文献速递胸部CT

前瞻性个体内比较标准剂量与缩减剂量胸部CT采用混合与纯迭代重建在肺结节随访队列中的效果:基于结节大小、类型和体重指数对肺结节检出率的影响

Prospective intra-individual comparison of standard dose versus reduced-dose thoracic CT using hybrid and pure iterative reconstruction in a follow-up cohort of pulmonary nodules-Effect of detectability of pulmonary nodules with lowering dose based on nodule size, type and body mass index.
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Radiol · 2017-04-15

前瞻性单中心研究纳入98例有书面知情同意的患者,在标准剂量胸部CT后行两种缩减剂量方案(自动管电流调制RD1与固定管电流RD2),并分别用FBP、ASIR和MBIR重建,分析肺结节检出诊断准确率。结果显示肺结节诊断性能受结节大小、方案、重建算法和患者体型影响;对≤4mm实性结节和≤5mm亚实性结节,RD1优于RD2(p<0.05),RD2的下降与患者体重指数相关且MBIR受影响最小。

要点

  • 对≤4mm实性结节,MBIR下RD1的AUC为0.935/0.913,RD2为0.739/0.739(阅片者1/2)。
  • 对≤5mm亚实性结节,MBIR下RD1的AUC为0.971/0.986,RD2为0.914/0.914(阅片者1/2)。
  • 钙化结节在各剂量与重建算法下AUC均>0.97,检出准确率保持优秀。

核心结论

  • 肺结节诊断性能受结节大小、扫描方案、重建算法和患者体型影响。
  • RD1在≤4mm实性结节和≤5mm亚实性结节评估中优于RD2(p<0.05)。
  • RD2的诊断性能下降与患者体重指数相关,且MBIR受影响最小。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性单中心研究,招募98例有书面知情同意的患者。
  • 先行标准剂量(STD)胸部CT,再行两种缩减剂量方案:自动管电流调制(RD1)和固定管电流(RD2)。
  • 各方案分别用FBP、ASIR和MBIR重建,进行肺结节检出诊断准确率分析。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 分析结节包括108个实性结节、47个亚实性结节和89个纯钙化结节。
  • ≤4mm实性结节:MBIR下RD1的AUC为0.935/0.913,RD2的AUC为0.739/0.739(阅片者1/阅片者2)。
  • ≤5mm亚实性结节:MBIR下RD1的AUC为0.971/0.986,RD2的AUC为0.914/0.914(阅片者1/阅片者2)。
  • 钙化结节:所有剂量和重建算法下两位阅片者AUC均>0.97。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: To determine the diagnostic accuracy of lung nodule detection in thoracic CT using 2 reduced dose protocols comparing 3 available CT reconstruction algorithms (filtered back projection-FBP, adaptive statistical reconstruction-ASIR and model-based iterative reconstruction-MBIR) in a western population.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: A prospective single-center study recruited 98 patients with written consent. Standard dose (STD) thoracic CT followed by 2 reduced-dose protocols using automatic tube current modulation (RD1) and fixed tube current (RD2) were performed and reconstructed with FBP, ASIR and MBIR with subsequent diagnostic accuracy analysis for nodule detection.

RESULTS: 108 solid nodules, 47 subsolid nodules and 89 purely calcified nodules were analyzed. RD1 was superior to RD2 for assessment of solid nodules ≤4mm, and subsolid nodules ≤5mm (p<0.05). Deterioration of RD2 is correlated to patient's body mass index and least affected by MBIR. For solid nodules ≤4mm, MBIR area under curve (AUC) for RD1 was 0.935/0.913 and AUC for RD2 was 0.739/0.739, for rater 1/rater2 respectively. For subsolid nodules ≤5mm, MBIR AUC for RD1 was 0.971/0.986 and AUC for RD2 was 0.914/0.914, for rater 1/rater2 respectively. For calcified nodules excellent detection accuracy was maintained regardless of reconstruction algorithms with AUC >0.97 for both readers across all dose and reconstruction algorithms.

CONCLUSIONS: Diagnostic performance of lung nodule is affected by nodule size, protocol, reconstruction algorithm and patient's body habitus. The protocol in this study showed that RD1 was superior to RD2 for assessment of solid nodules ≤4mm, and subsolid nodules ≤5mm and deterioration of RD2 is related to patient's body mass index.

来源:Eur J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Vardhanabhuti V, Pang CL, Tenant S, et al. Prospective intra-individual comparison of standard dose versus reduced-dose thoracic CT using hybrid and pure iterative reconstruction in a follow-up cohort of pulmonary nodules-Effect of detectability of pulmonary nodules with lowering dose based on nodule size, type and body mass index. Eur J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28629559. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2017.04.006

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。