减少诊断延迟:多阶段建议追踪
本研究将589条除乳腺X线摄影外的影像学随访建议录入数据库并进行13个月的多阶段追踪。追踪干预后检查完成率从基线43.1%升至70.5%(提高52%),未知随访依从率降至13.9%(降低74%),追踪后完成的检查收入为人力成本的4.1倍。
要点
- 建议到期后1个月基线检查完成率仅43.1%,需多阶段追踪干预。
- 多阶段追踪使检查完成率升至70.5%(提高52%),未知依从率降至13.9%(降低74%)。
- 追踪后完成检查的收入为人力成本的4.1倍。
核心结论
- 序贯性影像学建议追踪干预可大幅降低未知随访依从率并为卫生系统增加价值。
研究设计与样本
- 将589条除乳腺X线摄影外所有诊断影像模态的无条件影像随访建议录入数据库,通过多阶段追踪系统追踪13个月。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 基线在建议到期后1个月通过放射科信息系统核查,及时完成率为43.1%。
- 三种独立追踪干预的有效性介于29.0%至57.8%之间。
- 多阶段追踪系统将检查完成率提高至70.5%(提高52%)。
- 未知随访依从率及相关诊断延迟风险降至13.9%(降低74%)。
- 追踪干预后完成的检查收入为人力成本的4.1倍。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对建议到期后1个月仍未完成随访的患者启动追踪干预。
- 干预后依从需满足检查完成或临床闭环(活检、预期寿命有限或死亡、亚专科转诊)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to determine whether a multistage tracking system could improve communication between health care providers, reducing the risk of delay in diagnosis related to inconsistent communication and tracking of radiology follow-up recommendations.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Unconditional recommendations for imaging follow-up of all diagnostic imaging modalities excluding mammography (n = 589) were entered into a database and tracked through a multistage tracking system for 13 months. Tracking interventions were performed for patients for whom completion of recommended follow-up imaging could not be identified 1 month after the recommendation due date. Postintervention compliance with the follow-up recommendation required examination completion or clinical closure (i.e., biopsy, limited life expectancy or death, or subspecialist referral).
RESULTS: Baseline radiology information system checks performed 1 month after the recommendation due date revealed timely completion of 43.1% of recommended imaging studies at our institution before intervention. Three separate tracking interventions were studied, showing effectiveness between 29.0% and 57.8%. The multistage tracking system increased the examination completion rate to 70.5% (a 52% increase) and reduced the rate of unknown follow-up compliance and the associated risk of delay in diagnosis to 13.9% (a 74% decrease). Examinations completed after tracking intervention generated revenue of 4.1 times greater than the labor cost.
CONCLUSION: Performing sequential radiology recommendation tracking interventions can substantially reduce the rate of unknown follow-up compliance and add value to the health system. Unknown follow-up compliance is a risk factor for delay in diagnosis, a form of preventable medical error commonly identified in malpractice claims involving radiologists and office-based practitioners.
引用
- Wandtke B, Gallagher S. Reducing Delay in Diagnosis: Multistage Recommendation Tracking. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2017. PMID: 28742377. doi:10.2214/AJR.17.18332
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。