迭代重建低剂量CT对亚实性结节检出性能:20 mA(7 mAs)与120 mA(42 mAs)在结节大小、特征及与体型特异性剂量估计关联方面的比较
日本多中心研究纳入68例受试者,比较7 mAs(0.21 mSv)与42 mAs(1.28 mSv)胸部CT在AIDR 3D重建下对亚实性结节的检出性能。对于长径≥5 mm的亚实性结节,两种剂量检出性能相似(AUC 0.96±0.02 vs 0.97±0.01),且7 mAs条件下SSDE≥0.65 mGy的四组检出敏感度优于SSDE<0.65 mGy组。
要点
- 长径≥5 mm的亚实性结节,7 mAs与42 mAs的检出AUC分别为0.96±0.02和0.97±0.01,性能相似。
- 7 mAs条件下,SSDE≥0.65 mGy的四组检出敏感度优于SSDE<0.65 mGy组。
- 42 mAs条件下,按SSDE分组的五组间检出敏感度无显著差异。
核心结论
- 对于长径≥5 mm的亚实性结节且体型正常者,7 mAs与42 mAs的检出性能相当,且SSDE高于0.65 mGy有助于获得足够的检出敏感度。
研究设计与样本
- 日本多中心研究(Area-detector Computed Tomography for the Investigation of Thoracic Diseases Study的一部分),68例受试者行120 kV、0.35秒/旋转、管电流240 mA(84 mAs)、120 mA(42 mAs)和20 mA(7 mAs)胸部CT,2 mm层厚轴位图像采用AIDR 3D重建,以84 mAs CT图像为标准参考,4名放射科医师对7 mAs和42 mAs图像进行连续评分。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 共识别22个部分实性和86个纯亚实性结节。
- 长径≥5 mm亚实性结节及按位置和部分实性分组的亚组中,7 mAs与42 mAs的检出AUC分别为0.96±0.02和0.97±0.01。
- 7 mAs条件下,SSDE≥0.65 mGy的四组检出敏感度优于SSDE<0.65 mGy组。
- 42 mAs条件下,按SSDE分组的五组间检出敏感度无显著差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to compare sub-solid nodule detection performances (SSNDP) on chest computed tomography (CT) with Adaptive Iterative Dose Reduction using Three Dimensional Processing (AIDR 3D) between 7 mAs (0.21 mSv) and 42 mAs (1.28 mSv) in total and in subgroups classified by nodular size, characteristics, and location, and analyze the association of SSNDP with size-specific dose estimate (SSDE).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: As part of the Area-detector Computed Tomography for the Investigation of Thoracic Diseases Study, a Japanese multicenter research project, 68 subjects underwent chest CT with 120 kV, 0.35 seconds per rotation, and three tube currents: 240 mA (84 mAs), 120 mA (42 mAs), and 20 mA (7 mAs). The research committee of the study project outlined and approved our study protocols. The institutional review board of each institution approved this study. Axial 2-mm-thick CT images were reconstructed using AIDR 3D. Standard reference was determined by CT images at 84 mAs. Four radiologists recorded SSN presence by continuously distributed rating on CT at 7 mAs and 42 mAs. Receiver operating characteristic analysis was used to evaluate SSNDP at both doses in total and in subgroups classified by nodular longest diameter (LD) (≥5 mm), characteristics (pure and part-solid), and locations (ventral, intermediate, or dorsal; central or peripheral; and upper, middle, or lower). Detection sensitivity was compared among five groups of SSNs classified based on particular SSDE to nodule on CT with AIDR 3D at 7 mAs.
RESULTS: Twenty-two part-solid and 86 pure SSNs were identified. For larger SSNs (LD ≥ 5 mm) as well as subgroups classified by nodular locations and part-solid nodules, SSNDP was similar in both methods (area under the receiver operating characteristics curve: 0.96 ± 0.02 in CT at 7 mAs and 0.97 ± 0.01 in CT at 42 mAs), with acceptable interobserver agreements in five locations. For larger SSNs (LD ≥ 5 mm), on CT at 42 mAs, no significant differences in detection sensitivity were found among the five groups classified by SSDE, whereas on CT with 7 mAs, four groups with SSDE of 0.65 or higher were superior in detection sensitivity to the other group, with SSDE less than 0.65 mGy.
CONCLUSIONS: For SSNs with 5 mm or more in cases with normal range of body habitus, CT at 7 mAs was demonstrated to have comparable SSNDP to CT at 42 mAs regardless of nodular location and characteristics, and SSDE higher than 0.65 mGy is desirable to obtain sufficient SSNDP.
引用
- Nagatani Y, Takahashi M, Ikeda M, et al. Sub-solid Nodule Detection Performance on Reduced-dose Computed Tomography with Iterative Reduction: Comparison Between 20 mA (7 mAs) and 120 mA (42 mAs) Regarding Nodular Size and Characteristics and Association with Size-specific Dose Estimate. Acad Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28606593. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2017.01.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。