共176个病灶,病灶经MRI-超声融合活检病理验证。
- 所有病灶按PI-RADSv2词典由两名独立盲法放射科医生对T2w和DWI序列描述符及评估类别进行评分。
- 采用受试者工作特征分析评估评估类别的诊断效能,计算加权kappa值分析评估类别一致性、非加权kappa值分析描述符分配一致性。
关键影像表现/征象
- 外周带T2w楔形病灶虽在词典中被标为第2类,但具有相当可观的癌率。
诊断标准与关键数值
- PI-RADSv2评估类别AUC为0.76/0.74(放射科医生1/放射科医生2),P>0.05。
- 评估类别加权kappa在外周带为0.601、移行带为0.580。
- 描述符分配kappa值范围为0.082(移行带T2w形状)至0.407(外周带T2w信号强度)和0.493(外周带ADC模式)。
- PI-RADSv2第3类癌率外周带32% vs 移行带12%,P<0.05。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To examine the diagnostic performance of PI-RADSv2 T2w and diffusion weighted imaging (DWI) based lexicon descriptors, inter-observer agreement for descriptor assignment and diagnostic accuracy of the PI-RADSv2 assessment categories for multiparametric prostate MRI.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: 176 lesions in 79 consecutive patients are analyzed, lesions are histopathologically verified by MRI-ultrasound fusion biopsy. All lesions are rated according to the PI-RADSv2 lexicon, descriptors for T2w and DWI sequences and resulting assessment categories are assigned by two independent blinded radiologists. We perform receiver-operating-characteristic analysis using the assessment categories. To analyze inter-observer agreement, we calculate weighted kappa values for assessment category assignment and unweighted kappa values for descriptor assignment.
RESULTS: PI-RADSv2 assessment categories yield an area under the curve of 0.76/0.74 (radiologist 1/radiologist 2), P >0.05. Weighted kappa for agreement is 0.601 in the peripheral zone and 0.580 in the transition zone. We detect a difference in the cancer rate for PI-RADSv2 category 3 between peripheral zone (32%) and transition zone (12%), P <0.05. We obtain moderate agreement at most for descriptor assignment with kappa values ranging from 0.082 (T2w shape in the transition zone) to 0.407 (T2w signal intensity in the peripheral zone) and 0.493 (ADC pattern in the peripheral zone). Our analysis corroborates typical descriptors for benign/malignant lesions, but also reveals insights into potential pitfalls - T2w wedge shaped lesions in the peripheral zone have a considerable cancer rate, despite being labelled category 2 in the lexicon.
CONCLUSION: Agreement for descriptor assignment in the PI-RADSv2 lexicon is at most moderate in our study. Typical descriptors for benign and malignant lesions are validated, whereas the discriminatory power of some descriptors is challenged. The difference in the cancer rate for PI-RADSv2 category 3 between peripheral zone and transition zone should be considered when management recommendations are linked to assessment categories in the future.
引用
- Benndorf M, Hahn F, Krönig M, et al. Diagnostic performance and reproducibility of T2w based and diffusion weighted imaging (DWI) based PI-RADSv2 lexicon descriptors for prostate MRI. Eur J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28668436. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2017.05.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。