一项前瞻性随机研究:依据操作者经验比较三种透视引导下肩关节造影入路
该前瞻性随机研究比较经前路、后路盂肱关节及肩袖间隙三种透视引导下肩关节造影入路,最终评估98例患者,由住院医师或专科培训医师操作;前路成功率100%,后路90.0%,肩袖间隙88.2%(p=0.013),后路透视时间最长(均值95.44秒),肩袖间隙最短(均值31.57秒,p=0.006)。结论认为后路或肩袖间隙入路对受训者可能较困难,后路可能需要较长透视时间。
要点
- 前路盂肱关节入路成功率100%(34/34),高于后路90.0%(23/30)和肩袖间隙88.2%(30/34),p=0.013。
- 后路盂肱关节入路透视时间最长(均值95.44秒),肩袖间隙入路最短(均值31.57秒),p=0.006。
- 成功率按操作者经验未见差异;第1或第2年住院医师的辐射剂量更大(p=0.014),三种入路间无差异。
核心结论
- 透视引导下肩关节造影经后路盂肱关节或肩袖间隙入路对受训者可能较困难,后路盂肱关节入路可能需要较长透视时间。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机研究,原设计每种入路34例,最终评估2014年7月至12月98例患者(平均年龄51.5岁;55例男性),前路盂肱关节入路n=41、后路盂肱关节入路n=27、肩袖间隙入路n=30,由住院医师(n=76)或专科培训医师(n=22)操作。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 前路盂肱关节入路成功率100%(34/34),后路盂肱关节入路90.0%(23/30),肩袖间隙入路88.2%(30/34),p=0.013。
- 后路盂肱关节入路透视时间最长(均值95.44秒),肩袖间隙入路最短(均值31.57秒),p=0.006。
- 第1或第2年住院医师的辐射剂量更大(p=0.014),三种入路间辐射剂量无差异。
- 仅1例经后路盂肱关节入路行造影的患者主诉术后疼痛。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为后路盂肱关节或肩袖间隙入路对受训者可能较困难,后路盂肱关节入路可能需要较长透视时间。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare three approaches via the anterior and posterior glenohumeral joints, and the rotator interval in fluoroscopy-guided shoulder arthrography according to the experience of the practitioners.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This prospective randomized study was originally designed to have 34 subjects for each approach, and finally evaluated 98 patients (mean age: 51.5 years; 55 men) from July to December 2014, who had shoulder arthrography via the anterior (n = 41) or posterior glenohumeral joint (n = 27) approaches, or via the rotator interval approach (n = 30) by residents (n=76) or fellows (n=22). The success rate, number of punctures, fluoroscopy time, radiation dose, and complications of the three methods were compared, and according to the practitioners.
RESULTS: The success rate was 100% for the anterior glenohumeral joint approach (34 out of 34), 90.0% for the posterior glenohumeral joint approach (23 out of 30), and 88.2% for the rotator interval approach (30 out of 34; p = 0.013). There was no difference in the success rate according to the practitioners' experience. Fluoroscopy time was longest for the posterior glenohumeral joint approach (mean: 95.44 s) and shortest for the rotator interval approach (mean: 31.57 s, p = 0.006). Radiation dose was larger by 1st- or 2nd-year residents (p = 0.014), with no difference among the three approaches. Only one patient who underwent arthrography using the posterior glenohumeral joint approach complained about post-procedural pain.
CONCLUSION: Fluoroscopy-guided shoulder arthrography via the posterior glenohumeral joint or rotator interval approach may be difficult for trainees, and the posterior glenohumeral joint approach may need a long fluoroscopy time.
引用
- Lee GY, Lee JW, Lee E, et al. A prospective randomized study comparing three different approaches to fluoroscopy-guided shoulder arthrography according to the experience of practitioners. Skeletal Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28365852. doi:10.1007/s00256-017-2637-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。