同步多层加速涡轮自旋回波磁共振成像:与平面内并行成像加速的对比及联合用于膝关节高分辨率磁共振成像
前瞻性研究对14例膝关节在3T磁共振上比较并行采集技术(PAT)与同步多层(SMS)加速及其组合的信噪比和对比噪声比,并比较两种4倍加速(PAT2-SMS2)高分辨率TSE方案与临床2倍加速(PAT2-SMS1)标准。结果显示SMS较PAT显著提高信噪比和对比噪声比,PAT2-SMS2与PAT2-SMS1定量和定性图像质量相似,且采集时间缩短约50%。
要点
- SMS加速较PAT加速显著提高信噪比和对比噪声比。
- 4倍加速PAT2-SMS2与2倍加速PAT2-SMS1的定量和定性图像质量相似。
- PAT2-SMS2联合加速使采集时间较常规PAT2加速缩短约50%。
核心结论
- SMS较PAT具有信号保留能力,使4倍PAT2-SMS2与2倍PAT2-SMS1加速获得相似的信噪比和对比噪声比;PAT2与SMS2联合的4倍加速TSE使采集时间较常规PAT2加速缩短约50%,定量和定性图像质量相似,有望提高膝关节临床二维磁共振成像效率。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入14例膝关节磁共振检查(8男、6女,平均年龄46岁,年龄范围28-62岁),使用3T磁共振系统和可联合PAT与SMS加速的TSE脉冲序列原型;定量分析采用差值法计算6种TSE加速方案(PAT2-SMS1、PAT3-SMS1、PAT1-SMS2、PAT1-SMS3、PAT2-SMS2、PAT2-SMS3)的信噪比和对比噪声比,定性分析比较PAT2-SMS1与PAT2-SMS2及更快的PAT2-SMS2 SPEED方案,由2名读者采用等距5点Likert量表评分,并记录软骨缺损、半月板撕裂、肌腱和韧带撕裂及骨髓水肿表现;采用Friedman和Kruskal-Wallis检验,P值小于0.01认为有统计学意义。
关键影像表现/征象
- PAT2-SMS1上液体信号最亮,PAT2-SMS1与PAT2-SMS2的噪声、边缘锐利度、对比分辨率和脂肪抑制相似,PAT2-SMS2 SPEED上述指标轻度 inferior。
- 关节软骨在PAT2-SMS1上评分轻度更高,半月板可见度在PAT2-SMS2 SPEED上轻度 inferior。
- 观察者偏好度在PAT2-SMS1与PAT2-SMS2上均较高,在更快的PAT2-SMS2 SPEED图像上轻度 inferior。
- 两名读者在所有序列上均见4处软骨缺损和2处半月板撕裂。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 定量分析采用差值法计算6种TSE加速方案的信噪比和对比噪声比;SMS的信噪比和对比噪声比均值显著高于PAT,PAT2-SMS2与PAT2-SMS1相似。
- 定性分析采用等距5点Likert量表评分图像质量、结构可见度和总体观察者满意度;统计学检验P值小于0.01认为有统计学意义。
- 所有采集的全身比吸收率范围为1.4至3.9 W/kg,均保持在规定限值内。
临床应用与阅片要点
- PAT2-SMS2联合加速可在与PAT2-SMS1相似的定量和定性图像质量下将采集时间缩短约50%,有望提高膝关节临床二维磁共振成像效率。
- PAT2-SMS2 SPEED方案图像质量轻度 inferior,液体信号最亮见于PAT2-SMS1。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: We prospectively quantified the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) of integrated parallel acquisition technique (PAT) and simultaneous multislice (SMS) acceleration and various combinations thereof, and we further compared two 4-fold-accelerated (PAT2-SMS2) high-resolution turbo spin echo (TSE) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) protocols of the knee against a clinical 2-fold-accelerated (PAT2-SMS1) TSE standard.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Institutional review board approval was obtained, and all subjects gave informed consent. Fourteen knee MRI examinations were obtained (8 men, 6 women; mean age, 46 years; age range, 28-62 years) using a 3 T MRI system and a TSE pulse sequence prototype that allowed for the combination of PAT and SMS acceleration. Predicted whole-body specific absorption rates were recorded for all pulse sequences. For quantitative analysis, the difference method was used to calculate SNR and CNR analysis of 6 different TSE acceleration schemes (PAT2-SMS1, PAT3-SMS1, PAT1-SMS2, PAT1-SMS3, PAT2-SMS2, and PAT2-SMS3). For qualitative analysis, sagittal intermediate-weighted and axial fat-suppressed T2-weighted MR images were obtained with PAT2-SMS1 and PAT2-SMS2 acceleration schemes using similar parameters. One faster PAT2-SMS2 acceleration scheme with decreased repetition time and longer echo train was labeled with the addition SPEED for the purpose of this report. Two readers rated the data sets for image quality, structural visibility, and overall observer satisfaction using equidistant 5-point Likert scales. Readers additionally noted the presence of cartilage defects, meniscal tears, tendons and ligament tears, and bone marrow edema pattern. Friedman and Kruskal-Wallis tests were used. P values of less than 0.01 were considered significant.
RESULTS: All pulse sequences were successfully executed and reconstructed inline. Whole-body specific absorption rates ranged between 1.4 and 3.9 W/kg for all acquisitions and remained within mandated limits. Quantitatively, mean SNR and CNR were significantly higher for SMS than those for PAT and similar for PAT2-SMS2 and PAT2-SMS1. Fluid was brightest on PAT2-SMS1, whereas noise, edge sharpness, contrast resolution, and fat suppression were similar on PAT2-SMS1 and SMS2-PAT2 and mildly inferior on PAT2-SMS2 SPEED. Articular cartilage received mildly higher ratings on PAT2-SMS1, whereas visibility of menisci was mildly inferior on PAT2-SMS2 SPEED. Observer preferences were similarly high for PAT2-SMS1 and PAT2-SMS2 and mildly inferior for the faster PAT2-SMS2 SPEED images. Four cartilage defects and 2 meniscal tears were seen by both readers on all sequences.
CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate the signal preservation capabilities of SMS over PAT acceleration, which allow for similar SNR and CNR of 4-fold PAT2-SMS2 and 2-fold PAT2-SMS1 acceleration. Four-fold-accelerated TSE through the combination of PAT2 and SMS2 enables approximately 50% shorter acquisition times compared with regular PAT2 acceleration, similar quantitative and qualitative image quality, and holds promise for a meaningful increase of the efficiency of clinical 2-dimensional MRI of the knee.
引用
- Fritz J, Fritz B, Zhang J, et al. Simultaneous Multislice Accelerated Turbo Spin Echo Magnetic Resonance Imaging: Comparison and Combination With In-Plane Parallel Imaging Acceleration for High-Resolution Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the Knee. Invest Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28430716. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000000376
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。