文献速递腹部技术与安全CT

三种软件包在肝脏与脾脏分割及体积测量中的对比评估

Comparative Evaluation of Three Software Packages for Liver and Spleen Segmentation and Volumetry.
PubMed 文献 · Acad Radiol · 2017-02-28

本研究比较了 Advantage Workstation Solutions、Claron Technology Liver Segmentor 与 Vitrea Core Fx 三种软件分割肝脏和脾脏的速度与准确性,数据集为 30 例患者门静脉期腹部 CT。结果显示两种自动软件包(Claron 和 Vitrea)在手动校正前测量的肝脏和脾脏体积准确且快速,肝脏体积较脾脏体积更准确,手动校正耗时且对多数受试者未显著改变体积测量。

要点

  • Claron 和 Vitrea 自动分割肝脏和脾脏体积准确且快速,手动校正前即可使用。
  • 肝脏体积测量较脾脏更准确,可能与脾脏体积远小于肝脏有关。
  • 手动校正耗时,且对多数受试者未显著改变体积测量结果。

核心结论

  • 两种自动软件包(Claron 和 Vitrea)在手动校正前测量的肝脏和脾脏体积准确且快速;肝脏体积较脾脏体积更准确,可能因脾脏体积远小于肝脏;手动校正耗时且对多数受试者未显著改变体积测量。

研究设计与样本

  • 对比研究,数据集为 30 例患者门静脉期腹部 CT 扫描,由两名放射科医生分别使用三种软件包(AWS、Claron、Vitrea)分割肝脏和脾脏,以 AWS 上完全手动分割的体积作为准确性参考标准。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 肝脏最终平均分割时间:读者1 AWS 6.5 分钟、Claron 4.4 分钟、Vitrea 5.1 分钟;读者2 AWS 5.5 分钟、Claron 3.6 分钟、Vitrea 4.2 分钟。
  • 脾脏最终平均分割时间:读者1 AWS 2.7 分钟、Claron 2.1 分钟、Vitrea 1.8 分钟;读者2 AWS 2.1 分钟、Claron 1.4 分钟、Vitrea 1.2 分钟。
  • 自动肝脏分割体积与 AWS 体积的平均差异:Claron 为 2.5%-2.9%,Vitrea 为 4.9%-6.6%。
  • 自动脾脏分割体积与 AWS 体积的平均差异:Claron 为 5.0%-6.2%,Vitrea 为 10.6%-12.0%。
  • 初始与最终分割体积的平均差异范围:肝脏 -1.2% 至 0.4%,脾脏 -4.0% 至 9.8%。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • Claron 和 Vitrea 自动分割肝脏和脾脏体积准确且快速,可在手动校正前使用。
  • 手动校正耗时,且对多数受试者未显著改变体积测量结果。
  • 肝脏体积测量较脾脏更准确,脾脏体积测量可能因体积较小而准确性较低。

局限性

  • Claron 在读者1的 4 例受试者和读者2的 2 例受试者中未能分割脾脏。
  • 30 例患者中除 2 例外均有癌症诊断,14 例肝脏和 24 例脾脏报告为正常,其余肝脏和脾脏包含一个或多个异常。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: This study aims to compare the speed and accuracy of three different software packages in segmenting the liver and the spleen.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: The three software packages are Advantage Workstation Solutions (AWS), Claron Technology (Claron) Liver Segmentor, and Vitrea Core Fx (Vitrea). The dataset consisted of abdominal computed tomography scans of 30 patients obtained from the portal venous phase. All but two of the patients had a cancer diagnosis. The livers of 14 patients and the spleens of 24 patients were reported as normal; the remaining livers and spleens contained one or more abnormalities. The initial segmentation times and volumes were recorded in Claron and Vitrea as these created automatic segmentations. The total segmentation times and volumes following corrections were recorded. The livers and spleens were segmented separately by two radiologists who used all three packages. Accuracy was assessed by comparing volumes measured using fully manual segmentation on the AWS.

RESULTS: Claron could not segment the spleen in four subjects for the first reader and in two subjects for the second reader. The final mean segmentation times for the liver for both readers were 6.5 and 5.5 minutes for AWS, 4.4 and 3.6 minutes for Claron, and 5.1 and 4.2 minutes for Vitrea. The final mean segmentation times for the spleen were 2.7 and 2.1 minutes for AWS, 2.1 and 1.4 minutes for Claron, and 1.8 and 1.2 minutes for Vitrea. No statistically significant difference was found between the organ volumes measured by the two readers when using Vitrea. The mean differences between the initial and final segmentation volumes ranged from -1.2% to 0.4% for the liver and from -4.0% to 9.8% for the spleen. The mean differences between the automated liver segmentation volumes and the AWS volumes were 2.5%-2.9% for Claron and 4.9%-6.6% for Vitrea. The mean differences between the automated splenic segmentation volumes and the AWS volumes were 5.0%-6.2% for Claron and 10.6%-12.0% for Vitrea.

CONCLUSIONS: Both automated packages (Claron and Vitrea) measured liver and spleen volumes that were accurate and quick before manual correction. Volumes for the liver were more accurate than those for the spleen, perhaps due to the much smaller splenic volumes compared to those of the liver. For both liver and spleen, manual corrections were time consuming and for most subjects did not significantly change the volume measurement.

来源:Acad Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Pattanayak P, Turkbey EB, Summers RM, et al. Comparative Evaluation of Three Software Packages for Liver and Spleen Segmentation and Volumetry. Acad Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28258903. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2017.02.001

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。