数字乳腺断层摄影的阅片者表现是否随二维乳腺X线摄影经验而变化?
TOMMY试验纳入8869名女性,7060例回顾性盲法阅片,比较二维乳腺X线摄影与数字乳腺断层摄影(DBT)联合二维或合成二维的阅片者表现;DBT使所有阅片者特异度提高,敏感度提升在经验少于10年者更明显。
要点
- DBT联合二维或合成二维使所有阅片者特异度提高,放射科医生56% vs 68%(P < .0001)。
- 敏感度在24名阅片者中19名(79%)改善,经验少于10年者91% vs 86%(P = .03)。
- 年阅片量少于80000例者敏感度88% vs 86%(P = .03)。
核心结论
- 在常规二维筛查乳腺X线摄影基础上加用DBT提高了所有阅片者的特异度,但敏感度的提升在经验少于10年的阅片者中更大。
研究设计与样本
- TOMMY试验为经伦理批准的多中心、多阅片者、回顾性阅片研究,2011年7月至2013年3月招募8869名女性(年龄29-85岁,平均56岁),回顾性阅片数据集7060例,随机分配盲法独立阅片二维、DBT联合二维、合成二维联合DBT;24名阅片者(19名放射科医生、3名高级执业放射技师、2名乳腺临床医生)英国国家卫生服务乳腺筛查项目经验3-25年(中位10年),年阅片量5000-13000例(中位8000例)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 特异度:放射科医生二维56% vs DBT 68%(P < .0001);高级执业放射技师二维49% vs DBT 67%(P < .0001);乳腺临床医生二维46% vs DBT 55%(P = .02)。
- 敏感度:经验少于10年者DBT 91% vs 二维86%(P = .03);总乳腺X线阅片量少于80000例者DBT 88% vs 二维86%(P = .03)。
- 以中位经验10年为 cutoff 比较阅片者表现。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文结论为DBT联合二维筛查提高所有阅片者特异度,敏感度提升在经验少于10年者更大。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Purpose To assess whether individual reader performance with digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) and two-dimensional (2D) mammography varies with number of years of experience or volume of 2D mammograms read. Materials and Methods After written informed consent was obtained, 8869 women (age range, 29-85 years; mean age, 56 years) were recruited into the TOMMY trial (A Comparison of Tomosynthesis with Digital Mammography in the UK National Health Service Breast Screening Program), an ethically approved, multicenter, multireader, retrospective reading study, between July 2011 and March 2013. Each case was read prospectively for clinical assessment and to establish ground truth. A retrospective reading data set of 7060 cases was created and randomly allocated for independent blinded review of (a) 2D mammograms, (b) DBT images and 2D mammograms, and (c) synthetic 2D mammograms and DBT images, without access to previous examinations. Readers (19 radiologists, three advanced practitioner radiographers, and two breast clinicians) who had 3-25 (median, 10) years of experience in the U.K. National Health Service Breast Screening Program and read 5000-13 000 (median, 8000) cases per annum were included in this study. Specificity was analyzed according to reader type and years and volume of experience, and then both specificity and sensitivity were analyzed by matched inference. The median duration of experience (10 years) was used as the cutoff point for comparison of reader performance. Results Specificity improved with the addition of DBT for all readers. This was significant for all staff groups (56% vs 68% and 49% vs 67% [P < .0001] for radiologists and advanced practitioner radiographers, respectively; 46% vs 55% [P = .02] for breast clinicians). Sensitivity was improved for 19 of 24 (79%) readers and was significantly higher for those with less than 10 years of experience (91% vs 86%; P = .03) and those with total mammographic experience of fewer than 80 000 cases (88% vs 86%; P = .03). Conclusion The addition of DBT to conventional 2D screening mammography improved specificity for all readers, but the gain in sensitivity was greater for readers with less than 10 years of experience.
引用
- Tucker L, Gilbert FJ, Astley SM, et al. Does Reader Performance with Digital Breast Tomosynthesis Vary according to Experience with Two-dimensional Mammography? Radiology. 2017. PMID: 28287917. doi:10.1148/radiol.2017151936
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。