肘部尺侧副韧带超声评估:哪种方法最具可重复性
研究纳入50名志愿者,由两名肌骨放射科医师用Nazarian法、Jacobson/Ward(JW)法及改良JW法测量肘部尺侧副韧带厚度。Nazarian法组内相关系数(ICC)为0.82,JW法为0.51,改良JW法为0.84;Nazarian法测得平均厚度6.41 mm,JW法1.86 mm,改良法1.38 mm。三种方法均可重复,JW法观察者间一致性低于Nazarian法,改良JW法可重复性优于JW法且与Nazarian法相似。
要点
- Nazarian法测量尺侧副韧带厚度ICC为0.82,可重复性「很好」。
- JW法ICC为0.51,观察者间一致性「中等」,低于Nazarian法。
- 改良JW法ICC为0.84,可重复性优于JW法且与Nazarian法相似。
核心结论
- 超声评估尺侧副韧带厚度的三种测量方法均可重复;JW法观察者间一致性低于Nazarian法,改良JW法可重复性优于JW法且与Nazarian法相似。
研究设计与样本
- 采用超声测量50名志愿者的尺侧副韧带厚度,由两名肌骨放射科医师分别使用Nazarian法、Jacobson/Ward(JW)法及改良JW法(28名受试者)进行测量,以组内相关系数(ICC)评估各方法可重复性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- Nazarian法测量尺侧副韧带厚度的ICC为0.82(「很好」)。
- JW法测量尺侧副韧带厚度的ICC为0.51(「中等」)。
- 改良JW法(垂直于韧带而非成像框架测量)的ICC为0.84(「很好」)。
- Nazarian法测得平均韧带厚度为6.41 mm,JW法为1.86 mm,改良JW法为1.38 mm。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: The ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) is an important medial stabilizer of the elbow, particularly in overhead-throwing athletes. However, there is no universally accepted method for evaluating UCL thickness with ultrasound (US).
OBJECTIVE: To assess reproducibility of previously published methods, as well as a modified technique, for evaluating the UCL via US. We hypothesize that a modified technique would show greater reproducibility.
MATERIAL AND METHODS: Using US, the thickness of the UCL in 50 volunteers was measured by two musculoskeletal trained radiologists using two different measurement techniques. The techniques utilized were as described by Nazarian and Jacobson/Ward (JW). Technique measurements were evaluated using interclass correlation coefficients (ICC) to determine the reproducibility of each method. Twenty-eight of the subjects also underwent measurement via a modified JW technique, measured perpendicular to the ligament rather than the frame of imaging. This technique was also evaluated with ICC values.
RESULTS: The ICC value for the Nazarian technique was 0.82 (very good) and 0.51 (moderate) for the JW technique. When using the modified JW technique, we found an ICC value of 0.84 (very good). Mean ligament thickness was greatest with the Nazarian technique, 6.41 mm, with the JW technique measuring 1.86 mm and the modified technique measuring 1.38 mm.
CONCLUSION: US assessment of UCL thickness by all three measurement techniques are reproducible. The JW technique had less interobserver agreement when compared to the Nazarian method, whereas the modified JW technique had greater reproducibility compared to the JW technique and similar to the Nazarian technique.
引用
- Shukla M, Keller R, Marshall N, et al. Ultrasound evaluation of the ulnar collateral ligament of the elbow: Which method is most reproducible? Skeletal Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28424849. doi:10.1007/s00256-017-2656-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。