左心室与右心室整体及区域磁共振特征追踪衍生应变参数在观察者内与观察者间的可重复性
研究回顾性分析20名健康人与20例急性心肌炎患者的电影序列,用TOMTEC特征追踪软件测量双心室整体及区域应变与应变率。结果显示整体纵向与环向参数可重复性好至优秀,径向应变与应变率参数可重复性差,作者建议临床研究中慎用径向参数。
要点
- 整体纵向与环向应变及应变率可重复性好至优秀,径向参数可重复性差。
- 区域层面基底段与中间段参数比心尖段参数可重复性更好。
- 作者建议临床研究中慎用径向应变与应变率参数。
核心结论
- 使用TOMTEC算法的CMR特征追踪在健康与疾病状态下对左心室和右心室整体及区域层面均高度可重复,例外是径向应变与应变率参数,作者建议临床研究中慎用。
- 基于本研究估算的样本量可作为未来特征追踪研究设计时的参考。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析20名健康个体与20例急性心肌炎患者的CMR电影序列。
- 采用三个水平长轴视图与覆盖整个左心室和右心室的短轴视图堆栈。
- 使用专用特征追踪软件算法(TOMTEC)进行分析。
- 观察者内分析由一名观察者对所有患者与志愿者的CMR图像分析两次。
- 观察者间分析由另外三名盲法观察者对相同数据集各分析一次。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 观察者内左心室整体应变与应变率参数ICC范围为0.81-1.00,仅整体径向应变率可重复性差(ICC 0.23)。
- 观察者间所有左心室整体与区域纵向及环向应变和应变率参数ICC范围为0.66-0.93。
- 右心室整体纵向与环向应变及应变率参数ICC范围为0.75-0.97。
- 区域层面基底段与中间段应变及应变率参数比心尖段参数可重复性更好。
- 左心室与右心室径向应变及应变率参数较环向或纵向参数可重复性更差。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 日常阅片与报告测量双心室应变时,整体与区域纵向及环向参数可重复性较好。
- 径向应变与应变率参数可重复性差,作者建议临床研究中慎用。
- 区域测量时基底段与中间段参数较心尖段更稳定。
- 本文估算的样本量可作为未来特征追踪研究设计时的参考。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the reproducibility of regional and global strain and strain rate (SR) parameters of both ventricles and to determine sample sizes for all investigated strain and SR parameters in order to generate a practical reference for future studies.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The study population consisted of 20 healthy individuals and 20 patients with acute myocarditis. Cine sequences in three horizontal long axis views and a stack of short axis views covering the entire left and right ventricle (LV, RV) were retrospectively analysed using a dedicated feature tracking (FT) software algorithm (TOMTEC). For intra-observer analysis, one observer analysed CMR images of all patients and volunteers twice. For inter-observer analysis, three additional blinded observers analysed the same datasets once. Intra- and inter-observer reproducibility were tested in all patients and controls using Bland-Altman analyses, intra-class correlation coefficients (ICCs) and coefficients of variation.
RESULTS: Intra-observer reproducibility of global LV strain and SR parameters was excellent (range of ICCs: 0.81-1.00), the only exception being global radial SR with a poor reproducibility (ICC 0.23). On a regional level, basal and midventricular strain and SR parameters were more reproducible when compared to apical parameters. Inter-observer reproducibility of all LV parameters was slightly lower than intra-observer reproducibility, yet still good to excellent for all global and regional longitudinal and circumferential strain and SR parameters (range of ICCs: 0.66-0.93). Similar to the LV, all global RV longitudinal and circumferential strain and SR parameters showed an excellent reproducibility, (range of ICCs: 0.75-0.97). Radial strain and SR parameters were less reproducible in the LV as well as in the RV when compared to circumferential or longitudinal parameters.
CONCLUSION: CMR FT using the TOMTEC algorithm is highly reproducible in health and disease in both, the LV and RV on a global and regional level. The only exceptions are radial strain and SR parameters, which should be used with caution within clinical studies. The sample sizes estimated on the basis of the present study might serve as a reference during the planning of future FT studies.
引用
- Schmidt B, Dick A, Treutlein M, et al. Intra- and inter-observer reproducibility of global and regional magnetic resonance feature tracking derived strain parameters of the left and right ventricle. Eur J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28267556. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2017.01.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。