升级与未升级BI-RADS 3病变的观察者间变异性
回顾性分析2004至2008年1188个筛查发现的BI-RADS 3病变,其中60个(5.1%)在监测中升级为BI-RADS 4/5,按病变类型、侧别和年份匹配60个未升级对照。两位放射科医生盲法独立评估82个可获取的研究,发现BI-RADS 3病变评估的观察者间变异性很大,许多BI-RADS 3病变在盲法复核时被评为评估不完整。
要点
- BI-RADS 3病变的盲法复核显示观察者间评估变异性大。
- 部分BI-RADS 3病变在盲法复核时被评为评估不完整。
- 升级病变的初始评估适当性需结合盲法复核结果判断。
核心结论
- BI-RADS 3病变的评估存在很大的观察者间变异性,许多BI-RADS 3病变在盲法复核时被评为评估不完整。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,分析2004年1月1日至2008年12月31日乳腺X线摄影数据库,识别1188个筛查发现的BI-RADS 3病变,其中60个(5.1%)在监测中升级为BI-RADS 4/5作为病例,按病变类型、侧别和年份匹配60个未升级BI-RADS 3病变作为对照;两位放射科医生盲法独立评估可获取的研究。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 读者1将18/82(22%)评估为BI-RADS 0(病例13个,对照5个)。
- 读者1将35/82(42.7%)评估为BI-RADS 2(病例11个,对照24个)。
- 读者1将7/82(8.5%)评估为BI-RADS 3(病例4个,对照3个)。
- 读者1将22/82评估为BI-RADS 4(病例15个,对照7个)。
- 读者2将8/82(9.8%)评估为BI-RADS 0(病例4个,对照4个)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To evaluate interobserver variability in the assessment of Breast Imaging-Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS) 3 mammographic lesions, and to determine if the initial evaluation of upgraded BI-RADS 3 lesions was appropriate.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective review of the mammography database (1/1/2004-12/31/2008) identified 1,188 screen-detected BI-RADS 3 lesions, 60 (5.1%) were upgraded to BI-RADS 4/5 during surveillance (cases). Cases were matched to 60 non-upgraded BI-RADS 3 lesions (controls) by lesion type, laterality, and year. Available studies were assessed separately by two radiologists blinded to outcomes.
RESULTS: Eighty-two studies were available (43 cases, eight malignancies, and 39 controls). Reader 1 assessed 18/82 (22%) as BI-RADS 0, 13 cases, five controls; 35/82 (42.7%) as BI-RADS 2, 11 cases, 24 controls; 7/82 (8.5%) BI-RADS 3, four cases, three controls; 22/82 BI-RADS 4, 15 cases, seven controls. Reader 2 assessed 8/82 (9.8%) as BI-RADS 0, four cases, four controls; 27 (32.9%) BI-RADS 2, 11 cases, 16 controls; 33 (40.2%) BI-RADS 3, 19 cases, 14 controls; 14 (17%) BI-RADS 4, nine cases, five controls. For cancers, reader 1 assessed two BI-RADS 0, one BI-RADS 2, one BI-RADS 3, and four BI-RADS 4; reader 2 assessed two BI-RADS 2, four BI-RADS 3, and two BI-RADS 4. Reasons for BI-RADS 0 assessment included incomplete mammographic views, lack of ultrasound, and failure to include the lesion on follow-up imaging. Reasons for BI-RADS 4 assessment included suspicious morphology or instability.
CONCLUSION: There is much interobserver variability in the assessment of BI-RADS 3 lesions. Many BI-RADS 3 lesions were judged as incompletely evaluated on blinded review.
引用
- Michaels AY, Chung CSW, Frost EP, et al. Interobserver variability in upgraded and non-upgraded BI-RADS 3 lesions. Clin Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28381334. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2017.03.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。