计算机辅助脑出血体积量化模型与标准ABC/2手工体积计算相比在准确性、精确性和采集时间上的回顾性验证
在单中心76例脑出血CT病例中,2名血管神经内科医师和2名神经放射科医师用SegTool与ABC/2重复测量静态脑出血体积。SegTool测量值与真实体积无显著差异,ABC/2高估体积45%;SegTool组间测量变异性较ABC/2低50%,平均测量时间ABC/2为35.7秒、SegTool为44.6秒;作者认为SegTool在准确性和组间信度上似乎优于ABC/2,平均测量时间延迟9秒,可能可用于临床试验和实践。
要点
- SegTool测量脑出血体积与真实体积无显著差异,ABC/2高估体积45%。
- SegTool组间测量变异性较ABC/2低50%。
- 平均测量时间ABC/2为35.7秒,SegTool为44.6秒。
核心结论
- SegTool在准确性和组间信度上似乎优于ABC/2,平均测量时间延迟9秒,作者认为其可能可用于临床试验和实践。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性测试-再测试实验,纳入76例脑出血病例的静态CT,由2名血管神经内科医师和2名神经放射科医师独立使用SegTool与ABC/2重复测量,真实体积由2名操作者重复手工勾画的共识估计。
诊断标准与关键数值
- SegTool测量值与真实脑出血体积无显著差异。
- ABC/2高估脑出血体积45%。
- SegTool组间测量变异性较ABC/2低50%。
- 平均测量时间:ABC/2为35.7秒,SegTool为44.6秒。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为SegTool在准确性和组间信度上似乎优于ABC/2,平均测量时间延迟9秒,可能可用于临床试验和实践。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Intracerebral hemorrhage accounts for 6.5%-19.6% of all acute strokes. Initial intracerebral hemorrhage volume and expansion are both independent predictors of clinical outcomes and mortality. Therefore, a rapid, unbiased, and precise measurement of intracerebral hemorrhage volume is a key component of clinical management. The most commonly used method, ABC/2, results in overestimation. We developed an interactive segmentation program, SegTool, using a novel graphic processing unit, level set algorithm. Until now, the speed, bias, and precision of SegTool had not been validated.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In a single stroke academic center, 2 vascular neurologists and 2 neuroradiologists independently performed a test-retest experiment that involved repeat measurements of static, unchanging intracerebral hemorrhage volumes on CT from 76 intracerebral hemorrhage cases. Measurements were made with SegTool and ABC/2. True intracerebral hemorrhage volumes were estimated from a consensus of repeat manual tracings by 2 operators. These data allowed us to estimate measurement bias, precision, and speed.
RESULTS: The measurements with SegTool were not significantly different from the true intracerebral hemorrhage volumes, while ABC/2 overestimated volume by 45%. The interrater measurement variability with SegTool was 50% less than that with ABC/2. The average measurement times for ABC/2 and SegTool were 35.7 and 44.6 seconds, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: SegTool appears to have attributes superior to ABC/2 in terms of accuracy and interrater reliability with a 9-second delay in measurement time (on average); hence, it could be useful in clinical trials and practice.
引用
- Xue W, Vegunta S, Zwart CM, et al. Retrospective Validation of a Computer-Assisted Quantification Model of Intracerebral Hemorrhage Volume on Accuracy, Precision, and Acquisition Time, Compared with Standard ABC/2 Manual Volume Calculation. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2017. PMID: 28596188. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A5256
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。