盂肱关节盲穿注射真的不如影像引导注射准确吗:考虑多种解剖入路的叙述性系统评价
该系统评价检索至2016年5月的多个数据库,纳入38项研究(2309例患者2690肩,195具尸体299肩),比较盲穿与影像引导盂肱关节注射的关节内准确率。影像引导注射总体准确率高于盲穿,但5篇盲穿研究(159肩)报告准确率高达100%。作者认为盲穿可作为成本效益替代方案,但需大型前瞻性随机研究验证。
要点
- 影像引导下盂肱关节注射的总体准确率高于盲穿注射。
- 5篇盲穿研究共159肩报告关节内准确率高达100%。
- 38项研究中盂肱关节注射总体准确率范围为42%至100%。
核心结论
- 文献综述证实影像引导盂肱关节注射总体准确率高于盲穿,但部分研究(包括较大样本量)显示盲穿准确率达100%,盲穿可作为成本效益替代方案,需大型前瞻性随机研究验证。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性系统评价,检索Scopus、MEDLINE、Cochrane CENTRAL和Embase截至2016年5月,最终纳入38项研究,包括2309例患者(2690肩)和195具尸体(299肩),以影像或手术解剖确认关节内针位为参考标准,采用AMSTAR工具评估方法学质量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 盂肱关节关节内注射总体准确率在38项研究中为42%至100%。
- 65%的文章使用了影像引导,影像引导注射总体准确率高于盲穿注射。
- 5篇盲穿研究(159肩)报告准确率高达100%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文结论认为盲穿盂肱关节注射可作为影像引导注射的成本效益替代方案,但需大型前瞻性随机研究验证。
局限性
- 原文结论指出需要大型前瞻性随机研究来验证盲穿作为成本效益替代方案的假设,并比较两种技术在最常见解剖入路中的成本效益。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To perform a systematic review to establish whether blind injections of the gleno-humeral (GHJ) joint may be an accurate alternative to injections performed imaging guidance, considering multiple anatomical approaches.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Our search strategy yielded 478 articles for Scopus, 815 articles for MEDLINE, 128 articles for Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials and 555 articles for Embase until May 2016. One hundred and sixty-seven abstracts were retrieved after duplicates removal. Two readers independently reviewed all the 1067 abstracts. They selected for the full-text analysis only the abstracts in which the accuracy of intra-articular position of the needle was confirmed on imaging (humans) or by a surgical dissection (cadavers). Thirty-eight studies were eventually selected for the full-text reading and data extraction. The selected studies included a total of 2309 patients (2690 shoulders) and 195 cadavers (299 shoulders). To objectively assess the methodological quality of the present systematic review, "Assessment of Multiple Systematic Review" (AMSTAR) tool was used.
RESULTS: The overall accuracy of the intra-articular injection in GHJ varied from 42 to 100% in the 38 selected studies. Imaging guidance was used in 65% of articles and the overall accuracy of guided GHJ injections was higher than blind injection. However, five articles in which blind injection the GHJ was used (159 shoulders) reported accuracy as high as 100%.
CONCLUSION: A comprehensive review of the literature confirms that guided injections of the GHJ have overall accuracy higher compared to blind injection. Nevertheless, in some studies, including a relatively large number of shoulders, blind injections have been proven to be 100% accurate. Hence, blind injections of GHJ could be proposed a cost-effective alternative to imaging-guided injection. A large prospective randomized study is needed to gauge this hypothesis and compare the cost-effectiveness of these two techniques for the most common anatomical approaches.
引用
- Simoni P, Grumolato M, Malaise O, et al. Are blind injections of gleno-humeral joint (GHJ) really less accurate imaging-guided injections? A narrative systematic review considering multiple anatomical approaches. Radiol Med. 2017. PMID: 28523634. doi:10.1007/s11547-017-0772-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。