文献速递神经儿科影像CTMR

儿童虐待性与非虐待性颅脑外伤患者头部CT影像判读误差

Radiologic head CT interpretation errors in pediatric abusive and non-abusive head trauma patients.
PubMed 文献 · Pediatr Radiol · 2017-05-11

该回顾性研究纳入184例5岁以下、因已知或疑似头部外伤在社区医院完成头部CT初诊判读的患儿,由两名儿科神经放射学专家独立判读并达成共识作为二次判读,用RADPEER评分比较初诊与二次判读的差异率。初诊与二次判读的总体差异率和重大差异率分别为28%和16%,显著高于两名专家之间的6%和1%;虐待性颅脑外伤组的初诊与二次判读差异率显著高于非虐待性组(总体41% vs 23%,重大26% vs 12%)。导致重大判读误差的最常见表现为骨折和硬膜下出血,二次判读更常提示虐待性颅脑外伤可能。

要点

  • 社区医院初诊判读与三级儿科医院二次判读的总体差异率为28%,重大差异率为16%。
  • 虐待性颅脑外伤组的初诊与二次判读总体差异率为41%、重大差异率为26%,均高于非虐待性组。
  • 导致重大判读误差的最常见表现为骨折和硬膜下出血。

核心结论

  • 来自社区医院转诊的、存在虐待性颅脑外伤风险的儿科外伤患者中,影像判读误差发生率较高,提示对该人群在三级儿科医院进行头部CT二次判读具有价值。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,纳入184例5岁以下、因已知或疑似头部外伤在社区医院由认证放射科医师完成头部CT初诊判读的患儿;由学术性儿科医院两名认证且完成专科培训的神经放射学专家独立判读并解决分歧形成共识二次判读;采用RADPEER评分系统比较初诊与共识二次判读;尽可能以MRI和/或手术所见验证初诊或二次判读;由儿童虐待专家根据临床和影像数据将患者分为虐待性颅脑外伤组与非虐待性颅脑外伤组。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 导致重大影像判读误差的最常见表现为骨折和硬膜下出血。
  • 虐待性颅脑外伤组与非虐待性颅脑外伤组在患者年龄和出血患者百分比上差异有统计学意义。
  • 颅骨骨折、缺血、头部CT辐射剂量以及多平面或三维重建图像的有无在两组间未发现统计学差异。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 初诊与二次判读总体差异率为28%,高于两名专家之间的总体差异率6%(P=0.0001)。
  • 初诊与二次判读重大差异率为16%,高于两名专家之间的重大差异率1%(P=0.0001)。
  • 虐待性颅脑外伤组初诊与二次判读总体差异率为41%,高于非虐待性颅脑外伤组的23%(P=0.02)。
  • 虐待性颅脑外伤组初诊与二次判读重大差异率为26%,高于非虐待性颅脑外伤组的12%(P=0.03)。
  • 存在判读差异的患者中,MRI和/或手术所见与二次判读一致者为29/29(100%)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 对来自社区医院、存在虐待性颅脑外伤风险的儿科头部外伤患者,三级儿科医院的二次判读可能有助于发现初诊遗漏的骨折和硬膜下出血。
  • 二次判读较初诊判读更常提示虐待性颅脑外伤可能(P=0.0001)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Pediatric head trauma, including abusive head trauma, is a significant cause of morbidity and mortality.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this research was to identify and evaluate radiologic interpretation errors of head CTs performed on abusive and non-abusive pediatric head trauma patients from a community setting referred for a secondary interpretation at a tertiary pediatric hospital.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective search identified 184 patients <5 years of age with head CT for known or potential head trauma who had a primary interpretation performed at a referring community hospital by a board-certified radiologist. Two board-certified fellowship-trained neuroradiologists at an academic pediatric hospital independently interpreted the head CTs, compared their interpretations to determine inter-reader discrepancy rates, and resolved discrepancies to establish a consensus second interpretation. The primary interpretation was compared to the consensus second interpretation using the RADPEER™ scoring system to determine the primary interpretation-second interpretation overall and major discrepancy rates. MRI and/or surgical findings were used to validate the primary interpretation or second interpretation when possible. The diagnosis of abusive head trauma was made using clinical and imaging data by a child abuse specialist to separate patients into abusive head trauma and non-abusive head trauma groups. Discrepancy rates were compared for both groups. Lastly, primary interpretations and second interpretations were evaluated for discussion of imaging findings concerning for abusive head trauma.

RESULTS: There were statistically significant differences between primary interpretation-second interpretation versus inter-reader overall and major discrepancy rates (28% vs. 6%, P=0.0001; 16% vs. 1%, P=0.0001). There were significant differences in the primary interpretation-second interpretation overall and major discrepancy rates for abusive head trauma patients compared to non-abusive head trauma patients (41% vs 23%, P=0.02; 26% vs. 12%, P=0.03). The most common findings resulting in major radiologic interpretation errors were fractures and subdural hemorrhage. Differences in the age of the patient and the percentage of patients with hemorrhage were statistically significant between the abusive head trauma versus non-abusive head trauma groups, while no statistical difference was identified for skull fractures, ischemia, head CT radiation dose, or presence of multiplanar or 3-D reformatted images. The second interpretation more frequently indicated potential for abusive head trauma compared to the primary interpretation (P=0.0001). MRI and/or surgical findings were in agreement with the second interpretation in 29/29 (100%) of patients with discrepancies.

CONCLUSION: A high incidence of radiologic interpretation errors may occur in pediatric trauma patients at risk for abusive head trauma who are referred from a community hospital. This suggests value for second interpretations of head CTs at a tertiary pediatric hospital for this patient population.

来源:Pediatr Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kralik SF, Finke W, Wu IC, et al. Radiologic head CT interpretation errors in pediatric abusive and non-abusive head trauma patients. Pediatr Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28497263. doi:10.1007/s00247-017-3872-3

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。