数字断层摄影在肺结节检测中的优势:结节位置和大小的影响——体模研究
该体模研究将96个不同大小的实性模拟肺结节置入肺体模的8个区域,另设96例无结节对照,均行胸部X线摄影(CXR)、双能减影摄影(DES)和数字断层摄影(DTS),由3名观察者独立判读,采用jackknife替代自由响应受试者工作特征分析。结果显示,DTS对较小结节在肺尖、纵隔旁和肺外侧区域的检测优于CXR和DES,对较大结节在纵隔旁区域也优于CXR和DES;在膈后区域三种技术诊断性能相似。
要点
- DTS对5、8 mm结节在肺尖、纵隔旁和肺外侧区域的检测优于CXR和DES。
- 对10、12 mm结节,DTS在纵隔旁区域优于CXR和DES,在肺尖和肺外侧区域与CXR、DES相似。
- 在膈后区域,三种技术对不同大小结节的诊断性能相似。
核心结论
- 在胸部体模中,与CXR和DES相比,DTS显著提高了对肺尖、纵隔旁和肺外侧区域较小结节以及纵隔旁区域较大结节的检测能力。
研究设计与样本
- 体模研究,将96个不同大小的实性模拟肺结节置入肺体模的8个不同区域,另设96例无结节对照,所有病例均行CXR、DES和DTS检查,由3名观察者独立判读,采用jackknife替代自由响应受试者工作特征分析诊断性能。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To investigate the advantage of digital tomosynthesis (DTS) over chest radiography (CXR) and dual-energy subtraction radiography (DES) for pulmonary nodule detection according to the location and size of solid simulated pulmonary nodules (SPNs).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Ninety-six SPNs of variable sizes were inserted into eight different regions of a lung phantom. These regions were further classified into two groups of danger and non-danger zones based on anatomical location influencing the detection of pulmonary nodules. The 96 cases with inserted SPNs and an additional nodule-free 96 control cases all underwent CXR, DES, and DTS examinations. Three observers independently reviewed all the images. The jackknife alternative free-response receiver operating characteristic was used to analyse diagnostic performance for each technique.
RESULTS: DTS was superior to CXR and DES for detection of smaller SPNs, except in the retrodiaphragmatic and apical regions. DTS outperformed CXR and DES for detection of larger SPNs in the paramediastinal region. For 5- and 8-mm SPNs, DTS was superior to CXR and DES in the apical, paramediastinal and lateral pulmonary regions. In the retrodiaphragmatic region, the three techniques showed similar diagnostic performance regardless of the SPN size. DES was similar to DTS for detection of 8-mm SPN in the apical region. For 10- and 12-mm SPNs, CXR and DES showed similar diagnostic performance to DTS in the apical and lateral pulmonary regions; however, DTS was superior to CXR and DES in the paramediastinal region.
CONCLUSIONS: DTS significantly improved the capability to detect synthetic pulmonary nodules compared with CXR and DES, for detection of smaller nodules in the apical, paramediastinal, and lateral pulmonary regions, and larger nodules located in the paramediastinal region in a thoracic phantom.
引用
- Kim EY, Bista AB, Kim T, et al. The advantage of digital tomosynthesis for pulmonary nodule detection concerning influence of nodule location and size: a phantom study. Clin Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28454640. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2017.03.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。