神经放射科医师与非神经放射科医师在多发性硬化新病灶检测中的比较
本研究纳入2009至2011年间至少两次3T MR(含容积T2 FLAIR序列)的多发性硬化患者,以半自动辅助软件检测结果为参考标准,比较5名神经放射科医师与5名非神经放射科医师对159对比较(共318次检查)的报告准确性。神经放射科医师敏感度82%、阴性预测值89%、假阴性率18%,均优于非神经放射科医师的42%、64%、58%;两组阳性预测值均为100%。
要点
- 神经放射科医师检测新病灶的敏感度82%,非神经放射科医师为42%。
- 神经放射科医师阴性预测值89%、假阴性率18%,非神经放射科医师分别为64%、58%。
- 两组阳性预测值均为100%。
核心结论
- 神经放射科医师在多发性硬化随访MR阅片中检测到的新病灶多于非神经放射科医师;辅助软件对两类医师均有帮助,对非神经放射科医师帮助更大。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入2009至2011年间至少两次3T MR(含容积T2 FLAIR序列)的多发性硬化患者,由5名神经放射科医师和5名非神经放射科医师报告全部检查,以既往半自动辅助软件检测结果为参考标准。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 神经放射科医师敏感度82%,非神经放射科医师敏感度42%。
- 神经放射科医师阴性预测值89%,非神经放射科医师阴性预测值64%。
- 神经放射科医师假阴性率18%,非神经放射科医师假阴性率58%。
- 两组阳性预测值均为100%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Multiple sclerosis monitoring is based on the detection of new lesions on brain MR imaging. Outside of study populations, MS imaging studies are reported by radiologists with varying expertise. The aim of this study was to investigate the accuracy of MS reporting performed by neuroradiologists (someone who had spent at least 1 year in neuroradiology subspecialty training) versus non-neuroradiologists.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Patients with ≥2 MS studies with 3T MR imaging that included a volumetric T2 FLAIR sequence performed between 2009 and 2011 inclusive were recruited into this study. The reports for these studies were analyzed for lesions detected, which were categorized as either progressed or stable. The results from a previous study using a semiautomated assistive software for lesion detection were used as the reference standard.
RESULTS: There were 5 neuroradiologists and 5 non-neuroradiologists who reported all studies. In total, 159 comparison pairs (ie, 318 studies) met the selection criteria. Of these, 96 (60.4%) were reported by a neuroradiologist. Neuroradiologists had higher sensitivity (82% versus 42%), higher negative predictive value (89% versus 64%), and lower false-negative rate (18% versus 58%) compared with non-neuroradiologists. Both groups had a 100% positive predictive value.
CONCLUSIONS: Neuroradiologists detect more new lesions than non-neuroradiologists in reading MR imaging for follow-up of MS. Assistive software that aids in the identification of new lesions has a beneficial effect for both neuroradiologists and non-neuroradiologists, though the effect is more profound in the non-neuroradiologist group.
引用
- Wang W, van Heerden J, Tacey MA, et al. Neuroradiologists Compared with Non-Neuroradiologists in the Detection of New Multiple Sclerosis Plaques. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2017. PMID: 28473341. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A5185
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。