沸腾组织碎裂术治疗效率对高强度聚焦超声频率和焦点压力水平的依赖性
研究利用12阵元扇形阵列高强度聚焦超声换能器,在聚丙烯酰胺凝胶体模和离体牛肝、心肌组织上观察不同频率(1–1.9 MHz)和焦点峰值负压下的沸腾组织碎裂术。结果显示空化气泡云可在前焦区形成并遮挡焦点,频率1.2–1.5 MHz在消融速率与可靠性间较可取;脉冲数恒定时病灶大小与脉冲时长无关,采用更短(1 ms vs. 10 ms)更高幅度的脉冲可在相同占空比下将治疗时间最多缩短10倍。
要点
- 在1和1.2 MHz所有曝光及1.5–1.7 MHz最高幅度曝光中,凝胶体模前焦区形成空化气泡云遮挡焦点,1.9 MHz未观察到遮挡。
- 离体组织中当1 MHz峰值负压超过10.2 MPa、1.5 MHz超过14.5 MPa时,25%的曝光出现遮挡效应,仅造成前焦区轻度组织破碎而非液化。
- 脉冲数恒定且每脉冲均诱导沸腾时,液化病灶大小与脉冲时长无关,1 ms较10 ms脉冲可在相同占空比下将治疗时间最多缩短10倍。
核心结论
- 液化病灶尺寸随频率呈反比趋势,1.2–1.5 MHz频率范围在消融速率与可靠性之间似乎较可取;脉冲数恒定时病灶大小与脉冲时长无关,更短(1 ms vs. 10 ms)更高幅度的脉冲可在给定占空比下将治疗时间最多缩短10倍。
研究设计与样本
- 实验研究,使用自制12阵元扇形阵列高强度聚焦超声换能器(F数=1.05),在光学透明聚丙烯酰胺凝胶体模和离体牛肝、心肌组织上施加5种频率(1、1.2、1.5、1.7、1.9 MHz)的沸腾组织碎裂术脉冲,分别用高速摄影和B型超声观察空化和沸腾气泡活动。
关键影像表现/征象
- 凝胶体模中,1和1.2 MHz所有曝光及1.5–1.7 MHz最高幅度曝光均见前焦区空化气泡云形成并遮挡焦点,1.9 MHz未观察到遮挡。
- 离体组织中,1 MHz峰值负压超过10.2 MPa、1.5 MHz超过14.5 MPa时,25%的曝光出现遮挡效应。
- 发生遮挡时曝光导致前焦区轻度组织破碎,但未发生液化。
- 液化病灶尺寸随频率呈反比趋势。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 离体组织遮挡效应判据:1 MHz峰值负压超过10.2 MPa、1.5 MHz超过14.5 MPa时25%曝光出现遮挡。
- 液化病灶尺寸与频率呈反比 proportionality 趋势,1.2–1.5 MHz在消融速率与可靠性间似乎较可取。
- 脉冲数恒定且每脉冲内诱导沸腾时,病灶大小与脉冲时长(或总HIFU开启时间)无关。
- 相同占空比下,1 ms较10 ms脉冲可将治疗时间最多缩短10倍。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 行沸腾组织碎裂术时需注意前焦区空化气泡云遮挡焦点可致组织仅轻度破碎而不液化,1 MHz峰值负压超过10.2 MPa、1.5 MHz超过14.5 MPa时离体组织25%曝光出现该效应。
- 选择1.2–1.5 MHz频率范围可能兼顾消融速率与可靠性。
- 脉冲数恒定时采用更短(1 ms vs. 10 ms)更高幅度脉冲可在相同占空比下最多缩短治疗时间10倍。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Boiling histotripsy (BH) is a high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU)-based method of mechanical tissue fractionation that utilizes millisecond-long bursts of HIFU shock waves to cause boiling at the focus in milliseconds. The subsequent interaction of the incoming shocks with the vapor bubble mechanically lyses surrounding tissue and cells. The acoustic parameter space for BH has been investigated previously and an inverse dependence between the HIFU frequency and the dimensions of a BH lesion has been observed. The primary goal of the present study was to investigate in more detail the ablation rate and reliability of BH in the frequency range relevant to treatment of deep abdominal tissue targets (1-2 MHz). The second goal was to investigate the effect of focal peak pressure levels and shock amplitude on BH lesion formation, given a constant duty factor, a constant ratio of the pulse duration to the time to reach boiling and a constant number of BH pulses. A custom-built 12-element sector array HIFU transducer with F-number = 1.05 was used in all experiments. BH pulses at 5 different frequencies (1, 1.2, 1.5, 1.7 and 1.9 MHz) were delivered to optically transparent polyacrylamide gel phantoms and ex vivo bovine liver and myocardium tissue to observe cavitation and boiling bubble activity with high-speed photography and B-mode ultrasound imaging, correspondingly. In gel phantoms, a cavitation bubble cloud was shown to form prefocally and to shield the focus in all exposures at 1 and 1.2 MHz and in the highest amplitude exposures at 1.5-1.7 MHz; shielding was not observed at 1.9 MHz. In ex vivo tissue, this shielding effect was observed in 25% of exposures when peak negative in situ pressure exceeded 10.2 MPa at 1 MHz and 14.5 MPa at 1.5 MHz. When shielding occurred, the exposures resulted in mild tissue disruption in the prefocal region, but not liquefaction. The dimensions of liquefied lesions followed the inverse proportionality trend with frequency; consequently, the frequency range of 1.2-1.5 MHz appeared to be preferable for BH exposures in terms of the compromise between the ablation rate and reliability. The lesion size was independent of the duration of the BH pulses (or the total "HIFU on" time), provided that the number of pulses was constant and boiling was induced within each pulse. Thus, the use of shorter (1 ms vs. 10 ms), higher amplitude BH pulses allowed up to 10-fold reduction in treatment time for a given duty factor.
引用
- Khokhlova TD, Haider YA, Maxwell AD, et al. Dependence of Boiling Histotripsy Treatment Efficiency on HIFU Frequency and Focal Pressure Levels. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2017. PMID: 28641910. doi:10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2017.04.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。